Federal Public Defender Sounds Alarm Over 'Unconstitutionally Overbroad' Warrants Against Jan. 6 Defendants

One of the most troubling things about the Biden regime has been the unequal application of the law we have seen. What has always made the U.S. special in the history of the world was not only its freedom but its rule of law. That’s why people came to us from troubled places all over the world, fleeing banana republics. Yet the Biden team seems to be intent on turning us into the banana republics that people have fled from.

We’ve seen the stark difference in the way that the Jan. 6 defendants have been treated versus the BLM or other leftist rioters. We’ve seen all kinds of tactics brought to bear when it comes to anything related to Jan. 6, whereas in a similar riot against the inauguration of President Donald Trump in Washington, D.C., on Jan. 20, 2017; most of those arrested had their charges dismissed.

One of the tactics raising concerns is the “geofence warrant” that I’ve previously written about.

There’s more from defense attorney Tara Fish, who takes it apart in her motion to suppress on behalf of defendant David Rhine. Fish argues first that the search was massively overbroad, first going through “millions of private accounts” to determine if any fit within the data of being in or near the Capitol. “The warrant was therefore unconstitutionally overbroad, a modern-day general warrant.” That’s a big problem because warrants have to be narrow and specific.

The warrant application didn’t set forth evidence that everyone present “at or near the Capitol Building was guilty of a crime.” Because it didn’t specify based on the person or the evidence of a crime, it guaranteed that it would sweep up people whose “crime” may only have been standing in the vicinity.

They “equated presence at the Capitol with criminal activity.”

That should concern everyone, on all sides of the political aisle. Journalist Michael Tracey snarked that because the “Jan 6 investigation is the most important in the history of human civilization or something, and Democracy™ as we know it hangs in the balance,” the powers that be think these precedent-setting violations of the Constitution should just be ignored. He also noted the evil people being pursued through these intense tactics include suspects like this couple, whose alleged crime appears to have been they went into the building and took a selfie.

Now, if they had been leftists just trespassing during a BLM riot, they probably wouldn’t even have been charged–much less hunted down with such tactics.

But it’s very easy to see how such a warrant can be abused to serve a government that wants to cut off protesters or dissent.

Trending on Redstate Video

You May Also Like
Pakistan blast: 59 dead, 150 wounded at Peshawar mosque after suicide bombing; TTP claims responsibility

Pakistan blast: 59 dead, 150 wounded at Peshawar mosque after suicide bombing; TTP claims responsibility

PESHAWAR, Pakistan — A suicide bomber struck a crowded mosque inside a…
Robin Roberts marks 10 years since lifesaving bone marrow transplant: How to become a donor with Be The Match

Robin Roberts marks 10 years since lifesaving bone marrow transplant: How to become a donor with Be The Match

Robin Roberts is no stranger to facing adversity. She received a breast…
Victim in beating at Dave & Buster's in Jacksonville has died

Victim in beating at Dave & Buster’s in Jacksonville has died

The man accused of beating Thony Roy to death had a violent…
Dee Tozer (pictured, centre), from Melbourne, who has more than 30 years experience, says of the 5,000 couples she's worked with nearly all of them had no interest in celebrating Valentine's Day

Couples therapist Dee Tozer: Why you should celebrate Valentine’s Day

The one VERY surprising features of ALL unhappy couples’ love-life: ‘They have…
Controversy surrounds Bishop Snyder High School baseball team after alleged racist comments surface

Controversy surrounds Bishop Snyder High School baseball team after alleged racist comments surface

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. – The Bishop John J. Synder High School baseball team…
Bed Bath & Beyond to close 87 more stores

Bed Bath & Beyond to close 87 more stores

Bed Bath & Beyond warns of potential bankruptcy Bed Bath & Beyond…
9 people hurt in Lakeland shooting, police say

9 people hurt in Lakeland shooting, police say

LAKELAND, Fla. — Two people suffered critical injuries during a shooting that…
An Alabama man was arrested during a welfare check. Two weeks later, he was dead.

An Alabama man was arrested during a welfare check. Two weeks later, he was dead.

WALKER COUNTY, Ala. (WIAT) — His family thought jail may be the…