When does a heartbeat start? South Carolina Supreme Court again takes up abortion issue
Share and Follow


COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — With a heartbeat abortion ban solidly in place in South Carolina, lawyers for the state and Planned Parenthood return to the state’s highest court Wednesday to argue how restrictive the ban should be.

The law is being enforced in South Carolina as a ban on almost all abortions around six weeks after conception, setting that mark as the time cardiac activity starts.

But Planned Parenthood and other abortion rights groups are arguing the 2023 law includes alternative definitions about the timing of a fetal heart forming and a “heartbeat” starting and the true ban should start around nine or 10 weeks.

Both sides are set to argue for just over an hour at the South Carolina Supreme Court in Columbia. The justices likely will take several months to decide the case. In the meantime, the abortion ban around six weeks likely will remain in place after a lower court upheld it.

The 2023 law says abortions cannot be performed after an ultrasound can detect “cardiac activity, or the steady and repetitive rhythmic contraction of the fetal heart, within the gestational sac.”

South Carolina and several other states place that at six weeks into development. But what follows the “or” in the sentence could require that a heart has formed, and medical experts say that doesn’t happen until around nine weeks.

The legal fight has been brewing since the state Supreme Court reversed itself after overturning a similar ban in 2021. The Republican-dominated General Assembly then made small changes and a justice who voted in the majority in the 3-2 decision to overturn the ban reached retirement age and was replaced.

In the decision upholding the new ban, the state Supreme Court itself noted the different definitions saying resolving them would be a question “for another day.”

That day is Wednesday. Since then, more inconsistencies in the law’s language have been brought up. The law refers to a fetal heartbeat, but most experts consider a fertilized egg to be an embryo for about 10 weeks after conception before transitioning into a fetus.

Lawyers for the state said the parsing of the language ignores the intent of the Legislature. Both supporters and opponents of the bill called it nearly exclusively a six-week ban during debate in the House and Senate.

Since the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade in 2022 and ended a nationwide right to abortion, most Republican-controlled states have started enforcing new bans or restrictions and most Democrat-dominated ones have sought to protect abortion access.

Currently, 13 states are enforcing bans on abortion at all stages of pregnancy, with limited exceptions, and South Carolina and three others have bans that kick in at or about six weeks into pregnancy — often before women realize they’re pregnant.

The latest lawsuit was filed by South Carolina resident Taylor Shelton, who said she had sought medical attention for pain from her intrauterine device and was stunned to find out, just two days after missing her regularly-tracked period, that she was pregnant.

She ended up in North Carolina, driving for hours to several appointments to undergo an abortion because doctors in South Carolina were unsure how to define a heartbeat. Shelton couldn’t be completely sure she was within six weeks.

Some Republicans in South Carolina are also pushing for an outright abortion ban, but while legislation was introduced this January when the General Assembly started its two-year session, no hearings have been held.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Military families share emotional reactions to consolidation recommendation for Anchor Academy & Mayport Elementary

Military Families React to Proposed Merger of Anchor Academy and Mayport Elementary Schools

At a recent community meeting, parents and students expressed their opinions on…
Irina Shayk's bleached brows are almost as shocking as her giant emerald earrings

Irina Shayk Stuns with Bold Bleached Brows and Statement Emerald Earrings in Fashion Forward Look

Supermodels are accustomed to capturing attention, but Irina Shayk recently offered a…
Trump rages at 'weak Republicans' over Epstein whiplash

Trump Criticizes Fellow Republicans Amid Epstein Controversy

Donald Trump has called on Pam Bondi to launch an investigation into…
Vine is being rebooted as 'diVine,' a short-form video app that bans AI content

Former Vine Platform Revamped as ‘diVine,’ Introducing AI-Free Short-Form Video Experience

Jack Dorsey, the former CEO and co-founder of Twitter, is making waves…
Charlotte promises to resist pending federal immigration raids: 'Campaign of terror'

Charlotte Stands Firm: City Vows to Shield Residents from Looming Federal Immigration Crackdown

City officials in Charlotte, North Carolina, are bracing for an impending federal…
Tucker Carlson sparks panic as he exposes Trump shooter's terror ties

Tucker Carlson Unveils Alleged Links Between Trump Shooter and Terrorism, Causing Widespread Concern

Tucker Carlson has once again stirred controversy, this time with a startling…
21 gang members arrested in massive North Texas crime crackdown, FBI says

FBI Announces Arrest of 21 Gang Members in Sweeping Crime Crackdown Across North Texas

Authorities in Texas have apprehended over 20 members of the Kiccdoe gang,…
‘Protector’ father of nine slain after minor crash spirals into deadly road rage clash

Tragic Road Rage Incident Claims Life of Devoted Father of Nine Following Minor Collision

A 49-year-old father tragically lost his life in a suspected road-rage incident…