Foolish dad allegedly Googled 'murder defenses' after killing partner
Share and Follow

A Missouri man allegedly turned to Google for legal advice just moments after brutally killing of his child’s mother.

Karl Mayberry, aged 34, has been charged with the murder of his partner, Alvatyne Thomas, who was 31 years old, in December 2021. Following the incident, he allegedly turned to the internet to search for information on ‘first-degree murder defenses’ and ‘whether hearsay can be used as evidence in a murder case in Missouri’, as detailed in a legal document known as an affidavit.

Mayberry, who shares a child with Thomas, was taken into custody on Wednesday and charged with first-degree murder in connection to the 2021 homicide. 

Thomas, the mother of Mayberry’s child, was found dead on December 27, 2021, by St. Louis Metropolitan police during a welfare check at her Oregon Avenue apartment in St. Louis.

Upon arriving at the scene, police said they entered the home when they saw Thomas, already deceased with ‘a plastic bag taped around her head.’

‘She had been shot in the back and had extreme swelling to her forehead, a severed ear and apparent defensive wounds on her hands,’ the affidavit states. 

‘She appeared to have had bleach poured over her body as well.’

Karl Mayberry, 34, is accused of murdering his partner, Alvatyne Thomas (pictured), 31, in December 2021, then searching online for 'first-degree murder defenses' and 'can he say she say be used against a person for murder in Missouri'

Karl Mayberry, 34, is accused of murdering his partner, Alvatyne Thomas (pictured), 31, in December 2021, then searching online for ‘first-degree murder defenses’ and ‘can he say she say be used against a person for murder in Missouri’

Mayberry, who shares a child with Thomas, was taken into custody on Wednesday and charged with first-degree murder in connection to the 2021 homicide

Mayberry, who shares a child with Thomas, was taken into custody on Wednesday and charged with first-degree murder in connection to the 2021 homicide

Authorities say Mayberry initially claimed he had been at work during the time of Thomas’s death, however, coworkers disputed his alibi, telling police he disappeared for several hours that day, only to return in different clothes and appearing visibly distressed.

‘Officers interviewed multiple co-workers, who stated the defendant had disappeared for hours during the timeframe in question,’ the affidavit reads. 

‘When he returned, he was in different clothing and appeared emotionally distraught.’

Mayberry also allegedly sent a message to someone claiming that Thomas was ‘found dead in the kitchen with a plastic bag wrapped around her head’ – a detail that had not yet been made public.

He has also been accused of sending texts to criminal defense attorney asking how much it would cost ‘to defend a murder.’

During the years-long investigation, Thomas’s family told police she had been in an abusive relationship with Mayberry, Law and Crime reported.

Following Mayberry’s Wednesday arrest, Thomas’ sisters expressed a mix of relief and frustration, saying they were grateful charges had finally been filed, but questioned why it had taken over three years for justice to be served.

Thomas, the mother of Mayberry's child, was found dead on December 27, 2021, by St. Louis Metropolitan police during a welfare check at her Oregon Avenue apartment in St. Louis

Thomas, the mother of Mayberry’s child, was found dead on December 27, 2021, by St. Louis Metropolitan police during a welfare check at her Oregon Avenue apartment in St. Louis

Thomas' Oregon Avenue apartment in St. Louis

Thomas’ Oregon Avenue apartment in St. Louis

Thomas and Mayberry pictured together with their daughter, Starla

Thomas and Mayberry pictured together with their daughter, Starla

‘I already knew he had a part in it. There was nobody else that would do that to her,’ Thomas’ younger sister, Dewanna Coleman, told FirstAlert4.

‘I stayed on it. I stayed watching the news. Yes, he should have been charged because you had evidence right then and there. The day you called the family, y’all told us y’all had evidence,’ Thomas’ other sister, Cheneish Johnson, said.

Johnson added that she’s ‘happy’ about Mayberry’s arrest, but doesn’t feel ‘justice will ever be served’ for the brutal slaying.

‘I’m happy, but at the same time, I don’t feel justice will be ever served. She’s gone and we’ll never get her back. The kids will never see her again, yet he still gets to eat, take a bath, use the bathroom,’ Johnson, said.

Mayberry remains held without bond at the St. Louis Justice Center.

Court records show he was on federal probation at the time of Thomas’s death due to prior convictions for assault and being a felon in possession of a firearm, according to Law & Crime.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Australian PM Anthony Albanese apologizes to Jewish community after Bondi Beach terror attack, feels 'weight of responsibility'

Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese Issues Apology to Jewish Community, Acknowledges ‘Weight of Responsibility’ Following Bondi Beach Terror Incident

Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese issued an apology to the Jewish community…
A sharps disposal bin to safely discard used syringes and lancets is installed in Austin, Ind., by the Scott County Health Department Tuesday, Nov. 23, 2025. (AP Photo/Obed Lamy)

Community Faces Challenges in Sustaining Vital Syringe Program Amid New Regulations

In Jeffersonville, Indiana, a storage room at the Clark County Health Department…
Chicago firefighter, another person injured after West Side church fire spreads to another building at N. Lotus Ave., W. Huron St.

Chicago Firefighter and Civilian Injured as West Side Church Blaze Extends to Adjacent Building on N. Lotus Ave. and W. Huron St.

A blaze erupted on Sunday night, injuring a Chicago firefighter and another…
More frozen shrimp sold in several states recalled over possible radioactive contamination

Alert: Frozen Shrimp Recalled Across Multiple States Due to Potential Radioactive Risk

A recall has been issued for approximately 83,800 bags of frozen shrimp…
Woman behind bombshell Miley Cyrus 'adoption' lawsuit breaks silence

Key Figure in Miley Cyrus ‘Adoption’ Controversy Speaks Out

A nostalgic photograph captures a moment of familial pride: a young girl…
Senate stares down fraught health care battle with ObamaCare subsidies set to expire

Senate Faces Critical Showdown as ObamaCare Subsidies Near Expiration, Threatening Healthcare Access

As lawmakers head home for the holidays, the Senate is poised for…
Once-thriving shopping mall is eerily empty on Sunday before Christmas

Deserted Mall: A Surprising Sight Just Days Before Christmas

In a stark contrast to its bustling past, a once-celebrated shopping mall…
Barry Manilow, 82, reveals he is battling lung cancer

Barry Manilow, 82, Courageously Faces Lung Cancer Battle: Iconic Singer’s Health Update

On Monday morning, Barry Manilow disclosed via an Instagram post that he…