Michelle Trachtenberg Wrote and Shopped Mattel Screenplay Before Death
Share and Follow

Michelle Trachtenberg was embarking on a new path as a screenwriter before her death at the age of 39.

The actress was on the verge of closing a deal on a screenplay she’d written based on the book Toy Monster: The Big, Bad World of Mattel, the film’s director and producer Casey Tebo told TMZ on Monday, March 3.

Casey, 50, told the outlet that it was one of the “best” screenplays he’d ever read and that he and Michelle were close to closing a deal with a studio prior to her death on February 26.

Toy Monster, written by author Jerry Oppenheimer, was originally published in 2009. The exposé focused on Mattel’s corporate culture and how the brand behind Barbie and Hot Wheels became dominant in the brutal toy business.

Casey directed the 2021 film Black Friday and 2018’s portrait Steven Tyler: Out on a Limb, about the legendary Aerosmith frontman. He told TMZ that he and Michelle had a breakthrough in January when a “very successful finance studio” expressed their interest in the screenplay. The project is now on hold following Michelle’s death, but Casey is determined to make the movie in the Gossip Girl star’s memory.

Michelle was found unresponsive inside her New York City apartment by her mother, Lana Trachtenberg. She called 911 and EMS workers pronounced the Buffy the Vampire Slayer alum dead at the scene.

Sources confirmed to multiple outlets that Michelle underwent liver transplant surgery prior to her death. An insider told the New York Post that her body may have rejected the organ.

The New York Police Department said in a statement obtained by In Touch on February 26, that “criminality” was “not suspected” in Michelle’s death.

The Ice Princess star’s cause and manner of death were both officially listed as “undetermined,” the New York Medical Examiner’s office confirmed to In Touch on February 27.

A source told the New York Post that the cause of death was listed in the way it was after Michelle’s family reportedly objected to an autopsy. Only an external examination of the body could be completed, while the medical examiner’s office was “obligated to honor the family’s request due to the state’s public health law,” according to the insider.

Michelle hadn’t appeared in a TV series or film since a two-episode guest appearance in 2022’s Gossip Girl reboot. She hadn’t attended a major red carpet event since 2020’s 28th Annual Elton John AIDS Foundation Academy Awards party.

Michelle Trachtenberg Was Working on Mattel Screenplay Before Death
Presley Ann/Getty Images for Christian Siriano

The Inspector Gadget star made a rare public outing to designer Christian Siriano‘s 15-year anniversary celebration in Los Angeles in 2023.

Some fans became concerned about Michelle in early 2024, after she appeared slightly pale and gaunt in several selfies.

“Michelle u look sick. R u ok?” one fan asked about her well-being in the comments of a January 2024 photo. The star hit back, “Explain to me how I look sick. Did you lose a calendar and not realize I’m not 14. I’m 38. How sad for you to leave such a comment.”

Several of Michelle’s famous costars paid tribute to the actress after her death.

“Michelle, listen to me. Listen. I love you. I will always love you. The hardest thing in this world, is to live in it. I will be brave. I will live … for you,’” Buffy the Vampire Slayer star Sarah Michelle Gellar captioned the February 27 post featuring photos of the duo.

“You knew when she entered a room because the vibration changed. Everything she did, she did 200%,” actress Blake Lively later wrote about her Gossip Girl costar.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Ned’s Declassified Actor Steps Up to Support Homeless Co-Star with Hotel Stay

Ned’s Declassified School Survival Guide actor Daniel Curtis Lee has extended a…

Seven Instances Where Sydney Sweeney’s Stunning Legs Couldn’t Redeem Her Fashion Choices

Dec. 23, 2025 9:00 pm EST By Lea B…

Tom Brady Enjoys Sun-Soaked Vacation with Son Jack Amid Gisele Bündchen’s Recent Wedding News

Tom Brady celebrated Christmas Eve by hitting the links with his oldest…

Enchanting Royal Duet: Kate Middleton and Princess Charlotte’s Heartwarming Piano Performance at Christmas Carol Service

In a heartwarming surprise, Kate Middleton and her daughter, Princess Charlotte, delighted…

Jennifer Fessler’s Stunning Transformation: Unveiling Her Nose Job and Facelift Journey with Before & After Photos

Jennifer Fessler recently showcased the results of her cosmetic surgery, which included…

Tamra Judge Reveals Shocking RHOC Finale Drama, Speaks on PTSD Struggles & Slams Gretchen’s Controversial Posts

Tamra Judge recently revealed she was forewarned about a dramatic phone call…

Influencer Chessie King Shares Emotional Journey to Second Pregnancy: 446 Days and 86 Injections Mark IVF Success

Chessie King, a well-known influencer, has opened up about her challenging journey…

Meghan Markle and Prince Harry Unveil Festive Christmas Plans Amidst Royal Family Distance

As the Royal Family gears up for their customary Christmas festivities at…