Police hunt 'Haggler After Midnight' mugger targeting certain victims in bizarre crime spree
Share and Follow


The New York Police Department is hunting a moped-riding, knife-wielding robber whom they have dubbed the “Haggler After Midnight” for his peculiar mugging approach, saying his holdups are getting more brazen and violent.

Since early November, the suspect has targeted 11 victims in Brooklyn and Queens, generally Hispanic men between 20 and 40 on their way home from work in the wee hours of the morning, police said.

Deputy Chief John Mastronardi at the department’s Crimes against Persons Unit told WNBC that the mugger negotiates in both English and Spanish. 

“He’s got a strange M.O. – he likes to haggle with his victims, so we call him the ‘Haggler After Midnight,’” he said. “Oftentimes if a victim produces a property that they’re going to give up, he says ‘No, no, no, I don’t want that, want that.’ So he gets to choose.”

His most recent attack on Dec. 10 was his boldest yet, Mastronardi said. 

“In the last [incident], the male approached one of our victims and put a knife to his throat,” the detective said. 

Thus far, none of the suspect’s victims have been injured.

Crime Stoppers is offering a cash reward for any information that leads to the man’s capture.  

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
'It's great to see': Fans fill Jacksonville ahead of Gator Bowl kickoff

Jacksonville Buzzes with Excitement as Fans Flock to Gator Bowl Kickoff

Supporters from Missouri and Virginia are eagerly descending upon Jacksonville, bringing their…
Karoline Leavitt announces she is pregnant with her second child

Exciting News: Karoline Leavitt Reveals She’s Expecting Baby Number Two!

In a heartwarming announcement, White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt shared the…
Khloe Kardashian and Kris Jenner let loose on Christmas 'hookups'

Khloe Kardashian and Kris Jenner Spill the Beans on Their Christmas ‘Hookup’ Stories

Khloe Kardashian and Kris Jenner recently took time to chat about their…
Trump’s peace through strength in 2025: where wars stopped and rivals came to the table

Unveiling Trump’s 2025 Peace Strategy: How ‘Strength’ Silenced Conflicts and United Global Rivals

As the year 2025 began, Donald Trump took office with a commitment…
C-reactive protein outranks ‘bad’ cholesterol as leading heart disease risk marker

C-reactive Protein Surpasses LDL Cholesterol as Primary Indicator of Heart Disease Risk

Heart disease remains the number one cause of death in the United…
FILE - Jeffrey R. Holland, member of the quorum of the twelve apostles, speaks during a news conference at the Conference Center, in Salt Lake City, Jan. 27, 2015. (AP Photo/Rick Bowmer, File )

Jeffrey R. Holland’s Passing: The Future of LDS Church Leadership in Question

Jeffrey R. Holland, a prominent leader within the Church of Jesus Christ…
Chevy Chase opens up about memory issues in upcoming documentary

Chevy Chase Reveals Struggles with Memory Loss in Candid New Documentary

Chevy Chase has opened up about experiencing memory loss following a significant…
New York needs Elise Stefanik and more: Letters

Why New York’s Future Could Depend on Leaders Like Elise Stefanik: Reader Opinions

Come back, Elise It’s unfortunate that Rep. Elise Stefanik chose not to…