The Pitt’s Creator Revealed Two Canceled Storylines That Might Return For Season 2

Share and Follow

Thanks to the mammoth success of The Pitt, there are millions of fans of the TV show that know that it tackled serious social issues. After all, on top of featuring positive male role models, The Pitt’s first season also chronicled how legal troubles can ensnare people and how doctors can suffer from emotional breakdowns. Despite the important issues The Pitt’s first season touched on, some planned storylines for the show were dropped.

Fortunately for fans and Noah Wyle, who must be getting rich, many of the show’s characters will be returning for The Pitt’s planned second season. According to The Pitt’s creator, two storylines that were left out of the show’s first season might return during the second season too.

Two Canceled The Pitt Season 1 Storylines May Come Back For Season 2

During the first season of The Pitt, fans were given a staggering insight into how intense being an emergency room doctor can be. One of the ways that the show accomplished that admirable goal was by having the show’s doctors be forced to cope with a slew of real-life issues.

Considering how much The Pitt’s doctors had coming at them, it makes sense that show’s producers didn’t include more. After all, having The Pitt address more serious social issues may have made it hard for the show to be as nuanced as it was.

As it turns out, there were other storylines that the team behind The Pitt were considering tackling during the first season that were dropped. In addition to talking about the dropped plot lines, The Pitt’s creator and executive producer revealed the storylines might return during Season 2.

In April 2025, TV Insider interviewed The Pitt’s creator and executive producer, R. Scott Gemmill.

Screen Rant’s Most Realistic Medical Shows, According to Real Doctors
The Most Realistic Medical Shows	Rank
Code Black	#5
House M.D.	#4
Scrubs	#3
ER	#2
The Pitt	#1

During that discussion, R. Scott described two The Pitt potential storylines that were considered for the first season before the show’s team decided to drop them.

We didn’t do an Ozempic story that we had talked about. We didn’t do some things about immigration, which we didn’t get into.

Considering that Ozempic has been one of the most talked-about subjects related to the medical field, many producers would have wanted to tackle that for attention. The fact that the team behind The Pitt decided against going down that route seems to show they are prioritizing storytelling above all else.

One of the best things about TV shows is that when they are successful, they return and become ongoing stories. As a result, when a television storyline is dropped for whatever reason, that doesn’t necessarily mean that it has to be gone forever.

In March 2025, The Pitt’s creator and executive producer, R. Scott Gemmill, told The Television Academy why he worked on a medical drama again after previously producing ER. “For me, it came out of a conversation with another writer about why I would never do a medical show again, because we had done it so well. Anything we approached would be compared to that — unless there was a way to do it new and fresh that made it feel like it was worthy.”

During that same conversation with TV Insider, R. Scott mentioned that the storylines that were dropped during The Pitt season 1 could return during the second season. At the same time, R. Scott also suggested that the storylines could be brought back further down the line.

So, there’s lots of things for us to go back to, and some will make their way this year and some will get put in and then get punted down the line. It’s just the way that is.

As exciting as it is to learn about what might happen on The Pitt in the future, R. Scott told TV Insider something else that arguably was more fascinating.

The Pitt’s Best Characters, According to Collider
The Pitt Character	Rank
Dennis Whitaker	#10
Victoria Javadi	#9
Dr. Trinity Santos	#8
Dr. Cassie McKay	#7
Dr. Samira Mohan	#6
Dr. Frank Langdon	#5
Dana Evans	#4
Dr. Mel King	#3
Dr. Heather Collins	#2
Dr. Michael “Robby” Robinavitch	#1

While talking to the outlet, R. Scott explained why those two storylines were excluded from The Pitt Season 1.

“[There were] lots of stories that didn’t make it [into Season 1]. A lot of patient stories where we just ran out of real estate, page count, and stuff like that.”

While considering that there are only so many stories that can be told during a season of The Pitt, the next question is how the decisions about which plot lines to drop are made.

During his discussion with TV Insider, R. Scott explained how The Pitt’s producers decide which storylines to keep in the show, and which to remove.

“It’s really about picking and choosing what we want to tell and what we think is going to have the most impact.”

Warrick Page/Max via Warner Bros. Discovery

No matter how the team behind The Pitt decided which stories to tackle, it seems very clear that their instincts were correct.

The Pitt’s Creator And Star Revealed That There Will Likely Be Lots Of Time To Tell Stories On The Show

During the aforementioned TV Insider discussion with R. Scott Gemmill, Noah Wyle was a part of the discussion as well. While talking to the outlet, both men revealed that there would likely be a lot of opportunities to bring canceled The Pitt storylines back.

First off, Noah explained to the outlet that he wants to continue starring in The Pitt for years. Noah told TV Insider that he’d star in The Pitt “as long as you’ll have me.”

During the same discussion, R. Scott explained that he is the type of person who would continue to work on a show that he cares about for a long time.

“That’s up to you guys. It’s not up to me. I have a reputation of, once I get settled, I don’t go anywhere, so I’ll be here until they turn the lights out.”

R. Scott also explained why there will be lots of stories for The Pitt to tell in the future.