Generic Coles Supermarket shoppers, cash, shopping, retail, spending, inflation, Easter rush. Thursday 28th March 2024 AFR photo Louie Douvis
Share and Follow

One Aussie shopper has brought the nation’s receipt laws under the microscope after they were asked to produce a receipt for a product they had bought elsewhere.

Posing the question to the AusLegal page on Reddit, the frustrated customer in said they walked into a Victorian Coles with a trolley full of groceries from Aldi.

“I had a trolley full of items I had bought at Aldi, and popped into Coles for a few bits,” the poster said.

Generic Coles Supermarket shoppers, cash, shopping, retail, spending, inflation, Easter rush. Thursday 28th March 2024 AFR photo Louie Douvis
If a customer walks into Coles with an item they bought from Aldi, can a security guard or worker demand to see a receipt to prove they haven’t stolen anything?  (Louie Douvis)

“The lady at the self-checkout pointed at the 30-pack of Coke cans and demanded to see a receipt to prove I didn’t steal it.

“I said I didn’t have one, I never keep receipts unless it’s for an expensive purchase that I may need to refund/exchange.

“She continued insisting that I had to keep my receipts from other stores so that I could prove I hadn’t stolen.”

9News.com.au asked criminal defence attorney and author of Talk Your Way Out of Trouble, Jahan Kalantar, the question.

Turns out supermarkets have little to no power to demand a receipt from a customer.

“The law does not give private retailers like Coles and Woolworths any legal authority to compel you to produce proof of purchase for goods that you bought somewhere else,” Kalantar said.

”If the store thinks that you’ve stolen, they can request to inspect your bags, but security guards really don’t have much power; all they can do is get the police involved.

“If they keep people there against their will, if the Coles worker keeps you there, there’s a possibility that it might be a false imprisonment claim.”

The law does not give private retailers like Coles and Woolworths any legal authority to compel you to produce proof of purchase for goods. (Alex Ellinghausen)

Kalantar said most people would just comply and show their receipt to get out of the situation.

There is a bit of a grey area if you paid cash or don’t have a receipt, if they suspect you’ve stolen an item.

“I had one where the guy didn’t have his receipt, but he just opened his bank account and said here is the transaction, I couldn’t have taken it,” Kalantar said.

“But fundamentally, you are entitled to your privacy, just because you walk into a store and they have some assumption doesn’t mean anything.

“It’s very different if they’ve seen you on camera pocketing something, but there is no fundamental legal authority that a security guard can compel you to provide a receipt from a different store.”

9News.com.au has contacted Coles for comment.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Victoria unveils extensive changes following reported childcare abuse

This article contains references to child abuse. Victorian Premier Jacinta Allan has…
Kelly Smythe was one of Australian high society's 'It' girls in the early 2000s. Now fallen fashion maven's extraordinary texts emerge in row over an ultra-rare Hermès handbag

Kelly Smythe, a prominent figure in Australian high society during the early 2000s, is now making headlines due to the release of her remarkable messages regarding a highly coveted Hermès handbag.

A one-time society ‘It girl’ turned luxury fashion maven has been accused…
Dalai Lama ends years of speculation with move set to annoy China

Dalai Lama finally takes action after much talk, likely to upset China

The Dalai Lama has announced that he will have a successor after…
Port Adelaide defender Brandon Zerk-Thatcher has had to flee his home in Glenelg East as a fire threatened to set the property aflame.

Port Adelaide football player had to run away from a fire in the early morning.

Port Adelaide defender Brandon Zerk-Thatcher has had to flee his home in…
Fallen WA Police officer Anthony Woods

Man who killed well-known police officer in car theft incident sentenced to prison

Reagan Ainslie Chown, 25, was convicted of manslaughter over the late-night June…
Man hit by car in Mount Pritchard in Sydney's south-west

Partially sighted man critically injured after being struck by a car near his residence

A man is fighting for his life in hospital after being hit…
Seven missing after fireworks warehouse explodes in US

Seven individuals unaccounted for following explosion at firework storage facility in the United States

Seven people are missing following an explosion at a fireworks warehouse in…
Tammy Hembrow slammed for wild act in New Zealand following Matt Zukowski split: 'Why would you put your life in danger?'

Tammy Hembrow Under Fire for Risky Behavior in New Zealand After Breakup with Matt Zukowski

Tammy Hembrow has been criticised for bungee jumping in New Zealand following…