Photo of Carlethia Carlee Nichole Russell.
Share and Follow

An Alabama nursing student who faked her own kidnapping along the side of a highway over the summer has been convicted for misleading authorities, a verdict she plans to appeal.

A judge found Carlethia “Carlee” Nichole Russell guilty of false reporting to law enforcement and falsely reporting an incident, both misdemeanors, according to WBRC. She pleaded not guilty to both counts in Hoover Municipal Court on Wednesday. 

Will Carlee Russell get prison time?

The Alabama Attorney General’s Office recommended a total of a year in jail for the charges, as well as for her to pay nearly $18,000 in restitution for carrying out the July abduction hoax, and an additional $831 dollars in court fines.

On July 13, Russell, 25, vanished after dialing 911 to report a toddler was unattended along the side of I-459 in Hoover. For more than two days, police treated her disappearance as a missing persons case, which garnered national headlines. 

But 49 hours later, Russell turned up at her house on foot. She told investigators that she’d been taken from the side of the road by an unknown man who forced her into a semi-truck. The nursing student said her kidnapper later held her captive at a home where he made her strip naked. Russell also claimed she managed to escape but was caught again by her abductor. 

In the aftermath of her disappearance, Russell’s family corroborated her account on social media and spoke to various reporters defending her claims.

Police ultimately found her narrative not credible. At the time, investigators said Russell had acted “strange” and that she conducted suspicious internet searches in the days leading up to her vanishing, including searching for “how to pay for an Amber Alert,” “how to take money from a register without getting caught,” and on the movie Taken, about an abduction.

Russell later turned herself into local authorities. She eventually admitted to orchestrating the entire situation through a statement from her lawyer. 

“My client did not see a baby on the side of the road,” Russell’s lawyer, Emory Anthony, said. “My client did not leave the Hoover area when she was identified as a missing person. My client did not have any help in this incident, but this was a single act done by herself.”

Carlee Russell Expected to Appeal Her Conviction

Russell is expected to appeal Wednesday’s ruling in circuit court, particularly the jail time being recommended, according to NBC News. Her lawyers have said there is no past precedent for such a crime in Alabama. 

“Under the circumstances, a Class A misdemeanor, a first time offense — if you can find someone was put in jail I want you to bring me the file,” Anthony told WBRC. “We totally disagree with that. The restitution, we believe, is fair.”

Russell may also face additional charges. Prosecutors have assembled a grand jury in the case, according to WBRC. Her lawyer said Russell is remorseful for her actions. He added that his client has become emotionally vulnerable as her case proceeded through the courts. 

“She understands what’s happened, she’s apologized for what transpired,” Anthony said. “I don’t want her to have any type of breakdown. We are handling her with kid gloves.”

Russell’s defense team has two weeks to file an appeal. 

Russell’s ex-boyfriend, Thomar Latrell Simmons, said after the alleged kidnapping was revealed to be a hoax that the couple had a small fight before the ordeal.

“I mean we had a little argument but it wasn’t nothing to kidnap yourself over,” Simmons said on the podcast 205 Boyz.

Oxygen has reached out to Russell’s legal team for further comment. 

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Husband Fatally Stabs Pregnant Wife Multiple Times Before Contacting Police

Background: A neighborhood in St. Cloud, Minn. where Falus Ali was found…

College Cheerleader in Court as Baby Death Case Is Given to Grand Jury

A Kentucky woman charged with concealing her newborn baby’s death appeared in…

Police Report: Mother Provides Vodka to Teen Babysitter, Infant Discovered Outside

Inset: Ashley Ellis (Vanderburgh County Jail). Background: The area in Evansville, Indiana,…

Newly Appointed Trump Judge Quickly Criticizes Administration

President Donald Trump listens during a ceremonial swearing in of Paul Atkins…

Judge Rules Mike Lindell of MyPillow Made Defamatory Statements Against Smartmatic

Mike Lindell gives a thumbs up as he passes by a rally…

Deputies Arrest Man on Numerous Oklahoma Warrants, Face New Drug and Firearm Charges

Staff report ALACHUA COUNTY, Fla. – Samuel Joseph Mantone IV, 26, was…

Police Report: Couple Accused of Severely Neglecting 9-Year-Old Child Who Weighed Only 30 Pounds

Inset, left to right: Angel Holland and Aaron Stalling (Hamilton County Jail).…

Man Awaiting Trial in Several Cases Detained for Armed Robbery

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Pierre Lavon Williams, 35, was arrested yesterday…