NY bill would ban cops from routine traffic stops like the one that nabbed a serial killer: 'Most dangerous' ever
Share and Follow

A recent proposal aims to prohibit police officers in the state from pulling over and searching drivers for minor infractions, including the offense that led to the apprehension of serial killer Joel Rifkin.

Law enforcement leaders are denouncing the bill introduced in Albany as the most extreme and illogical they have encountered, cautioning that it would restrict officers’ ability to conduct regular traffic stops, which often reveal more serious crimes.

Nassau County District Attorney Anne Donnelly expressed her astonishment, stating, “In my 36 years in law enforcement, I have never seen anything as absurd as this proposal.” She made these remarks during a press conference held on Friday at the police memorial in Mineola, Long Island.


District Attorney Anne T. Donnelly and Nassau County Police Commissioner Patrick Ryder addressing the media about a multi-million-dollar money laundering investigation in Mineola, NY
Nassau County District Attorney Anne Donnelly called the proposal “ridiculous.” Dennis A. Clark

The proposed legislation would no longer allow officers to stop or search drivers over such issues as busted head or tail lights, expired registrations and inspections, window tints and even the smell of marijuana.

Donnelly said she believes the bill would disproportionately impact Nassau County because of the region’s high number of drivers and car accidents, allowing scofflaws and criminals to essentially break the law and get away with it.

She brought up the fact that Rifkin murdered at least 17 people in the area before being uncovered in 1993 during a traffic stop over the missing license plate on the rear of his tan Mazda pick-up truck — which was hiding a body in its trunk.

“When an officer walks up to a driver and asks them for their license and registration — they never know what is going to happen next,” Donnelly said. “It’s important to be able to make these legitimate stops. There is no such thing as a routine traffic stop.”

But supporters of the bill argued it’s a necessary step toward promoting racial equity and preventing unnecessary police encounters, especially in Nassau — which has an active lawsuit against the county claiming that the police have “acted with racial bias” when making traffic stops.

Though black and Latino residents make up under 30% of the county’s population combined, police data show they account for 61% of arrests, 50% of traffic stops, 60% of field interviews and 69% of pat-downs.


Police officer from highway traffic patrol pulling over a vehicle and approaching the driver for license and registration.
The new bill would ban cops in the state from stopping and searching drivers over a slew of low-level violations. Gorodenkoff – stock.adobe.com

White drivers on average also receive 1.3 tickets per stop compared to two tickets for black drivers and 2.1 for Latino drivers.

Nassau County Executive Bruce Blakeman called that argument “ridiculous,” and said most of the time a stop is made, police are unaware of the driver’s race beforehand.

“It’s just a bizarre argument, it’s pro-criminal,” Blakeman said. “It doesn’t matter what race you are. If you’re breaking the law then you’re breaking the law.”

Nassau Police Commissioner Patrick Ryder said that most of the time, low-level infractions such as broken lights or expired registrations result in warnings, but not having the power to enforce the law makes the roads less safe.

“They say the roads are so bad in Nassau County. Well, you would just be taking another tool away from us that’s going to get these bad drivers off the road,” he said. “Stop taking the handcuffs off of the criminals and putting them onto our men and women in law enforcement.”

State Sen. Brady Hoylman-Sigal, who sponsored the bill, did not respond to The Post’s request for comment.

Gov. Kathy Hochul’s office did not respond, either.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
I fought the NYC 'Super Flu' with $12 Emergen-C from Amazon

Beating NYC’s ‘Super Flu’: How a $12 Amazon Emergen-C Purchase Made All the Difference

New York Post may be compensated and/or receive an affiliate commission if…
Anthony Joshua is injured in car crash in Nigeria

Anthony Joshua Survives Shocking Car Crash in Nigeria: Latest Updates on His Recovery

Anthony Joshua, the renowned former heavyweight world champion, recently found himself in…
What is lake effect snow?

Unveiling Lake Effect Snow: What It Is and How It Impacts Weather

Predicting lake effect snow is one of the most intriguing challenges facing…
Shooting at an Oklahoma State University residence hall wounds at least 3 people

Tragedy Strikes: Two New Jersey Pilots, Known for Their Cafe Visits, Die in Helicopter Collision

Two men, who tragically lost their lives in a helicopter collision over…
Russia calls for Zelensky to be killed and his body put on display

Russia Urges Extreme Measures Against Zelensky, Including Public Display

An ally close to Vladimir Putin has issued a chilling threat towards…
Jacksonville police investigating shooting in Pinecrest neighborhood off Normandy Boulevard

Jacksonville Police Probe Pinecrest Neighborhood Shooting Near Normandy Boulevard: Latest Updates

A Jacksonville Fire Rescue Department spokesperson reported that an adult sustained life-threatening…
Police sergeant denies hearing Luigi Mangione mother's alleged damning statement about CEO killing

Sergeant Disputes Claim of Hearing Key Statement in CEO Murder Case Involving Luigi Mangione’s Mother

A San Francisco police sergeant has clarified that he is not the…
JSO: Woman taken into custody after shooting boyfriend at Northside apartment complex

JSO Arrests Woman for Alleged Shooting of Boyfriend at Northside Apartment Complex

The Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office reported a shooting incident that took place in…