Timeline to Aiden Fucci's trial for Tristyn Bailey's murder
Share and Follow


Since Fucci’s arrest, there’s been a maze of court filings, trial delays and the release of eerie evidence in the case.

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. — Aiden Fucci, the St. Johns County 16-year-old facing the possibility of life in prison for the murder of 13-year-old Tristyn Bailey, will stand trial starting Monday.

Jury selection will begin in the morning and is expected to last several days.

The case captured national attention in May 2021 as graphic, grizzly details of Tristyn’s murder became public. Police said the 13-year-old, who was the beloved youngest of her family and beloved as a cheerleader at her school, was stabbed 114 times. 

Her accused killer, Fucci, was 14 at the time she was killed; his age and his bizarre behavior following his arrest made headlines around the country. Particularly a Snapchat selfie he took from the back of a patrol car — asking if anybody “had seen Tristan.” 

As the State of Florida vs. Fucci is set to begin Monday, here is a timeline of the past year and nine months since Tristyn’s death.

For everything you need to know about this case, click here.  

  • Tristyn is last seen by her sister just after midnight
  • Tristyn is last picked up on surveillance footage just before 2 a.m.
  • Tristyn is reported missing at 10 a.m.
  • Tristyn’s body is found by a neighbor in the evening
  • Fucci appears in court for the first time, judge finds probable cause to charge him  with second-degree murder
  • Then-St. Johns County Sheriff Hardwick says Fucci is not cooperating and announces Tristan’s cause of death as stabbing
  • Aiden’s mother, Crystal Smith, turns herself in to authorities on tampering charges 
  • Later that day, Smith is released on bond
  • Crystal Smith, Aiden Fucci’s mother, pleads not guilty to tampering charges 
  • Snapchat images, surveillance videos released
  • Aiden appears unsettled, rambling in court appearance, says “I won’t let you demons take my soul,” leading to speculation about his mental health

The anniversary of Tristyn’s death, hundreds gather to honor her

  • New documents reveal that a friend of Fucci’s said in an interview that the murder was “100% premeditated” and “prompted by jealousy” 
  • Court filing shows that Fucci has refused to consent to polygraph test
  • First Coast News confirms a survey was sent to St. Johns County residents by Fucci’s attorneys 
  • Judge denies motion to move Aiden Fucci out of Duval County after attorneys claim “ongoing torture” 
  • Judge says Aiden Fucci is not entitled to a 12-person jury 
  • First Coast News obtains documents showing Fucci is extorting other inmates

Defense asks for another trial delay. This request is denied

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Columbia protests are 'writing on the wall,' about antisemitism on campuses: campus organization founder says

Founder of campus organization warns of rising antisemitism with protests at Columbia University

The founder of a pro-Israel international campus movement is warning against history…
Alaska law enforcement responds to World War II-era plane crash with 2 people on board

Alaska authorities attend to crash involving WWII-era plane carrying 2 individuals

A World War II-era plane crashed along a river near Fairbanks, Alaska,…
West Virginia hospital confirms first case of measles since 2009

“First Measles Case Reported in West Virginia Hospital in Over a Decade”

A West Virginia hospital has confirmed the first known case of measles…
Businesses in Jacksonville's San Marco area have windows smashed

Windows of businesses in San Marco, Jacksonville broken by vandals.

The owner of Missy Riley Art & Pieces, located at 1992 San…
4 Iranians indicted for alleged malicious multi-year cyber campaign targeting US government and defense firms

Four Iranians Charged for Alleged Long-Term Cyber Attack on US Government and Defense Companies

Four Iranian nationals were indicted Tuesday for allegedly being part of a…
Former officer accused of killing ex-wife and minor girlfriend, abducting son, shoots self

Ex-cop accused of murdering ex-wife and teenage girlfriend, taking son captive, commits suicide

This story discusses suicide. If you or someone you know is having…
2 former UN employees charged in conspiracy to sell military equipment in Libya

2 ex-UN workers accused of plot to sell weapons in Libya

Two former United Nations employees in Montreal have been charged with participating…