St. Johns County woman pleads no contest to manslaughter in death of her 11-year-old son
Share and Follow


Michelle Taylor, 41, will be sentenced on second-degree manslaughter on May 30 for the death of her 11-year-old son, David Eugene Taylor.

ST. JOHNS COUNTY, Fla. — A St. Johns County woman pleaded no contest to second-degree manslaughter last week, April 2, in connection to the death of her 11-year-old child, who died in a house fire in October 2018, court records show.

Michelle Taylor, 41, will have an arson charge dismissed by the state during her sentencing on May 30 in the case, according to a court document. The document also says that the state will recommend a sentence of anywhere between three to 13 years, with credit for time served.

On Oct. 23, 2018, a teen called 911, telling them that there was a fire at her home, located in the 1000 block of Lee Street, and that her younger sibling was trapped inside, according to the St. Johns County Sheriff’s Office (SJSO).

Deputies later arrived and tried to enter the home to save the child, but the heat and smoke prevented them from going inside, the sheriff’s office told First Coast News. Eventually, firefighters discovered the burned remains of an 11-year-old child inside the home, SJSO said.

Family members confirmed the child as Taylor’s son, David Eugene Taylor. His great-uncle Mark Hall told First Coast News that David was a student at R. J. Murray Middle School.

Hall said Taylor and her 18-year-old daughter at the time made it out of the house when the fire broke out, but that David went back in to try and save a dog. The dog was able to make it out of the house.

“He [probably] breathed the smoke in and passed out,” Hall said about David.

Local, state and federal authorities then began investigating the fire’s cause and origin. Investigators found that there was gasoline in samples taken from the home, hinting at arson, according to SJSO.

Investigators later identified Taylor as the arsonist, with her motive being to collect insurance money, SJSO said.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Family rescues diamondback terrapins from storm drains

Family saves diamondback terrapins trapped in storm drains

VENTNOR, New Jersey — Since she was a kid, Evelyn Kidd has…
Accidental ejection seat activation lead to pilot's 2024 death: Report

Report reveals pilot’s 2024 death caused by accidental ejection seat activation

SHEPPARD AFB (KFDX/KJTL) One year after the death of an instructor pilot…
What we know about suspected sniper in Idaho firefighter ambush

Insights on the individual suspected of being a sniper in the Idaho firefighter attack

() The gunman accused of fatally shooting two firefighters and wounding a…
Firefighters ambushed in Coeur d'Alene shooting

Firefighters attacked in surprise shooting in Coeur d’Alene

A shelter-in-place order was lifted after the Kootenai County Sheriff’s Office said…
Police reveal contents of mysterious black packages that washed up on pristine Florida beach

Police reveal contents of mysterious black packages that washed up on pristine Florida beach

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! As Yosemite Sam would…
Bryan Kohberger accepts plea deal in Idaho college murders case

Bryan Kohberger agrees to a plea bargain in Idaho murder case involving college students

() has learned a plea deal has been offered to Bryan Kohberger,…
Idaho murders victims' families blast Bryan Kohberger plea deal

Families of Idaho murder victims criticize plea deal offered to Bryan Kohberger

The family of one of Bryan Kohberger’s victims who was taken by…
Rochelle Humes, Marvin, Eddie Redmayne and Hannah at Wimbledon

Attending Wimbledon: Rochelle Humes, Marvin Humes, Eddie Redmayne, and Hannah

The stars were all out in London’s heatwave on Monday to attend…