Judge orders Trump officials’ depositions, blasts inaction in Abrego Garcia case
Share and Follow


GREENBELT, Md. — A federal judge Tuesday ordered depositions from several Trump officials, blasting the administration for failing to take any steps to secure the return of a Maryland man mistakenly deported to a Salvadoran prison.

During a hearing, U.S. District Court Judge Paula Xinis repeatedly clashed with Drew Ensign, an attorney with the Justice Department, as the judge contended the government had flouted her orders demanding updates on efforts to facilitate Kilmar Abrego Garcia’s return.

“What the record shows is that nothing has been done. Nothing. I asked for reports from individuals with direct knowledge and I’ve gotten very little information of any value,” the judge said, noting that she gave “a very simple directive” for updates on steps the government had taken.

Xinis, an Obama appointee, said she was holding off at this juncture on deciding whether the government should be held in contempt but would still rule down the road. 

For now, the judge ordered the administration to respond to interrogatories and document production requests. She also ordered the four government officials who signed affidavits in the case to sit for depositions by April 23, giving Abrego Garcia’s lawyers a chance to question key immigration officials in the administration.

But Ensign signaled the administration may assert legal privileges to avoid at least one of the depositions. He also suggested the government may appeal Xinis’s order, saying “we dont believe discovery is appropriate.”

“You lost. This is now about the scope of the remedy,” Xinis said, adding that there was nothing to appeal.

Abrego Garcia was protected under a 2019 immigration court ruling from being deported to El Salvador, and the Trump administration has acknowledged mistakenly deporting him there last month. Based on an informant, the administration accuses the man of being a part of MS-13, but Abrego Garcia’s family contests any gang ties.

The hearing was largely focused on whether the Trump administration had complied with a Supreme Court ruling that largely upheld an earlier order from Xinis, saying they must “facilitate” his return from CECOT, a notorious prison in El Salvador known by its acronym in Spanish.

Ensign said Xinis should consider the term in the narrower sense used in immigration law, suggesting the U.S. could only help the imprisoned man if he were able to escape CECOT and present himself before U.S. officials.

The Trump administration had also argued that they are unable to push a foreign country to release someone in their custody – though the U.S. has paid El Salvador $6 million to imprison Abrego Garcia and more than 200 other men at CECOT.

“If he appears at a port of entry or U.S. embassy we will facilitate his return,” Ensign said.

Xinis responded that the argument “flies in the face of the plain meaning of the word.”

“The bottom line is it was a very simple directive. My question, that the high court squarely affirmed I can ask, is what have you done? I’ve gotten nothing. I’ve gotten no real response, nor have I gotten any legitimate reason.”

Ensign also pointed to an Oval Office meeting between President Trump and Salvadoran President Nayib Bukele in which the Central American leader said he would not return Abrego Garcia.

Xinis said she did not understand why the Justice Department had submitted a transcript of the meeting as it did not answer her question about what efforts were being undertaken. A portion of the meeting was on camera, in front of reporters.

“No press release is going to move the court,” she said.

Xinis suggested a fast pace for the depositions and review of discovery – something that would ultimately put her on a path to determining whether to hold anyone from the Trump administration in contempt.

“We’re going to move. There will be no tolerance for gamesmanship and grandstanding,” she said.

“There are no business hours while we do this – there are going to be two intense weeks of discovery,” she added later.

“Cancel vacation, cancel other appointments. I’m usually pretty good about that in my courtroom, but not this time. It won’t be a convenience issue.”

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Eric Dier Hesitant to Exit Monaco Amid Premier League Interest; Manchester United Striker in Talks for Bradford Loan; Aston Villa Considering Departure of £21m Signing After Just One Year: Transfer Window Updates

The transfer window is now open, and fresh updates have emerged from…

Mamdani Expresses Strong Opposition Following ICE Detainment of New York City Council Staffer

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani (D) has voiced strong disapproval…

Trump Warns of Economic Fallout if SCOTUS Blocks Tariffs; Kevin Hassett Suggests Alternatives

Anticipation is high among market analysts as they await the U.S.…

Conservative Figure Reveals Startling Truth Behind His Decision to Leave Teaching at Liberal University

The challenges facing the American education system continue to spark heated…

Tucker Carlson’s Latest Look Fuels Speculation About Ozempic Use

Tucker Carlson’s noticeable transformation has fueled speculation that the well-known political commentator…

Minnesota Challenges Trump Administration: Seeks Judicial Intervention Over Controversial ICE Policies

More than five years have passed since the George Floyd protests…

Urgent Travel Advisory: Americans in Iran Urged to Depart Amid Rising Tensions and New Tariffs

On Monday, Americans residing in Iran were urged to leave the country…

Minneapolis Sees Surge in Attacks Targeting Federal Agents

Federal agents stationed in the Twin Cities have faced nearly two dozen…