Gino Palazzolo has come forward with what he claims is proof that 90 Day Fiancé: Happily Ever After? co-star and wife Jasmine Pineda cheated on him before they ever agreed to an open relationship. The couple, who originally met through a sugar baby website, first appeared on Before the 90 Days season 5. Two years later, Jasmine moved to the U.S. and married Gino. Since their wedding, Jasmine has accused Gino of being unfaithful, withholding intimacy, and controlling her finances. They are now set to return for Happily Ever After? season 9.

During their time on The Last Resort, Jasmine introduced a man named Matt Branis as her “friend,” and Gino eventually agreed to include Matt in their marriage. However, Gino is now alleging that Jasmine had a romantic relationship with Matt long before the show.

A screenshot of a Reddit post, shared on Instagram Stories by Gino, added fuel to the speculation. The post, originally made by a user named ocelot42069 and later deleted, detailed a personal account of seeing Jasmine frequently at a Planet Fitness in Michigan with another man believed to be her personal trainer. According to the poster, Jasmine and the man were “always making out.” That man, the fan later claimed, was Matt.

What the Alleged Cheating Means for Jasmine and Gino’s Relationship

Rumors about Jasmine and Matt had been circulating online since May 2024. However, the post and Gino’s reaction suggest that the relationship may have begun as early as November 2023. This means Jasmine could have been romantically involved with Matt before she and Gino ever discussed or agreed to an open marriage.

This timeline challenges Jasmine’s insistence that Matt was “just a friend” at the time. It also casts doubt on the sincerity of her attempt to repair the marriage with Gino. The upcoming season of 90 Day Fiancé: Happily Ever After? will reportedly feature Gino confronting Jasmine about the alleged infidelity and questioning the true nature of her relationship with Matt.

Our Take: Did Jasmine Use the Open Marriage to Hide an Affair?

In The Last Resort trailer, Jasmine denies cheating and blames Gino’s girlfriend, Natalie, for planting doubts in his mind. However, Gino’s suspicions appear to be based on multiple claims, including the fan’s post and Jasmine’s increasingly public relationship with Matt.

Reportedly, Jasmine became pregnant with Matt’s child around June 2024 and has since moved to Florida, where she now lives with her new family. On social media, she has repeatedly compared Matt to Gino, claiming he treats her better.

Although Jasmine insists she did not cheat, the timeline of events, fan accounts, and her evolving relationship with Matt suggest there may have been more to the story than what was originally shown. Season 9 may provide more clarity as viewers watch the drama unfold.