Trump vs. Harvard and the 'academic brain drain' myth
Share and Follow

Has President Donald Trump declared war on Albert Einstein?

“America is in danger of experiencing an academic brain drain,” The Economist warns.

When the Department of Homeland Security made the decision to prohibit Harvard University from accepting foreign students, Ian Bremmer from the Eurasia Group, a political scientist with strong ties in Washington, expressed his approval by calling it a great opportunity for China.

The government is trying to use its leverage over foreign students’ immigration status to compel Harvard to adopt stricter policies against antisemitism and scrap racially charged “diversity, equity, and inclusion” initiatives.

But this isn’t just another battle in America’s culture war: Foreign-policy mavens like Bremmer say what the administration is doing threatens national security and America’s technological edge over its rivals.

The Manhattan Project was a success thanks to émigré geniuses who contributed a great deal more to America’s World War II effort, and subsequent struggle with the Soviet Union, than just the atomic bomb.

And isn’t it true that something like 40% of Fortune 500 companies were started by immigrants?

Liberals might support high immigration levels, and large numbers of foreign students in particular, simply because they like the new and unfamiliar — though it’s hard not to notice that foreign students typically pay more tuition and pad the bottom line of our colleges and universities, just as immigration on the whole gives liberals opportunities to court newcomers with social services and identity politics.

Yet supposedly hard-headed realists say it’s not liberal ideology but America’s need for more scientists and entrepreneurs that’s the real reason we have to open our campuses (and borders) to the world’s talents.

After all, if we don’t do that, where else are we going to get the brains we need to compete with China?

The trouble with this tale, which is an article of faith for The Economist and the likes of Bremmer, is that it’s patently false — and largely intended to deceive.

In fact, very few companies on the Fortune 500 were started solely by immigrants; almost all were founded by Americans, occasionally in partnership with émigrés.

The source for the factoid, the American Immigration Council, has to fudge the numbers by lumping “children of immigrants” into the same category as “immigrants,” even when those children are born American citizens.

As for competing with China, how can it be that China itself is so competitive when it accepts relatively few foreign students or immigrants?

China, with a native population of more than 1.4 billion people, had only about 258,000 foreign students enrolled in degree-granting programs before COVID-19.

And while China sometimes claims to have nearly 500,000 foreign students overall, nearly half that number appear to be in non-degree programs: They’re not even full-time students, let alone Einsteins.

China’s economic and military competitiveness is home-grown, not a result of harvesting engineers from India.

America has a great many foreign-born Nobel Prize winners, to be sure.

But when America, and America’s campuses, have had more restrictive attitudes toward migration in the past, they have nonetheless competed, and won, at the highest levels — while developing countries, even when their most talented individuals have not been able to migrate, have not risen to America’s levels.

That’s not because individual talent doesn’t matter; it does, and the most truly exceptional minds, such as Einstein’s or other Nobel laureates’, should not only be welcomed by America but actively courted by us.

But where most people are concerned, even most people of above-average talent, the national environment counts more.

This is why the outlook of The Economist is so dangerous to America: It encourages lowered expectations of Americans themselves, with more disciplined if not more talented immigrants picking up the slack.

That’s the real brain drain: It’s draining the world’s intellectual capital to make up for self-imposed habits of failure in America.

The talented foreign student turns into an excuse for having Americans waste their own talents — not least by studying the kinds of highly ideological subjects that give rise to wokeness, antisemitism and “diversity, equity, and inclusion” in the first place.

The Trump administration faces another fierce fight in the courts over its attempt to revoke Harvard’s ability to host international students.

It’s a heavy-handed remedy, though perhaps nothing short of such pressure will be enough.

The most elite institutions of higher education in this country have long been a force unto themselves, even as they receive hundreds of millions of dollars from taxpayers and enjoy privileges for importing workers and customers — foreign talent and students — most businesses could only dream of.

A reckoning is overdue.

But Trump’s brawl with Harvard isn’t just about an institution — it’s also about the ideas that have led Americans to think they can’t succeed anymore, they can only import someone else to succeed in their place.

Daniel McCarthy is the editor of Modern Age: A Conservative Review.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Victoria and David make first public comments since Brooklyn rant

Victoria and David Beckham Break Silence on Brooklyn’s Public Outburst: A Family’s First Response

David and Victoria Beckham have recently opened up about cherished memories with…
Trans lawmaker killed by ulcers doctor says were caused by job stress

Transgender Lawmaker Succumbs to Ulcers, Doctor Attributes Cause to Job-Related Stress

A transgender lawmaker from Oregon, Claire Hall, passed away following severe internal…
Trump threatens Canada with 100% tariffs if it makes a deal with China

Trump Warns Canada of 100% Tariffs Amid Potential Trade Deal with China

President Donald Trump has issued a stark warning to Canada, cautioning that…
Trump posts 'loaded gun' image after federal agent kills man, 37

Trump Shares Provocative Image Following Fatal Shooting by Federal Agent

On Saturday, Donald Trump posted an image of what he claimed to…
Elite Moscow university offers students bonuses to join Russian military, with bogus claims of non-combat positions

Prestigious Moscow University Entices Students with Incentives to Enlist in Russian Military, Misleadingly Promoting Non-Combat Roles

In an effort to draw students into non-combat roles, a leading Moscow…
Chaos erupts in Minneapolis as agents fire tear gas at protesters

Minneapolis Unrest: Tear Gas Deployed Amid Intense Protests, Sparking Citywide Tensions

A wave of protests has led to multiple arrests in Minneapolis following…
Rachael Leigh Cook Reveals ‘Caught By Love’ Wrapped Two Weeks Before The Louvre Robbery: “I Cannot Believe The Similarities”

Rachael Leigh Cook Shares Eerie Timing of ‘Caught By Love’ Filming and Recent Louvre Heist

Rachael Leigh Cook, a familiar face in romantic comedies, is back in…
'Rioters bite off' officer's finger after deadly Minneapolis shooting

Officer Severely Injured Amid Unrest Following Fatal Minneapolis Shooting

In a dramatic escalation of tensions in Minneapolis, two individuals involved in…