Cultural landscape 'obliterated' at mine, court told
Share and Follow

The Country where Fortescue Metals Group has dug up tonnes of iron ore will be returned to traditional owners as “large pits in the land”, once mining operations have ceased, a court has been told.

The federal court is considering how much compensation Yindjibarndi native title holders could receive from Fortescue Metals Group, as closing submissions begin in the long-running legal dispute.

Yindjibarndi Ngurra Aboriginal Corporation is seeking compensation from Fortescue over “economic and cultural loss” due to mining operations.

FMG equipment at work in the Pilbara. (Erin Jonasson)

Fortescue began mining at the Solomon hub in Western Australia’s Pilbara region in 2013 without agreement from the Aboriginal corporation, instead dealing with a breakaway group.

During his submission, barrister for Yindjibarndi, Vance Hughston told the federal court the devastation to Country had been enormous, as had the wealth generated for Fortescue and the state of Western Australia.

“The only party missing out in all of this is the Yindjibarndi people,” he said.

“Country, physically and culturally is being destroyed, they’re locked out of that Country and they are not receiving a dollar’s compensation from the wealth that is being generated from their Country.”

Hughston said the Solomon mine hub is in an area of Country that was “effectively pristine”, but cultural and physical aspects of the land had been destroyed.

He said mining would continue until at least 2045, and then undergo several years of rehabilitation.

Hughston said rehabilitation works “will never restore the land to its original quality” and the “cultural landscape will remain obliterated”.

“What will be returned will be large pits in the land,” Hughston said.

Effectively, we say in our submissions, that native title has really been extinguished … this Country has been lost to them, they won’t be going back to this Country when the miners finally leave.”

Lawyers for Yindjibarndi argue compensation should take into account the amount the native title holders would have been able to negotiate with Fortescue, while the miner has said the amount should be calculated without reference to the value of any minerals on or in the ground.

“They want that access to the land to get the minerals and they will pay a percentage royalty on the minerals that are mined and sold.”

Closing submissions are expected to continue tomorrow.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Tammy Hembrow says she is 'aching' after fleeing Australia with her three kids following split with Matt Zukowski as she reveals breakup weight-loss

Tammy Hembrow is in pain after leaving Australia with her three children due to her breakup with Matt Zukowski, mentioning how the split has caused her to lose weight.

Tammy Hembrow has revealed her heart is still ‘aching’ following her split…
Elon Musk and Donald Trump are fighting again

Elon Musk and Donald Trump engage in another dispute

The truce between Elon Musk and US President Donald Trump didn’t even…
Noel Edmonds 'not sure of the way forward' after flood ravages his New Zealand estate - with 'three years of hard graft destroyed in a few hours'

Noel Edmonds uncertain about future after his New Zealand property is destroyed by a flood, losing three years of work in just a few hours.

  Noel Edmonds revealed he is ‘not sure of the way forward’…

Government employee provided unfair advantage to sister’s fiancé in new job, according to investigation

A senior official at the Department of Home Affairs engaged in corrupt…

RUNIT, a recent contact sport, is sparking concerns about concussions.

A video posted online shows medics coming to the aid of a…
Two guests, said to be a father and his young daughter, have been rescued by crew after going into the water while onboard the Disney Dream cruise ship as it returned from a voyage around the Bahamas.

A father and his daughter saved after falling from a Disney cruise ship

Two guests, said to be a father and his young daughter, have…

Israel to investigate airstrike that killed 24 Palestinians at Gaza beach cafe

The Israeli army said Tuesday that it launched a review into a…
Wild weather knocks out power, cuts trains and threatens homes

Severe Weather Causes Power Outages, Disrupts Train Services, and Endangers Houses

Sixty passengers were taken from a train hit by fallen power lines…