Robots could create a more reliable Wikipedia: study
Share and Follow

A new study found that using artificial intelligence to police entries to open-source encyclopedias like Wikipedia could result in a more reliable source of information for users.

The study, published in Nature Machine Intelligence earlier this month, found that AI tools can help police some of the inaccurate or incomplete references that often plague online encyclopedias like Wikipedia, which could lead to improved quality and reliability, according to a report in Scientific American.

Researchers for the study developed an AI system called “SIDE,” which analyzed Wikipedia references to find missing and broken links or see if the references actually support the claims of the article. For references that didn’t meet the standard, the system was able to suggest better alterative references that would be more useful.

Christopher Alexander, the chief analytics officer of Pioneer Development Group, told Fox News Digital there could be some advantages to the use of AI in encyclopedias, including the idea of entirely AI-created resources.

AI CAN CONTAIN GENDER BIAS, LEADING TO POTENTIAL DISADVANTAGES FOR WOMEN, EXPERT SAYS

Phone with Wikipedia displayed

A silhouetted woman holds a smartphone with the Wikipedia logo displayed on the screen. (Photo Illustration by Rafael Henrique/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images)

“The principal advantage is removing human bias. An AI could look at multiple interpretations, verify facts and constantly monitor the research or reporting around an entry,” Alexander said. “Another advantage is that the AI works 24 hours a day, seven days a week and will not tire. Humans simply cannot keep up with that sort of productivity.”

But there are also pitfalls, Alexander noted, including proprietary algorithms that would make it difficult for users to understand.

“The second disadvantage is found in the current state of AI platforms,” Alexander said. “Presently, the AI wants, more than anything else, to make you happy. Accuracy is secondary to being useful. This can lead to AIs providing inaccurate information.”

“An ‘AI Wikipedia’ would have more information and potentially less narrative bias.”

Putting the study’s system to the test, the researchers had their AI system check Wikipedia’s featured articles and suggest references, with nearly 50% of cases resulting in the system’s choice for a reference already being cited by an article. In cases where the system suggested alternatives, the researchers found that 21% of users preferred the citations generated by AI, compared to 10% who preferred the human citations. Another 39% did not express a preference.

WHAT IS ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI)?

Samuel Mangold-Lenett, a staff editor at The Federalist, told Fox News Digital, an encyclopedia run by AI could produce superior results to humans versions.

“AI is perfect for developing a so-called ‘better’ version of Wikipedia,” Mangold-Lenett said. “This would likely be another predictive text language model similar to Chat GPT and whenever someone searches a topic, like Wikipedia, a biographical-topical article is generated.”

Mangold-Lenett also noted that an AI-run Wikipedia would allow “for the rapid processing of massive datasets, theoretical utilization of every relevant available source,” something that would result in “ironclad fact-checking” and potentially eliminate “human error and bias.” 

“An ‘AI Wikipedia’ would have more information and potentially less narrative bias,” Mangold-Lenett said.

WHAT IS CHATGPT?

Phil Siegel, the founder of the Center for Advanced Preparedness and Threat Response Simulation (CAPTRS), argued that what would be considered a “better” version of Wikipedia could be up for debate, though he noted AI would result in a “more comprehensive” product.

“It would also probably be more grammatically correct and would be better at generating and managing links across entries,” Siegel told Fox News Digital. “It would also generate entries for more obscure information as long as it was quality controlled.”

Someone typing on a laptop

The study found 21% of users preferred citations generated by artificial intelligence. (Tristan Spinski for The Washington Post via Getty Images)

But Siegel also noted an AI-run encyclopedia would also be less timely and would require a “very good prompt management process that could update it quickly with new news.”

“For entries that don’t ever really change, that’s OK. But you wouldn’t want to count on that, for example, for an entry for a currently famous person,” Siegel said.

Ultimately, Siegel argued, AI could help supplement the tasks carried out by humans.

“I would still have humans edit and quality control this information in order to make sure it was complete, up to date and not hallucinating,” Siegel said. “More of a human-artificial intelligence ‘partnership.'”

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Chicago Heights, Illinois 'Z-farm' helping Urban Growers Collective battle food insecurity, lower carbon footprint

Chicago Heights, Illinois Z-farm Supports Urban Growers Collective in Fighting Food Insecurity and Reducing Carbon Footprint

CHICAGO HEIGHTS, Ill. (WLS) — Protecting the planet can start with the…
Ben Rice 'pretty comfortable' in first start as catcher for Yankees

Yankees player Ben Rice shines in his debut as a starting catcher

Ben Rice passed his first test as a starting catcher in the…
JSO: Argument leads to woman being shot on Franklin Street on Eastside

Woman shot on Eastside’s Franklin Street following argument

The Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office says the two women started arguing with each…
Tren de Aragua potentially resurfacing in Colorado after attack

Potential resurfacing of Tren de Aragua in Colorado following an attack

() Police in Aurora, Colorado, are on high alert as they look…
'Bigger than us': In Oklahoma City, the Thunder and their fans form NBA's closest bond

In Oklahoma City, the Thunder and their fans share a strong connection unlike any other in the NBA

OKLAHOMA CITY — 6501 S. Meridian Ave. is not the type of…
Friends calling for justice for Brandon Venegas, killed in Arlington hit-and-run

Campaign for justice for Brandon Venegas organized by friends after he was killed in a hit-and-run accident in Arlington

The Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office is looking for the driver who hit and…
Mark Cuban reveals he rejected stunning offer from Kamala Harris

Mark Cuban turned down a significant offer from Kamala Harris, as shared by the billionaire.

NBA team minority owner Mark Cuban has revealed that Kamala Harris’ ticket…
Ezra Miller gives bizarre interview about their 'tentative' Hollywood return

“Ezra Miller Discusses Their Uncertain Return to Hollywood in Unconventional Interview”

1 The actor posed on the red carpet for the first time…