Florida kayak tour guide allegedly killed woman and ‘hid’ body inside room at Key Largo resort: officials
Share and Follow

A man in the Florida Keys was arrested after he allegedly killed a woman at a Key Largo resort and hid her body inside his room.

The Monroe County Sheriff’s Office said in a Facebook post that 33-year-old Dylan Lamb killed Nadyne Marie Tillman, 43, sometime over the weekend after the two had just met on Saturday morning at the Amoray Dive Resort in Key Largo, Florida.

Deputies said Tillman’s body was found “hidden” in Lamb’s room after she was killed with injuries that are “consistent with being beaten.”

Tillman’s family members reported her missing after they didn’t hear from the mother since Saturday morning, which wasn’t like her. Authorities said they found Tillman’s body on Monday morning inside Lamb’s room at the resort. Tillman leaves behind several children, who she talked about frequently on Facebook.

Nadyne Marie Tillman

Nadyne Marie Tillman pictured on a beach. Tillman was killed by Dylan Lamb, the Monroe County Sheriff’s Office alleges.

Nadyne Marie Tillman seen in a selfie wearing a dress.

Nadyne Marie Tillman had just met Dylan Lamb on Saturday, deputies said.

Online records show that Lamb was charged with homicide, kidnap-false imprisonment, evidence-destroying and procure for prostitute.

Ka Thigpen told NBC Miami that her mother was visiting for her wedding on Friday and stayed in the hotel room next to Lamb’s.

Thigpen said her mother saw Lamb as well as Tillman’s daughter, who was looking for her at the resort. Tillman’s phone showed that she was at the resort.

Amoray Dive Resort outside

Authorities said Nadyne Marie Tillman was killed at the Amoray Dive Resort. (Google Maps)

Victim found in motel room

Nadyne Marie Tillman was found dead inside a hotel room. (Facebook)

“It’s just scary, it’s too close to home,” Thigpen said. “It’s just really scary because you never know who you’re going to meet up with and that’s what everyone should maybe learn from this situation.”

Monroe County Sheriff Rick Ramsay said no other individuals appear to be involved.

“I want to thank the men and women of the Sheriff’s Office for working around the clock to make an arrest in this case,” Ramsay said. “While the investigation remains ongoing, there do not appear to be any other individuals involved in this incident.”

A spokesman for the Monroe County Sheriff declined to share additional information when contacted by Fox News Digital.

Lamb’s arraignment is scheduled for April 13.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Indiana judge shooting: Police arrest 3 on attempted murder charges, 2 others in custody

Indiana Judge Shooting: Authorities Arrest Three on Attempted Murder Charges, Detain Two Additional Suspects

Authorities in Indiana have apprehended five individuals in connection with the shooting…
RHONY alum Bethenny Frankel reveals chronic kidney disease diagnosis

Bethenny Frankel Opens Up About Chronic Kidney Disease Diagnosis: A Candid Look Into Her Health Journey

Bethenny Frankel has revealed that she is facing stage two chronic kidney…
Sherrone Moore court appearance: Lawyer for fired Michigan football coach seeks to have home invasion, stalking charges dismissed

Former Michigan Coach Sherrone Moore’s Lawyer Fights to Dismiss Home Invasion and Stalking Charges in Court Appearance

ANN ARBOR, Mich. — Sherrone Moore, the former University of Michigan football…
Treadmill recall expands to include about 47,000 units

Urgent Treadmill Recall Alert: Over 47,000 Units Affected – Check If Yours is on the List!

Johnson Health Tech North America has broadened its voluntary recall of Matrix…
U.S. Border Patrol Cmdr. Gregory Bovino speaks during a news conference Tuesday, Jan. 20, 2026, in Minneapolis. (AP Photo/Angelina Katsanis)

Chicago Man Acquitted: No Guilt in Alleged $10K Hit on Border Patrol Chief

CHICAGO (AP) — On Thursday, a man accused of placing a $10,000…
Tear gas is deployed as Federal agents make arrests on Wednesday, Jan. 21, 2026, in Minneapolis. (AP Photo/Angelina Katsanis)

Journalist Don Lemon Detained During Minnesota Church Protest Against ICE

MINNEAPOLIS (AP) — Authorities have arrested a well-known civil rights lawyer and…
Paul Correa talking to officers GIF

Arizona County Attorney Dismissed Following Shocking Allegations of Filming Minor and Engaging in Public Indecency

Authorities have unveiled footage capturing the moment police confronted a prominent attorney…
5 arrested in shooting of Indiana judge Judge Steven Meyer

Five Individuals Apprehended in Connection with Shooting of Indiana Judge Steven Meyer

In a shocking incident, five individuals have been apprehended in connection with…