Overwhelming number of New Yorkers support changes to take mentally ill off streets, subways: poll
Share and Follow

According to a recent survey, almost 90% of New York City voters are in favor of increasing involuntary commitment and care for mentally ill individuals who are homeless in the city, including those on the streets or in the subway.

The poll conducted by the Association for a Better New York revealed that an overwhelming 88% of voters back the idea of expanding treatment options. This comes at a time when Governor Kathy Hochul’s efforts to broaden the laws around involuntary commitment are met with some opposition within the legislative body.

A question posed in the survey asked respondents about their level of support for expanding the state eligibility criteria for involuntary treatment and care to encompass individuals who are incapable of looking after themselves and meeting their basic needs.

Of the 600 voters polled only 4% said they were opposed and 8% were undecided as support for change was overwhelming in all parts of the city and demographic groups.

More than nine in 10 voters (91%) also agreed with the statement that “it is more compassionate to provide involuntary treatment and care for people with severe mental illness than it is to leave them on the streets” — including a majority (53%) who strongly agree with that statement.

Similarly, 91% of voters agree that “people struggling with severe mental illness should not be denied life-saving psychiatric care because their illness prevents them from recognizing that they need help” — including 59% who strongly agree.

The poll — conducted by Tulchin Research for ABNY — also found that 73% of voters said that the number of public safety incidents in New York involving individuals with untreated severe mental illness has increased in recent years. Some 18% said the number has stayed the same, and just 4% said it has decreased.

“New Yorkers are rightfully concerned about their safety,” said Steven Rubenstein, chairman of ABNY. “This isn’t just from watching the news. It is rooted in the firsthand experiences that New Yorkers are having in the transit system every single day.

“There is an overwhelming consensus spanning every borough and every political party that we have a problem and there are compassionate ways to fix it,” Rubenstein added. “The proposed laws to better care for people who cannot care for themselves have the solid support of New Yorkers.”

Some 86% of Big Apple residents said they’ve seen a person wandering on the street or in the subway who appears to be struggling with severe mental illness and unable to care for themselves.

About nine in 10 voters believe it should be a top or high priority of New York State lawmakers to address untreated severe mental illness, the poll showed.

Nearly-two thirds of respondents said they have felt endangered while riding the subway or bus due to the actions of someone grappling with severe mental illness.

A Hochul rep said she and the voters are in sync on wanting common sense solutions to help mentally ill residents get care while bolstering public safety.

“Providing care to people facing significant health risks due to mental illness is a compassionate and humane approach that all New Yorkers can recognize. This is why there is overwhelming public support for Governor Hochul’s proposal,” spokesperson Avery Cohen said.

“We look forward to working with the Legislature to enact these statutory changes and align New York with 43 other states that already have this in their laws. The cost of inaction is far too high.”

In its analysis, Tulchin Research said voters widely see involuntary care as “compassionate and necessary” to help those who can’t help themselves and believe that expanding the eligibility standard for involuntary care also protects public safety.

Despite overwhelming public support, Hochul is facing some headwinds in Albany.

The state Assembly and Senate either entirely omitted or scrapped parts of Hochul’s bid to expand involuntary commitment laws in separate counter proposals to the governor’s budget plan released last week.

The lower chamber’s one-house budget proposal omits Hochul’s proposal around expanding the necessary criteria to compel mentally ill people into psychiatric care.

But it includes provisions for strengthening hospital discharge planning and requiring review panels after serious incidents where mentally ill people fall through the cracks or harm others.

Many mental health care advocates and civil activists also oppose forced treatment, but others including Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie said there could be room for acceptable compromise.

“We want people to feel safe on the subways. Subways should not become temporary living places for people who have mental health issues,” Heastie said last week.

Tulchin Research conducted the ABNY survey among 600 voters in New York City from Feb. 4-10. It has a margin of error of+/- 4 percentage points.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
DeSantis opts Florida into federal education tax credit program to expand 'school choice'

DeSantis Enrolls Florida in Federal Tax Credit Initiative to Enhance School Choice Opportunities

Florida taxpayers can soon benefit from a tax credit of up to…
Federal agents arrest man in Bolingbrook Police Department lobby after he tried to report encounter with them: officials

Surprising Turn of Events: Man Arrested in Bolingbrook Police Lobby After Attempting to Report Federal Agents’ Encounter

In Bolingbrook, Illinois, concerned residents gathered with candles at the local police…
White House explodes as Trump's Minnesota 'retreat' sparks MAGA revolt

White House in Turmoil: Trump’s Minnesota ‘Retreat’ Ignites MAGA Uprising

The White House is in turmoil over allegations that Donald Trump is…
Ilhan Omar attacked by liquid-sprayer after calling for Noem to resign

Ilhan Omar Targeted in Liquid-Spraying Incident Following Call for Noem’s Resignation

In a startling incident, Congresswoman Ilhan Omar was confronted by a man…
Dozens arrested after protesters take over NYC hotel lobby during anti-ICE demonstration

Mass Arrests at NYC Hotel: Anti-ICE Protest Shakes the City!

Authorities made several arrests following a protest against ICE that erupted inside…
Inside Trump's plan to dish out $100 BILLION MORE to Americans

Discover Trump’s New $100 Billion Proposal for American Citizens

President Donald Trump and the Republican party are banking on the financial…
Rep. Ilhan Omar’s alleged attacker sprayed her with apple cider vinegar, hazmat crew confirms: report

Shocking Incident: Rep. Ilhan Omar Targeted in Apple Cider Vinegar Attack, Hazmat Team Investigates

During a tumultuous town hall meeting in Minnesota on Tuesday night, U.S.…
College student assaulted as alleged security lapses let attacker slip onto campus: report

Campus Security Flaws Exposed: Student Assaulted After Attacker Gains Unauthorized Access

Concerns about campus security at a Florida university have been raised following…