7 Top Frozen Pizzas with Authentic Cheese, Not Imitation

Bad cheese can ruin a pizza entirely, whether it’s from a high-end restaurant or a simple frozen option you keep on hand for convenience. While many frozen pizzas use low-quality ingredients that may offend pizza enthusiasts, there is now a wide range of excellent choices available. If you want genuine cheese without fillers and additives on your pizza, consider the following selections: Here are seven frozen pizzas that feature real, delicious, melty, gooey cheese.

Home Run Inn Pizza

Home Run Inn Pizza is a fan favorite for good reason—it’s incredibly tasty and made with authentic whole milk mozzarella cheese. A Reddit user commented, “It’s one of the best frozen pizzas I’ve tried,” adding that the crust was “nice and crispy,” the sauce was “tasty with a hint of sweetness,” and the cheese had a “buttery taste.”

Screamin’ Sicilian

Screamin’ Sicilian pizza is adored for its use of low-moisture whole milk mozzarella cheese. A Target customer noted, “Excellent tasting pizza with perfect amounts of sauce, cheese, and pepperoni. I kid you not, it is way better than average delivery options and fancier restaurants. Totally worth it. Good price point. We purchased 3 times now and are always impressed.”

The #1 Order to Never Make at a Pizza Place, According to Chefs

Rao’s Brick Oven Pizza

Rao’s Brick Oven Pizza is another favorite in my house, and the cheese is especially delicious: We’re talking a blend of whole milk mozzarella, whole milk provolone, fontina, romano & Parmesan cheeses. “8/10 Cheese here is the star of the show,” one customer wrote in the reviews. “There is a lot of it, and you will notice the center bakes to a nice brown when finished. There is a unique sharpness to the cheese that I don’t find with most frozen pizzas.”6254a4d1642c605c54bf1cab17d50f1e

Newman’s Own

Newman’s Own Thin & Crispy Pizza is raved about by customers for quality and taste. This pizza is topped with low-moisture mozzarella cheese plus a blend of Cheddar, asiago, and Parmesan. “I’m not big on frozen pizza (or pizza in general), but I was very pleasantly surprised with this one! It tasted great and was way cheesier than I’d expected. Would definitely buy again!” one Target shopper said.

Tony’s Pizza

Tony’s Cheese Pizza is proof you don’t need to break the bank to have amazing pizza—this pizza is topped with real mozzarella. “If cheese is what you please, check out TONY’S® Pizza in the delicious cheese variety. It’s that authentic flavor you crave with crispy, crunchy crust, sauce from real tomatoes and real cheese,” the brand promises.

5 Pizza Chains People Say Have “Gone Downhill”

Kirkland Signature Cheese Pizza

Kirkland Signature Cheese Pizza is topped with a cheese blend of whole milk mozzarella, provolone, Parmesan, and Romano cheeses. “The cheese tastes real; a good amount of sauce and the pizza crust is thin. it tastes way less greasy than a Little Caesar’s but close to that kinda of thickness. Best to cook directly on the pan for extra crunch,” one Redditor said.

Katie’s Burrata Margherita Pizza

Katie’s Burrata Margherita Frozen Pizza is topped with real mozzarella and burrata cheese. “This is a great frozen wood fired pizza,” one customer shared. “After reading other reviews I opted to cook the pizza for an extra couple minutes and the results were perfection. It is more expensive than most but worth it to have a hand made, wood fired pizza made with quality ingredients.”