Teacher 'tried to poison husband with poisonous plant in his smoothie'
Share and Follow

A high school art teacher allegedly tried to kill her husband by mashing up a poisonous flower and hiding it in his food and smoothies.

Sarah Scheffer, 37, was charged with attempted murder after her husband Matthew, 38, installed a hidden camera when he started getting sick.

He watched as his wife allegedly blended the contents of a green bowl, which were roots from a bag labeled ‘Lily of the Valley’ into a smoothie for him at their home in Jefferson City, Missouri.

Lily of the Valley is a white flower popular at weddings but poisonous when ingested, particularly its roots.

Ms Scheffer proudly wrote on her photography business’ Instagram page that she is ‘mother to two wild things and wife to a bearded foodie’ – but police alleged she planned to murder him and flee to Pakistan.

Sarah Scheffer, 37, was charged with attempted murder after her husband Matthew, 38, installed a hidden camera when he started getting sick

Sarah Scheffer, 37, was charged with attempted murder after her husband Matthew, 38, installed a hidden camera when he started getting sick

Ms Scheffer allegedly admitted during interrogation that she added the poisonous plant to the smoothie 'with the intent to cause the victim harm'

Ms Scheffer allegedly admitted during interrogation that she added the poisonous plant to the smoothie ‘with the intent to cause the victim harm’

The couple have two sons - a young boy and a baby - and it is unclear if Ms Scheffer planned to take them to Pakistan as part of her escape

The couple have two sons – a young boy and a baby – and it is unclear if Ms Scheffer planned to take them to Pakistan as part of her escape

Mr Scheffer, a regional manager at US Foods, installed the security camera after he began to suspect his wife was trying to make him sick for the past six weeks.

‘The victim described eight occurrences in which the defendant provided a beverage or food that had an odd taste,’ a probable cause statement read.

‘Shortly after ingesting he experienced extreme fatigue, confusion, blurred vision, severe cotton mouth, and nausea.’

Mr Scheffer confronted his wife on New Year’s Day after she gave him a drink that had a bitter taste, and she changed her story twice.

First she bizarrely said she urinated in his drink, then ‘admitted to putting an industrial strength adhesive in it’, then denied adding anything to it at all.

Ms Scheffer is a design and art teacher at Calvary Lutheran High School in Jefferson City (pictured on the school's website)

Ms Scheffer is a design and art teacher at Calvary Lutheran High School in Jefferson City (pictured on the school’s website)

Mr Scheffer secretly installed a camera facing the kitchen in their Jefferson City, Missouri, home (pictured) and allegedly caught her latest poisoning attempt

Mr Scheffer secretly installed a camera facing the kitchen in their Jefferson City, Missouri, home (pictured) and allegedly caught her latest poisoning attempt

Now extremely suspicious, her husband secretly installed a camera facing the kitchen and allegedly caught her latest poisoning attempt.

He stashed the smoothie in the fridge and called police on Tuesday, who took the drink for laboratory testing and later arrested his wife.

Ms Scheffer allegedly admitted during interrogation that she added the poisonous plant to the smoothie ‘with the intent to cause the victim harm’.

‘The defendant admitted to knowing that ingesting ‘lily of the valley’ could result in death,’ the statement said.

The probable cause statement opposed bail because Ms Scheffer told police she had a relationship with someone in Pakistan and had searched online for flights to the South Asian country.

Ms Scheffer was charged with attempted murder and armed criminal action, and booked into Cole County Jail.

She is a design and art teacher at Calvary Lutheran High School in Jefferson City, which put her on leave while the case plays out.

‘The alleged conduct was outside of the employee’s association with the school and did not involve a student or any other school personnel,’ Calvary Lutheran Executive Director John Christman said.

Lily of the Valley is a white flower popular at weddings but poisonous when ingested, particularly its roots

Lily of the Valley is a white flower popular at weddings but poisonous when ingested, particularly its roots

Ms Scheffer is a professional artist and photographer who also teaches at a local high school

Ms Scheffer is a professional artist and photographer who also teaches at a local high school

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Federal government plans to air-drop sterile flies over Texas to fight flesh-eating maggots

Federal government plans to air-drop sterile flies over Texas to fight flesh-eating maggots

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! The federal government is…
Several people injured in shooting incident at Georgia shopping mall: police

Several people injured in shooting incident at Georgia shopping mall: police

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! Several people were injured…
Lauren Sanchez's wedding dress is 'STOLEN' days after tying the knot

Lauren Sanchez’s Wedding Dress Vanishes Shortly After Wedding Day

One of Lauren Sanchez’s 27 nuptial dresses has vanished following her $20million…
Diddy trial: Sean "Diddy" Combs acquitted of most serious charges, convicted of a prostitution-related offense

Sean “Diddy” Combs Acquitted of Major Charges, Found Guilty of Prostitution-Related Offense

NEW YORK — Sean “Diddy Combs was convicted of a prostitution-related offense…
Chicago NASCAR race will be 'full-contact affair': Parker Kligerman

“Exciting Chicago NASCAR Race Promises High-Octane Action: Parker Kligerman”

Not sure how to find on your TV? Find your channel here. …
Seven unaccounted for, fireworks canceled after Calif. warehouse explosion

Explosion in California warehouse leaves seven missing, fireworks display called off

SAN JOSE, Calif. (KRON) — The City of San Jose has canceled…
TikTok influencer, 18, fatally shot at NJ beach as police charge 2 men with murder

18-year-old TikTok influencer killed by gunshots at New Jersey beach while authorities arrest two suspects for murder

Popular TikTok influencer Chrystofer A. Whyte, who boasted more than 100,000 followers,…
Diddy verdict: Shocked celebrities react as rapper is found not guilty

Celebrities Express Surprise Over Diddy’s Not Guilty Verdict

The entertainment industry in Los Angeles is shocked following a surprising decision…