Police recover body of missing transgender man they say was tortured for over a month by five people
Share and Follow

CANANDAIGUA — New York State Police charged five people Friday with murder in the killing of a missing man who authorities said died following repeated acts of violence and torture for more than a month by multiple individuals who later discarded his body in a field.

The victim, Sam Nordquist, a 24-year-old transgender man originally from Minnesota, was reported missing on Feb. 9. Police said he arrived in New York in September and had lost contact with loved ones.

Major Kevin Sucher, commander of the state police troop that includes the Finger Lakes region, said the facts and circumstances of the case were “beyond depraved” and “by far the worst” homicide investigation the office has ever been part of.

“No human being should have to endure what Sam endured,” he said, during televised news conference. Police did not share many details of the case, noting it remained under active investigation.

When asked if Nordquist’s torture and death were considered a hate crime, Capt. Kelly Swift the New York State Police Troop E’s Bureau of Criminal Investigation said police hadn’t ruled it out but stressed the investigation was continuing. Investigators also need to determine Nordquist’s relationship with the suspects as well as the suspects’ relationships with one another.

Those arrested include Precious Arzuaga, 38, and Patrick Goodwin, 30, of Canandaigua, New York; Kyle Sage, 33, of Rochester, New York; Jennifer Quijano, 30, of Geneva, New York; and Emily Motyka, 19, of Lima, New York. All five were charged with second-degree murder after police on Thursday searched a room at the Patty’s Lodge motel in Canandaigua, the last place Nordquist was known to be staying.

All five were being held in police custody, pending arraignment. It was unclear whether any had obtained an attorney.

The investigation has so far revealed a “deeply disturbing pattern of abuse” that ultimately resulted in Nordquist’s death, said Swift, who called it “one of the most horrific crimes” she has ever investigated in her 20-year law enforcement career.

Copyright © 2025 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Jam Master Jay news: Judge voids ruling of 1 of 2 men found guilty of killing Jason Mizell of Run-D.M.C., Karl Jordan Jr.

Judge Overturns Conviction of One Suspect in Jam Master Jay Murder Case

NEW YORK — In a surprising development, a judge has overturned one…
Racial comments in video from Clay Co. School Board member prompt calls for resignation

Outrage Grows as Racial Remarks by Clay County School Board Member Spark Resignation Demands

The pressure is mounting on Robert Alvero to step down from his…
FILE - Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy speaks during a news conference at the Department of Transportation in Washington, Dec. 12, 2025. (AP Photo/Mark Schiefelbein, File)

Colorado’s Federal Funds Slashed by $24M Due to Unlawful CDL Issuances

DENVER (AP) — On Monday, the U.S. Department of Transportation issued a…
Army veteran accused in Beanie Babies founder mansion break-in claimed pop star controlled him: report

Army Veteran Blames Pop Star Influence in Beanie Babies Mogul Mansion Break-In

A Nevada Army veteran, facing allegations of a violent intrusion at billionaire…
Fears woman is mauled by shark off California coast

Shark Attack Concerns Rise as California Woman Feared Mauled Off Coast

In a tragic turn of events, a 55-year-old woman is missing and…
Brown University hires former US Attorney Zachary Cunha as possible campus shooting lawsuits loom

Brown University Appoints Former US Attorney Zachary Cunha Amid Potential Campus Shooting Legal Challenges

Exclusive to Fox News: Brown University has enlisted the expertise of former…
Repeat offender allegedly kills Ohio man just days after nonprofit pays his bail

Ohio Man Tragically Killed by Repeat Offender Days After Nonprofit Bail Release Sparks Controversy

In Ohio, a frequent offender is facing accusations of committing murder shortly…
Brown University police chief placed on leave

Brown University Police Chief Temporarily Relieved of Duties: What You Need to Know

The chief of police at Brown University has been placed on leave…