North Carolina family can sue over COVID-19 vaccine administered without consent, court rules
Share and Follow

A North Carolina mother and her son can sue a public school system and a doctors’ group for allegedly giving the boy a COVID-19 vaccine without consent, the state Supreme Court ruled.

The ruling handed down Friday reverses a lower-court decision that a federal health emergency law prevented Emily Happel and her son Tanner Smith from filing a lawsuit.

Both a trial judge and the state Court of Appeals had ruled against the two, who sought litigation after Smith received an unwanted vaccine during the height of the coronavirus pandemic.

Smith was vaccinated in August 2021 at age 14 despite his opposition at a testing and vaccination clinic at a Guilford County high school, according to the family’s lawsuit.

Pfizer covid vaccine bottle

The mother and son argue that their constitutional rights were violated. (AP Photo/Steven Senne)

The court’s conservative justices backed Newby’s opinion, including two who wrote a separate opinion suggesting the immunity found in the federal law should be narrowed further.

Associate Justice Allison Riggs, a liberal who wrote a dissenting opinion, said that state constitutional claims should be preempted from the federal law and criticized the court’s majority for a “fundamentally unsound” interpretation of the constitution.

“Through a series of dizzying inversions, it explicitly rewrites an unambiguous statute to exclude state constitutional claims from the broad and inclusive immunity,” Riggs said.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Rarely-seen country icon steps out to support his nepo baby daughter

Legendary Country Star Makes Surprise Appearance to Support Rising Star Daughter

Country music legend Tim McGraw made a rare public appearance alongside his…
Israeli hostage who revealed sexual abuse describes full horror

Israeli Hostage Shares Harrowing Account of Sexual Abuse Ordeal

An Israeli man, who endured captivity and brutal assault at the hands…
Captain and first officer of UPS plane crash in Louisville revealed

Identities of Captain and First Officer in Louisville UPS Plane Crash Disclosed

The identities of the captain and crew members aboard the UPS aircraft…
Dishing With Diane: Sophia's Famous Pancakes off of I-65 in Merrillville, Indiana

Discover Sophia’s Renowned Pancakes: A Must-Visit Eatery Off I-65 in Merrillville, Indiana

In this week’s segment of “Dishing with Diane,” we’re thrilled to spotlight…
Wrestling fans shocked to learn WWE star's real age

Unveiling the Truth: WWE Fans Stunned by Superstar’s Real Age Revelation

In a surprising revelation, a popular WWE star has left pro-wrestling fans…
FAA flight reductions: Cuts tied to shutdown begin being phased in at 40 busy airports

FAA Begins Phasing in Flight Reductions at 40 Major Airports Amid Shutdown

In an effort to ensure travel safety amidst the ongoing government shutdown,…
5 things men need for a 'normal erection' — and a 'common complaint' for those with ED

Essential Factors for Maintaining a Healthy Erection: Addressing Common Concerns in Erectile Dysfunction

There’s no reason to succumb to a period of decline. In the…
My best friend was my bully. It's taboo to say, but it ruined my life

From Friendship to Bullying: How a Best Friend’s Betrayal Impacted My Life

One afternoon, I found myself at my best friend Evie’s house, gathered…