Karen Read jury selection: Dozens in pool already have an opinion on the case
Share and Follow

Jury selection kicked off Tuesday for the second trial of Karen Read, who is accused of murder and other charges for an alleged hit-and-run that left her boyfriend, Boston Police Officer John O’Keefe, dead in a blizzard in January 2022.

The 45-year-old’s first trial ended with a hung jury, and the judge later rejected multiple requests to dismiss the case.

This time around, nearly half of the first group of potential jurors told the judge they already have an opinion on the case.

Cannone on Monday ruled that Read’s defense cannot try and blame Albert’s nephew, Colin Albert, for the crime. 

A close-up of Karen Read smiling next to John O'Keefe wearing a white backwards hat.

Karen Read and John O’Keefe pose for an undated photograph. (Karen Read)

Other potential third-party culprits floated by the defense include Brian Albert himself and ATF Agent Brian Higgins, both of whom were present at the bar and the after-party. 

The judge said that Read’s defense cannot name them during opening statements – but they can introduce evidence during the trial that they believe points to them and not her.

Brian Albert wears a blue shirt, yellow tie and dark jacket on the witness stand

Witness Brian Albert testifies during the first trial of Karen Read at Norfolk County Superior Court, Friday, May 10, 2024, in Dedham, Mass.  (AP Photo/Charles Krupa, Pool)

Cannone also sided with prosecutors and blocked testimony from a former FBI agent named Michael Easter, who was expected to scrutinize alleged missteps from police in the investigation.

The lead investigator, former Massachusetts State Trooper Michael Proctor, was fired last month after an investigation into lewd text messages he sent about Read while probing O’Keefe’s death, which were read in court during her first trial.

Although he is no longer a trooper, his name is on the witness list the second time around – along with 149 other people. 

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Woman in Florida Barnes & Noble stabbed to death, police seek motive

Tragic Stabbing at Florida Barnes & Noble: Authorities Investigate Motive Behind Fatal Attack

Authorities in Florida are delving into the tragic death of a 65-year-old…
'Just blown away': Jacksonville family of nine overwhelmed by community support after house fire

Jacksonville Family of Nine Overcomes House Fire with Heartwarming Community Support

“It’s simply incredible what people can achieve with their kindness and the…
Newark Airport struck with ground delay on Christmas Eve

Christmas Eve Chaos: Newark Airport Faces Ground Delays Impacting Holiday Travelers

Newark Airport is experiencing significant ground delays as thousands rush to reunite…
Nursing home explosion in Bucks County, Pennsylvania leaves 1 resident, 1 employee dead

Tragic Bucks County Nursing Home Blast Claims Lives: Latest Updates and Safety Concerns

BRISTOL, Pa. — Search teams, including construction crews and drones, combed through…
'Miniature memory lane': Jacksonville father converts garage into neighborhood Christmas village display

Experience Holiday Magic: Jacksonville Dad Transforms Garage into Enchanting Christmas Village

What began as a simple holiday tradition for one man has blossomed…
The same Knicks issue is rearing its head once again

Unpacking the Knicks’ Recurring Struggles: Can They Overcome Their Persistent Challenges?

The Knicks are feeling the sting of early-season challenges. They’ve consistently struggled…
Brenda Spencer, Branndon Mosley arrested as teen escapes home, allegedes being held captive, sexual abuse in New Jersey

Colorado Mother Kimberlee Singler Extradited from UK Over Shocking Double Child Murder Allegations

In a tragic turn of events, a Colorado woman who had been…
Part of California State Route 138 washes away from flooding Wednesday, Dec. 24, 2025, outside of Wrightwood, Calif. (AP Photo/Wally Skalij)

Southern California Braces for More Rain as Christmas Day Storm Looms Over Already Waterlogged Region

LOS ANGELES (AP) — The intense winter storm that recently drenched Southern…