Woman stunned after $500,000 Hawaii house is built on her plot of land
Share and Follow

A woman who purchased a plot of land to set-up a dream business was shocked to discover a $500,000 house was mistakenly built on her lot.

Annaleine ‘Anne’ Reynolds purchased a one-acre lot in Hawaii’s Paradise Park for around $22,500 in 2018.

Reynolds fell in love with the vacant space and was excited to transform it into the oasis for her business of hosting women’s meditative healing resorts.

While she was spending time in California during the pandemic, waiting for the right moment to launch her business venture, Reynolds got a shocking phone call from a real estate broker.

The broker told Reynolds that he had sold a half-a-million dollar house that was mistakenly built on her plot of land.  

Annaleine 'Anne' Reynolds purchased a one-acre lot in Hawaii's Paradise Park for around $22,500 in 2018

Annaleine 'Anne' Reynolds purchased a one-acre lot in Hawaii's Paradise Park for around $22,500 in 2018

Annaleine ‘Anne’ Reynolds purchased a one-acre lot in Hawaii’s Paradise Park for around $22,500 in 2018

Reynolds fell in love with the lot and was excited to transform it into the oasis for her dream-business of hosting women's meditative healing resorts

Reynolds fell in love with the lot and was excited to transform it into the oasis for her dream-business of hosting women's meditative healing resorts

Reynolds fell in love with the lot and was excited to transform it into the oasis for her dream-business of hosting women’s meditative healing resorts

While Reynolds was in California during the pandemic, a broker told her that he had sold a half-a-million dollar house that was mistakenly built on her plot of land

While Reynolds was in California during the pandemic, a broker told her that he had sold a half-a-million dollar house that was mistakenly built on her plot of land

While Reynolds was in California during the pandemic, a broker told her that he had sold a half-a-million dollar house that was mistakenly built on her plot of land

The mix-up happened when local developer Keaau Development Partnership hired PJ's Construction to build about a dozen homes on the land that the developer bought in the subdivision - but the company built one on Reynolds's lot

The mix-up happened when local developer Keaau Development Partnership hired PJ's Construction to build about a dozen homes on the land that the developer bought in the subdivision - but the company built one on Reynolds's lot

The mix-up happened when local developer Keaau Development Partnership hired PJ’s Construction to build about a dozen homes on the land that the developer bought in the subdivision – but the company built one on Reynolds’s lot

A local developer, Keaau Development Partnership, bought the land and hired PJ’s Construction to build about a dozen homes on the site – but the company built one on Reynolds’s lot.

Reynolds, along with the construction company, the architect and others, are now being sued by the developer.

‘There’s a lot of fingers being pointed between the developer and the contractor and some subs,’ Reynolds’ attorney James DiPasquale said.  

Reynolds described the land she purchased as ‘sacred’ and said that she chose to buy it because that specific property had ‘all the right qualities.’

She rejected the developer’s offer for a neighboring lot of equal size and value, according to court documents. 

Now Reynolds’s attorney says she shouldn’t be forced to pay. 

‘It would set a dangerous precedent, if you could go on to someone else’s land, build anything you want, and then sue that individual for the value of it,’ DiPasquale said.

Most of the lots in the Hawaiian Paradise Park are identical, Peter Olson, an attorney representing the developer claimed.

‘My client believes she’s trying to exploit PJ Construction’s mistake in order to get money from my client and the other parties,’ Olson, acknowledging an error, told The Associated Press Wednesday of her rejecting an offer for an identical lot.

Reynolds described the land she purchased as 'sacred' and said that she chose to buy it because that specific property had 'all the right qualities'

Reynolds described the land she purchased as 'sacred' and said that she chose to buy it because that specific property had 'all the right qualities'

Reynolds described the land she purchased as ‘sacred’ and said that she chose to buy it because that specific property had ‘all the right qualities’

She rejected the developer's offer for a neighboring lot of equal size and value, according to court documents

She rejected the developer's offer for a neighboring lot of equal size and value, according to court documents

She rejected the developer’s offer for a neighboring lot of equal size and value, according to court documents

The empty house has attracted squatters, according to neighbors who said the brand new vacant home is the perfect target for squatters

The empty house has attracted squatters, according to neighbors who said the brand new vacant home is the perfect target for squatters

The empty house has attracted squatters, according to neighbors who said the brand new vacant home is the perfect target for squatters

She has filed a counterclaim against the developer, saying she was unaware of the ‘unauthorized construction.’

An attorney for PJ’s Construction told Hawaii News Now the developer didn’t want to hire surveyors.

The empty house has attracted squatters, according to neighbors who said the brand new vacant home is the perfect target for squatters. 

‘Before they put the fence on the property there were people coming, looking inside,’ a neighbor said. 

Reynolds, who repeatedly escribed the situation as ‘awful,’ said there has even been feces found inside the house.

‘It was so disgusting,’ she told Fox19

Reynolds has had to pay for fencing to surround the empty new house, but that isn’t the only expense she is covering. She is also paying several thousand dollars in property taxes.

The developer has pulled everyone involved into the lawsuit so that a judge can decide who is ultimately responsible for the drastic mistake.  

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
University of Illinois Chicago releases report on faulty Analytical Forensic Testing Laboratory blood tests in marijuana DUI cases

Report on inaccurate blood tests for marijuana DUI cases from University of Illinois Chicago’s Analytical Forensic Testing Laboratory

CHICAGO (WLS) — The University of Illinois Chicago has released an internal…
4th of July fireworks: Non-residents must pay $8-10 fee to attend South Holland holiday display, village officials say

“Entry Fee Required for Non-Residents to Attend South Holland’s 4th of July Fireworks Display, According to Village Officials”

SOUTH HOLLAND, Ill. (WLS) — Those planning to go to the South…
Los Angeles 7-Eleven employee Jessica McLaughlin brain dead after being attacked by manager in Hollywood, family says

Family reports Los Angeles 7-Eleven worker Jessica McLaughlin in critical condition after altercation with manager

LOS ANGELES — An employee at a 7-Eleven in Los Angeles is…
Michael Madsen death: Actor, Chicago native known for roles in 'Reservoir Dogs,' 'Kill Bill' films, dies at 67

Actor Michael Madsen from Chicago passes away at 67, known for his roles in ‘Reservoir Dogs’ and ‘Kill Bill’ films

MALIBU, Calif. — Actor Michael Madsen, known for roles in “Reservoir Dogs”…
15-year-old bicyclist killed in unincorporated Crystal Lake hit-and-run crash: McHenry County Sheriff's Office

Bicyclist, 15, fatally hit in hit-and-run accident in Crystal Lake: Update from McHenry County Sheriff’s Office

McHENRY COUNTY, Ill. (WLS) — A 15-year-old bicyclist was killed in a…
NYC bodegas alarmed at Mamdani's plan for city-run markets

NYC bodegas concerned about Mamdani’s proposal for city-operated markets

() New York City mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani, a democratic socialist with…
Edan Alexander smiles with family members

Trump to meet with US hostage who was released as Hamas considers 2-month truce

() President Donald Trump and the first lady will host freed American…
Michael Madsen's distressing private health battle revealed

Actor Michael Madsen Opens Up About his Personal Health Struggles

Michael Madsen’s lawyer suggested that the well-known actor passed away at the…