Elisabeth Moss is always one to take home some mementos when she wraps a project. But someone appears to have beaten her to the punch when The Handmaid’s Tale wrapped filming.

After admitting she takes “as much as possible” from set whenever she finishes a project, the Emmy-winning actress revealed during a recent appearance on Jimmy Kimmel Live that a crew member requested a pair of her character’s custom underwear after the show ended.

“There was one thing I wanted, which was Offred’s underwear set that I wore that was specially designed,” she explained. “And someone told me that someone already asked for it.”

Jimmy Kimmel was shocked. “Wait a minute. This is your custom underwear that you wore, and some creep on the staff requested it — in writing requested it?” he asked. “Like, ‘I want Elisabeth’s underpants. I’m gonna take ’em home. I’m gonna put ’em in storage for a while.’”

Moss joked that it would be the “best case scenario” if the person kept the underwear in storage. But, much to Kimmel’s surprise, Moss maintained that she doesn’t want to know who requested her underwear.

“You don’t? I wanna know! How do you not want to know?” Kimmel demanded.

“I went to work with these people,” Moss reminded him. “I don’t want to know who wants my underwear.”

“What kind of a crazy thing is that to say?” he fired back at the actress. “Oh my god, I hope it’s a woman.”

Moss mentioned that she always liked to take props and costumes from sets she’s worked on. She admitted to taking a chair from Mad Men to commemorate her time playing Peggy.

“I took my chair. The last chair that I sat in as Peggy, this purple chair,” she recalled. “But it’s not a very nice chair, so it’s just in storage. I don’t know what to do with it! I don’t know why I have a chair.”

Moss’ hit Hulu series will soon return with the sixth and final season, with the first three episodes premiering April 6.

New episodes of The Handmaid’s Tale will air on Tuesdays.