Kentucky sheriff charged with fatally shooting judge pal plans to offer insanity defense at trial: docs
Share and Follow

The rural Kentucky sheriff charged with gunning down his longtime judge pal in his chambers is planning to offer an insanity defense at his trial, according to legal papers.

Now-former Lester County Sheriff Shawn “Mickey” Stines’ legal team filed a notification last week that they’re gearing up to present evidence of insanity and extreme emotional disturbance in the death of District Judge Kevin Mullins, according to documents obtained by WCYB.

The legal maneuver comes after defense lawyer Jeremy Bartley previously claimed Stines was dealing with an “extreme emotional disturbance” when he pumped multiple gunshots into Mullins, 54, on Sept. 19 inside the Letcher County Courthouse.

“It was not something that was planned and occurred in the heat of passion,” Bartley told People in October.

“For us, the highest level of culpability should be manslaughter based on the partial defense of extreme emotional disturbance.”

The attorney said this week there might be “more evidence that would support a finding that he wasn’t criminally responsible,” according to the Louisville Courier Journal.

Footage of the fatal shooting shows the top cop pulling out his gun and pointing it at the judge’s head as Mullins tries to turn away and hide behind his desk.

Stines is then seen firing off multiple rounds, including two at close range, before leaving the chambers, according to the video. He was taken into custody without incident and has remained behind bars since.

Bartley previously said a deposition in a federal lawsuit Stines gave days before the shooting is part of his defense, the Courier Journal reported in December.

The sheriff was one of several parties facing legal action in 2022 after a Letcher County deputy was accused of giving favorable treatment to a woman on home arrest in return for sexual favors inside Mullins’ private office where there are no cameras, the newspaper reported.

Stine was accused only of not properly training the deputy who was fired and later convicted on state charges.

Meanwhile, Mullins was allegedly linked to the sextortion scandal, according to audio recordings obtained by NewsNation in December. 

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Our Chicago: Bears consider Arlington Heights and Northwest Indiana to build new stadium

Chicago Bears Eye Arlington Heights and Northwest Indiana for Potential New Stadium Locations

On a spirited Sunday afternoon, Soldier Field came alive with the enthusiasm…
Trump admin preparing 1,500 soldiers for potential Minnesota deployment: report

Trump Administration Gears Up for Possible Minnesota Military Deployment: 1,500 Troops on Standby

The Trump administration is reportedly gearing up to potentially deploy 1,500 troops…
St. Johns County records zero homicides in 2025, sheriff said the milestone was unexpected

St. Johns County Achieves Unprecedented Zero Homicides in 2025: Sheriff Hails Surprise Milestone

A landmark achievement in public safety has been recorded in St. Johns…
Florida snow 2026: Here are photos, videos capturing snowfall across the panhandle

Rare Snowfall in Florida’s Panhandle: Stunning Photos and Videos from 2026 Event

Experience the stunning visuals of snowfall from Sunday, January 18, 2026. FLORIDA,…
National Popcorn Day: Here’s where moviegoers can find popcorn deals

Celebrate National Popcorn Day with Exclusive Movie Theatre Deals and Discounts

Movie theater giants like AMC, Regal, and Cinemark are gearing up to…
Fans claim college football is RUINED as QB says he graduated in 2024

College Football Controversy: Fans Outraged Over Quarterback’s 2024 Graduation Claim

The term ‘student athlete’ took on a new dimension on Sunday when…
‘Long Island Lolita’ survivor Mary Jo Buttafuoco says bullet in her head ‘will get me eventually’

Mary Jo Buttafuoco Speaks Out: The Lingering Impact of the ‘Long Island Lolita’ Incident

The life of Mary Jo Buttafuoco changed dramatically when she was shot…
They're the picture perfect family. But this photo hides a dark truth

Unveiling Hidden Secrets: The Untold Story Behind the Picture-Perfect Family

The images capture an idyllic scene: a charming man and a cheerful…