15-Year-Old Girl Sentenced in Death of Rival Cheerleader

A 15-year-old New York girl was sentenced Tuesday to 3 to 9 years for the stabbing death of a rival cheerleader last spring.

Kayla Green, sophomore captain of the Mount Vernon junior varsity cheerleading squad, was killed in April 2022 in a brawl that broke out during a parade celebrating the state championship won by the school’s boys’ basketball team, lohud.com reports.

The defendant, a member of an independent cheer squad that Green had once belonged to, was indicted on a charge of first-degree manslaughter and pleaded guilty in December.

Judge Susan Cacace said in court on Tuesday the attack on Green stemmed from “a long-standing rivalry between two cheerleading squads in the city of Mount Vernon,” according to WCBS.

Prosecutor James Bavero said the attack “was an intentional, senseless and vicious intentional crime, which has caused immeasurable pain.”

The 15-year-old tearfully read a statement accepting responsibility for her actions and apologizing, lohud reported.

“I am sorry my actions took away a big sister. I am sorry my actions took away a daughter,” the girl said.

“I think of all the different choices I could have made that day that would have left Kayla alive and saved her family this heartache,” she said. “But that is why everyone is here today, because I made bad choices.”

As a juvenile, the maximum sentence she could have received was 3 to 10 years, the district attorney’s office said. Cacace didn’t spell out why she knocked a year off the maximum but noted that the defendant, who had a history of violent conduct, is “thriving in detention, perhaps on a path to make something of her life.”

Green’s family, however, was not satisfied with either the sentence or the girl’s apology.

“Justice did not occur today. Mockery did,” Green’s mother, Lavern Gordon, said in court. “My family is broken and our heart will never mend from this loss of my daughter.”

“Her killer gets to get out in three years to live her life, to have family, to have a career. My daughter will never see that,” said Gordon, who had pushed for murder charges instead of manslaughter charges for the 15-year-old, according to WCBS.

Still, the defendant’s attorney, Michael Borrelli, said he hoped that “the healing process can begin for the victim’s family and for the community, most specifically for the city of Mount Vernon.”

In handing down the sentence, Cacace pointed to a hopeful sign, saying the defendant is “thriving in detention, perhaps on a path to make something of her life.”

The district attorney’s office said the teen will be held in a juvenile detention center until she turns 18, when she’ll be transferred to prison.

For the latest true crime and justice news, subscribe to the ‘Crime Stories with Nancy Grace’ podcast.

[Featured image: Kayla Green/Instagram]

You May Also Like

Jerrel Perez sues Shawn Guetschow, Kenosha over school fight

Kenosha police officer Shawn Guetschow is seen kneeling the neck of a…

Murdaugh Family Murders: Law Firm CFO Explains Alex’s $2.8M Fraud Scheme

On Tuesday, the chief financial officer of Alex Murdaugh’s former law firm…

Gabby Petito: Lawyers Release Photo Showing Bruised Face Minutes After Brian Laundrie Reportedly Slapped Her

Slain vlogger Gabby Petito took a photo minutes before someone called 911…

Illinois Woman Charged With Murder After Decomposed Remains Found in Storage Unit

An Illinois woman arrested last year for concealing a body in her…

Samantha Markle seeks Meghan Markle, Prince Harry deposition

Prince Harry The Duke of Sussex and Meghan Markle The Duchess of…

5 Jehovah’s Witnesses sexually abused kids: Prosecutor

Acting Attorney General Michelle Henry announcing the charges against five Jehovah’s Witnesses…

Patricia Ann Ricks charged with murdering granddaughter

Share copy link Patricia Ann Ricks (Nash County Sheriff’s Office) An 8-year-old…

Thomas Charles Kincheloe Faces New Child Sex Charges

Thomas Charles Kincheloe (Laclede County Jail) Authorities in Missouri have filed new…