Supreme Court limits nationwide injunctions in birthright citizenship case
Share and Follow


WASHINGTON () The U.S. Supreme Court has granted President Donald Trump’s request to temporarily halt nationwide injunctions from district courts on birthright citizenship.

The 6-3 ruling found that universal injunctions “likely exceed the equitable authority that Congress has granted to federal courts.

The Supreme Court did not decide on whether Trump’s executive order to restrict birthright citizenship is constitutional.

Instead, it instructed district courts to “move expeditiously to ensure that, with respect to each plaintiff, the injunctions comport with this rule and otherwise comply with principles of equity.”

Trump’s January executive order would affect thousands of babies born each year in the United States. Federal judges in Maryland, Washington and Massachusetts blocked the order, finding it likely violates the Constitution’s 14th Amendment citizenship language. The administration is seeking to broadly enforce the directive.

The history of birthright citizenship in the US

That exception has traditionally been interpreted to exclude foreign diplomats’ children, foreign enemies in hostile occupation or Native American children subject to tribal laws. But some say the children of noncitizens fall under that umbrella, too.

The 14th Amendment reads: “All persons born or naturalized in the United States and subject to the jurisdiction thereof are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside.” It didn’t, however, always apply to everyone. It wasn’t until 1924, for example, that Congress granted citizenship to all Native Americans born in the U.S.

Proponents of Trump’s plan zeroed in on the qualification that narrows birthright citizenship to children born in the U.S. who are “subject to the jurisdiction thereof.”

The justices heard arguments in the Trump administration’s emergency appeals over lower court orders that kept the citizenship restrictions on hold across the country.

Birthright citizenship is among several issues, many related to immigration, that the administration had asked the court to address on an emergency basis.

During arguments, the court’s liberal justices seemed firmly in support of the lower court rulings that found the changes to citizenship that Trump wants to make would upset the settled understanding of birthright citizenship that has existed for more than 125 years.

What has Trump said about birthright citizenship?

Trump has said for years that he wants to end birthright citizenship.

“It’s ridiculous. We are the only country in the world that does this with the birthright, as you know, and it’s just absolutely ridiculous,” he said in January. Dozens of countries, mostly in the Americas, have birthright citizenship.

Opponents say the practice encourages people to come to the U.S. illegally so their children can have citizenship. Others argue that ending birthright citizenship would profoundly damage the country.

In 2019, the Migration Policy Institute estimated that 5.5 million children under age 18 lived with at least one parent in the country illegally in 2019, representing 7% of the U.S. child population. The vast majority of those children were U.S. citizens.

This story is developing.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Did he know the killer... or was HE the killer?

Facebook Idaho Murders: Was he acquainted with the killer, or was he the murderer himself?

Panic grips the quiet American town of Moscow and the University of…
Lucy Guo's advice to other billionaires: 'Act broke, stay rich'

Lucy Guo’s Tip for Fellow Billionaires: “Live Modestly to Keep Your Wealth”

At just 30 years old, tech entrepreneur Lucy Guo recently surpassed Taylor…
The REAL victims of the Coldplay Kiss cam scandal

The True People Affected by the Coldplay Kiss Cam Controversy

The CEO of Astronomer and the head of HR, whose romantic involvement…
Sia, 49, sparks romance rumours with unlikely reality star, 28

Sia, 49, Fuels Rumors of New Romance with Surprising 28-Year-Old Reality Star

Sia has sparked romance rumours with a very unlikely reality star as…
Warren Buffett's quiet moves send shockwaves through Wall Street

Warren Buffett’s Subtle Strategies Stir Up Wall Street Buzz

Famed investor Warren Buffett has quietly executed a series of multi-billion-dollar exits from…
Florida Representative Joe Casello dies while in office

Florida Legislator Joe Casello Passes Away During His Term

Casello was a firefighter in Worcester, Massachusetts, for three decades before entering…
Wrong-way crash on Hart Expressway leaves 1 dead, 1 injured

Fatal Wrong-Way Collision on Hart Expressway Results in One Death and One Injury

The Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office says this is the 89th traffic death in…
Sickening moment cop launches heinous attack on adorable animal

Shocking instance when officer commits cruel assault on innocent animal

A police officer in New Mexico caused fatal harm to a small…