You probably don't know the right way to say the names of these Long Island towns: 'Butchered'
Share and Follow

This will have you spit out your “cawffee.”

If someone mispronounces the names of local communities in Long Island, it often gives away that they are not from there. Surprisingly, even longtime residents from the area with the area codes 516 and 631 get it wrong at times.

Even sports teams like the New York Islanders and Long Island Ducks have shared videos where players from outside the area struggle to pronounce names like Wantagh and Patchogue correctly.

Mispronunciations are not limited to outsiders, as even residents can have trouble with names like Massapequa and Ronkonkoma. Over the centuries, these names have been anglicized, making their original pronunciations, which are based on Native-American languages, unfamiliar to many today.

“Our language wasn’t written in the sense of being translated into English or French — the sound is what they’re trying to copy,” Wallace, based on on the island, told The Post.

He compared how Algonquian is the root base of many different Native American languages, some of which were spoken on Long Island, much like the Romance languages, such as French, Spanish, and Italian, all of which stem from Latin.

However, during colonial times, much was lost in translation because the European settlers “didn’t know how to spell,” especially with hard consonants like the letter “H,” which are vital to the Algonquian language, he added.

From there, readers would only see, but not hear, the real pronunciation. Ultimately, it turned into a telephone game that has been ongoing for a few hundred years.

Wallace recognizes that there’s no one official way to sound out some towns, such as Wantagh, which islanders say as “wan-tah.”

And the local way of saying Patchogue as “patch-hog” is pretty close to its origin, he said.

These, however, are some Native American-named local towns that even the most bona fide residents are getting wrong, according to Wallace.

Copiague

Townsfolk and the recorded voice on the Long Island Railroad alike sound out this Suffolk community as “co-peg,” but really it should be pronounced closer to “co-pi-ah-e” with a short “I” and long “E,” he explained.

“[Europeans] would elongate the A when they read it…and that’s all they would hear after,” Wallace added of what translates loosely to grove or forest.

Massapequa

The town that has caught the eye of President Trump over as it fights to keep its Chiefs team logo in the face of a state ban on Native American mascots isn’t straightforwardly pronounced “Mass-a-pequa,” said Wallace, who opposes the school using the name.

As with other Algonquin hard consonants, the real sound is “Mass-a-peek” without the open vowels at the end, he added, explaining that it means place of great water.

Cutchogue

Unlike Patchogue, residents aren’t remotely close to getting the pronunciation of the quiet North Fork escape spot on.

While it’s spoken today as “cutch-hog,” Wallace said the real way is “cutch-e-hoki,” spelled as “kecheahki.”

In the same vein as Massapequa, it translates to mean great place.

Setauket

Similar to Cutchogue, Setauket, spoken like Secaucus in New Jersey, is a world apart from its perceived pronunciation.

Wallace says it as “Se-tau-ah-ki” and added its definition is place of streams, something the north shore enclave by the Long Island Sound is known for.

Ronkonkoma

That’s right, Long Island’s showstopper that’s been a punchline on “How I Met Your Mother” and an Artie Lange monologue on an insufferable Yankees fan “has been butchered,” Wallace said.

Its prototypical “Ron-cahnk-ama” pronunciation — which Neil Patrick Harris projected on the LIRR 2 a.m. drunk train in the sitcom — should be “Ronkon-koman,” he explained.

The town name derives from its kettle lake, formed by the glacier that carved North America, which was sacred to its native population.

One translation for Ronkonkoma is “deep cavern place” in reference to the lake, which is tied to urban legends of hauntings and drownings attributed to a Native American-related curse — a story Wallace has explicitly called bunk on.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Chicago police, Mayor Brandon Johnson address safety concerns for July 4, 2025 weekend after River North mass shooting

Chicago authorities and Mayor Brandon Johnson discuss safety for July 4, 2025 weekend following mass shooting in River North

CHICAGO (WLS) — Chicago leaders on Thursday addressed concerns about safety during…
Gov. Greg Abbott officially names Texarkana as Film Friendly

“Texarkana Designated as Film Friendly by Gov. Greg Abbott”

TEXARKANA, Tx. (KTAL/KMSS) – Texarkana will now join more than 200 Film…
How to prepare for a hurricane, as forecasters expect a busy 2025 storm season

Getting ready for a hurricane: Experts predict a hectic storm season in 2025

HOUSTON (AP) — Hurricane season can be stressful for millions of Americans…
UFC confirms Trump's plan to host a fight at White House in 2026

UFC Confirms Trump’s Intention to Host Fight at White House in 2026

The UFC plans to host a fight card on the White House…
Osasis reunion tour kicks off with Cardiff, Wales performance

Osasis begins their reunion tour with a performance in Cardiff, Wales.

It’s the band’s first performance in 16 years and will be followed…
Chelsea benefits from Palmeiras own goal to reach FIFA Club World Cup semifinals

Chelsea advances to FIFA Club World Cup semifinals with the help of an own goal by Palmeiras

Chelsea advanced to the Club World Cup semifinals with a 2-1 victory…
Inside Donald and Melania's festive Fourth of July weekend plans

What Donald and Melania have in store for their Fourth of July celebrations

Flags, fireworks and a ferris wheel. Children splashing and shouting in the…
Environmental Protection Agency union alleges political retaliation after Chicago EPA workers put on leave after criticizing Trump

Union representing Environmental Protection Agency workers in Chicago claims political retaliation following employees being placed on leave for criticizing President Trump

CHICAGO (WLS) — The ABC7 I-Team is delving into allegations of political…