Beauty queen charged for ex-NFL husband's murder plot to be released from prison in Bahamas
Share and Follow

Georgia mom Lindsay Shiver, who is accused of plotting to hire a hitman to kill her estranged husband, ex-NFL player Robert Shiver, with help from her alleged Bahamian lover, was reportedly expected to be released from a Bahamas prison on bail.

Shiver, 38, is expected to return to the United States after posting $100,000 bail, according to “Good Morning America,” which interviewed Shiver last year, sparking backlash from the Nassau judge overseeing the Georgia beauty pageant winner’s case.

Justice Cheryl Grant-Thompson revoked Shiver’s bail last year after the GMA interview, calling it a “blatant disregard for the court’s leniency and indulgence,” but she reportedly reversed her decision this week upon the condition that Shiver and her 30-year-old lover, Terrance Bethel, maintain their silence as part of a gag order.

Shiver’s Bahamas attorney, Ian Cargill, said she was expected to be released on bail on Thursday, WDHN reported. Cargill did not immediately respond to an inquiry from Fox News Digital regarding her reported release.

Shiver, along with her lover, Bethel, and the alleged hitman, Faron Newbold Jr., were arrested in the Bahamas in July 2023. They pleaded not guilty to all charges.

“This cannot and will not be tolerated. What the respondents have done can be seen by the applicant as a spit in the face of justice,” Grant-Thompson wrote in a Monday filing, according to Loop News.

Shiver’s attorneys reportedly argued that she did not breach her jail conditions, which the judge disagreed with.

“It was clearly laid out that if Mrs. Shiver wished to travel or move outside of the designated area, she was first to contact and request the permission of the court,” the judge wrote in her ruling, adding that her decision to revoke bail was also to take Shiver “out of harm’s way” after a different boyfriend tried to “choke and suffocate her with a pillow in Alabama,” according to Loop News.

Grant-Thompson previously released Shiver, who has three children, in December 2023 on $100,000 bail and allowed her to travel back to the United States upon certain conditions, one of which Shiver apparently broke with her TV interview.

The Shivers reached a boiling point after 13 years of marriage, evident in divorce filings, with Robert accusing Lindsay of having an affair, and Lindsay countering with allegations of “physical and mental cruel treatment,” including accusations of domestic violence.

They are both seeking primary custody of their children and sole use of their $2.5 million home in Georgia.

In bodycam footage previously obtained by Fox News Digital, Lindsay called 911 on Robert on July 16, 2023, after he refused to let her hitch a ride on their private jet to meet her lover in the Bahamas.

That same day, she allegedly wrote “Kill him,” in a WhatsApp message to Newbold. Five days later, she was arrested in the Bahamas, along with Bethel and Newbold, for conspiring to murder Robert. 

Robert told the judge he was “thankful to be alive” during a December 2023 court appearance, where he appeared via Zoom, as Court TV previously reported. 

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Senate approves bill to end longest government shutdown in US history

Senate Passes Legislation to Conclude Nation’s Lengthiest Government Shutdown

The United States Senate cast a vote on Monday night to conclude…
Gavin Newsom just let slip the Democrats' dirty little secret

Gavin Newsom Reveals Surprising Insight into Democratic Strategy

In a dramatic turn of events, the Democratic Party’s recent triumphs have…
Trump tariff revenue not high enough to fund rebate checks: Analysis

Analysis Reveals Insufficient Tariff Revenue to Support Trump Rebate Checks

An analysis released on Monday reveals that President Donald Trump’s proposed tariff…
Help change lives during our 10th annual K9s for Warriors Veterans Day Telethon

Join the 10th Annual K9s for Warriors Veterans Day Telethon: Transforming Lives of Veterans and Service Dogs

For the past decade, First Coast News has partnered with K9s for…
'Zootopia 2' directors Jared Bush and Byron Howard reveal what makes Disney sequel so fun

Directors Jared Bush and Byron Howard Unveil the Exciting Elements Behind Disney’s ‘Zootopia 2’ Sequel

In “Zootopia 2,” audiences will reunite with the dynamic duo of Judy…
Father and son gunned down in blue city after jewelry store robbery, thousands offered for information

Father and Son Fatally Shot Following Jewelry Store Heist in Urban Area; Substantial Reward Announced for Information

A tragic incident unfolded in Chicago over the weekend, resulting in the…
Trump says Marjorie Taylor Greene has 'lost her way'

Trump Criticizes Marjorie Taylor Greene for Straying from Core Values

On Monday, President Trump addressed remarks made by Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene,…
Trump asks Supreme Court to toss E. Jean Carroll sex abuse verdict

Trump Appeals to Supreme Court for Overturn of E. Jean Carroll Sex Abuse Verdict

In a significant legal development, President Trump has approached the Supreme Court…