1

Credit: Instagram, Bravo

Madison LeCroy believes she knows why Sienna Evans was ultimately “turned off” by Shep Rose.

Following a series of awkward Southern Charm episodes, in which Shep, 44, was seen clamouring for the admiration of Sienna, 26, who seemed disintersted, at the least, Madison, 34, shared her thoughts on Sienna’s true feelings for her castmate as Molly O’Connell, 37, revealed she had an NFL boyfriend and Rodrigo “Rod” Reyes, 40, joked that the model “pulled a Shep on Shep.”

“[Shep] buys [Sienna] a necklace at the shop we were at. It was a cute necklace; it was very nice,” Molly recalled on the March 6 episode of the Southern Charm: After Show, noting that it was “a little awkward” to hear that Shep had previously purchased the “same f*cking necklace” for his ex-girlfriend, Taylor Ann Green, 30.

But after Austen Kroll, 37, asked Shep, “Didn’t you give the same one to Taylor?,” Shep denied it.

“That was like a huge thing, Shep. We were all talking about it. Taylor was like, ‘You gave that to me two years ago.’ You gave the exact same necklace to her that you gave to Taylor,” Austen insisted.

Also looking back, Taylor said the “only piece of jewelry” Shep ever gave her was a shark tooth necklace from Foxy Fossils, which is where Shep purchased the necklace he gave Sienna. However, she pointed out that Shep got her the great white shark tooth and Sienna the megalodon tooth.

“But what’s funny is that there’s a picture of me modeling the megalodon that she’s wearing,” she added.

Elsewhere, Madison and Craig Conover, 36, shaded Shep for being cheap.

“Can you imagine buying someone a shark tooth necklace when you could afford anything?” Craig asked. “He’s just cheap.”

“I would be offended,” Madison replied. “[She] thought it was going to be a Birkin bag.”

Madison also learned from Shep that Sienna wanted a home.

“He had made comments that like, she wanted a mansion and she wanted a house on the water and she wanted to fly first class and all these things and he was like, ‘No, I’m not doing that.’ So maybe that’s what turned her off,” she suspected.

And Craig seemed to agree, noting that Shep had told him that Sienna had been with “investors in South Africa” that were “way richer” than him and complained about a Denver Broncos player.

“These fans just came up to me and said he found them in a bar in Kansas City a couple of weeks ago, and, like, all he talked about was her. Because, like, the Broncos were on TV, and he was like, ‘Can you believe she left me for the Denver Broncos?’ And he was like showing them texts,” he shared.

Then, after Molly revealed that Sienna claimed she had “another boyfriend from the NFL on the back-burner,” Taylor said she, too, learned that Sienna was seeing someone after filming wrapped.

“She was seeing some football player,” Taylor revealed as Rod reasoned, “She pulled a Shep on Shep.”

Even Shep admitted that anyone could “figure this out,” as he mentioned that Sienna’s sister, Anissa Evans, had a child with Portland Trail Blazers player Deandre Ayton, 26.

“He makes $35 million a year, or $25 [million], whatever,” he explained.

“So you have fond memories, but you are wholeheartedly calling her a gold digger?” Austen wondered.

“I know what happened,” Shep responded. “If she was like, ‘I hacked his bank account, and there’s a few mil short of what I require?,’ that basically would have been as honest a thing that she could have said.”

Southern Charm season 10 airs Thursdays at 8/7c on Bravo.