Supreme Court leaves intact Washington state conversion therapy ban
Share and Follow


The Supreme Court said it won’t review Washington state’s conversion therapy ban for minors, allowing the law to remain in effect.

The justices declined to take up an appeal from Brian Tingley, a licensed marriage and family therapist who sought to strike down the statute as unconstitutional.

Three of the Supreme Court’s conservatives — Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito and Brett Kavanaugh — said they would’ve heard Tingley’s appeal.

A federal appeals court last year upheld the law, which bans counselors from seeking to change the sexual orientation or gender identity of someone under the age of 18.

Tingley argued the law violates his First Amendment rights by censoring him and targeting him for his Christian beliefs.

“Tingley’s clients seek his counsel voluntarily because they want the help his viewpoint provides,” his attorney wrote in court filings. “Yet the Law forbids him from speaking, treating his professional license as a license for government censorship.”

In separate written dissents, Thomas and Alito said the issue merited the high court’s review. The duo have previously indicated on multiple occasions a willingness to wade into LGBTQ issues.

“In recent years, 20 States and the District of Columbia have adopted laws prohibiting or restricting the practice of conversion therapy. It is beyond dispute that these laws restrict speech, and all restrictions on speech merit careful scrutiny,” Alito wrote.

“The Ninth Circuit set a troubling precedent by condoning this regime,” Thomas similarly wrote.

“Although the Court declines to take this particular case, I have no doubt that the issue it presents will come before the Court again. When it does, the Court should do what it should have done here: grant certiorari to consider what the First Amendment requires,” he continued.

Tingley had also suggested the high court use the case as a vehicle to consider a broader question concerning religious rights.

Tingley said his case showed a need to overturn Employment Division v. Smith, a 1990 case in which the court ruled that laws comply with the First Amendment’s guarantee of free religious exercise if they are neutral and don’t specifically target religious practice.

The court considered overruling it in a 2021 case but ultimately did not. Three of the court’s conservatives — Thomas, Alito and Justice Neil Gorsuch — said at the time they would have tossed the precedent.

Tingley’s request to hear the case was supported by 12 Republican state attorneys general and various conservative religious groups.

“Washington’s censorship also taints science with politics. Free speech protects professional fields like medicine from the political pressures that often stifle rather than advance the scientific endeavor,” the states wrote in their brief.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
NASCAR Chicago Street Race" with contract over, will race return to Grant Park next year?

Is the NASCAR Chicago Street Race coming back to Grant Park next year after the contract ends?

3rd annual race weekend is currently final year of contract with city;…
Newly single Katy Perry shows ex Orlando Bloom on 'family' yacht trip

Katy Perry takes a yacht trip with family, post-breakup with Orlando Bloom

Katy Perry showed off her incredible figure in a black bikini during…
National Weather Service defends its flood warnings amid fresh scrutiny of Trump staff cuts

National Weather Service stands by flood warnings despite new criticism of decreased Trump administration staffing.

Fatal floods in Texas that left thousands scrambling for safety with little…
Russian minister found dead hours after Putin fired him

Russian minister found dead hours after Putin fired him

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! Russia’s transport minister, who…
Camp Mystic deaths hit 27 amid search for children missing in floods

27 people die at Camp Mystic as authorities look for missing kids in flood

The Camp Mystic death toll has risen to 27 campers and counselors…
Hilliard man recounts springing into action after neighbor on motorcycle hit by 14-year-old ATV driver

A man from Hilliard shares his story of taking quick action when his neighbor on a motorcycle was hit by a 14-year-old ATV driver.

The Florida Highway Patrol reported that a man was killed near his…
map visualization

Mapping: Locations of confirmed deaths from flash flooding in Texas

AUSTIN (KXAN) At least 82 people have been killed in catastrophic flash…
Sean 'Diddy' Combs received standing ovation from fellow inmates after partial conviction

Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs was applauded by other prisoners after being partly found guilty

1 Marc Agnifilo, the lead attorney for the “Act Bad” rapper, told…