Appeals court allows Trump to keep National Guard deployed, for now 
Share and Follow


A federal appeals court panel late Thursday allowed President Trump to keep the National Guard deployed in Los Angeles, for now. 

The three-judge 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals panel unanimously extended its pause of a judge’s order finding Trump’s deployment illegal and forcing him to return control of the troops to California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D). 

“We emphasize, however, that our decision addresses only the facts before us. And although we hold that the President likely has authority to federalize the National Guard, nothing in our decision addresses the nature of the activities in which the federalized National Guard may engage,” the appeals panel wrote in its unsigned, 38-page decision. 

The panel said it disagreed with the administration that Trump’s decision isn’t reviewable by the courts, but the judges acknowledged they must be “highly deferential.” 

“Affording the President that deference, we conclude that it is likely that the President lawfully exercised his statutory authority,” the opinion reads. 

Trump has sent in thousands of National Guard troops to protect immigration officers in the wake of recent protests in Los Angeles, which at times have devolved into violence. The move quickly sparked a lawsuit from Newsom and the state’s attorney general. 

Though the 9th Circuit’s decision marks a victory for Trump in the legal battle, it may be short-lived. U.S. District Judge Charles Breyer, who issued last week’s decision invalidating the deployment, is set to hold a hearing Friday on whether to issue an indefinite injunction. 

Breyer is an appointee of former President Clinton and the brother of retired Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer. 

In deploying the troops, Trump cited a statute that allows him to federalize the National Guard whenever there is a rebellion or when he cannot execute federal laws with regular forces. 

The appeals panel on Thursday said it agreed the latter trigger was likely met, so it didn’t need to reach the question of whether there was a rebellion. 

“Plaintiffs’ own submissions state that some protesters threw objects, including Molotov cocktails, and vandalized property. According to the declarations submitted by Defendants, those activities significantly impeded the ability of federal officers to execute the laws,” the opinion reads. 

The three-judge appeals panel comprised two Trump-nominated judges, Mark Bennett and Eric Miller, and Judge Jennifer Sung, an appointee of former President Biden. 

The 9th Circuit also rejected Newsom’s argument that Trump failed a statutory requirement to issue his deployment order “through” the governor. Newsom contended it established a requirement that he consent, but the appeals panel said notifying the adjutant general of the California National Guard was likely sufficient.  

The panel stressed the statute “does not give governors any veto power over the President’s federalization decision.” 

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Symptoms of 'super flu' explained…and how to tell it apart from Covid

Understanding ‘Super Flu’ Symptoms: Key Differences from COVID-19 Explained

As winter tightens its grip, the United States is grappling with rising…
What obsession with NFL draft positioning misses about Giants' needs

Why Focusing Solely on NFL Draft Rankings Overlooks the Giants’ True Needs

Imagine if the Mona Lisa were to find a new home, not…
How to view 3I/ATLAS during its Earth tour

Catch a Glimpse of 3I/ATLAS: Your Guide to Observing Its Journey Near Earth

As the interstellar comet known as 3I/ATLAS prepares to make its celestial…
Footage shows Nick Reiner at a gas station hours after parents' murder

Nick Reiner Captured on Gas Station CCTV Just Hours Following Parents’ Tragic Murder

In a chilling development, new video footage captures Nick Reiner casually purchasing…
Prison Fellowship's Angel Tree brings hope to Florida families during the holiday season

Prison Fellowship’s Angel Tree Spreads Holiday Cheer to Florida Families, Offering Hope and Support

For many children, the holiday season underscores the absence of a parent…
The hotel room Nick Reiner left 'covered in blood'

Shocking Incident: Hotel Room Left ‘Covered in Blood’ by Nick Reiner

Exclusive images acquired by the Daily Mail have unveiled the shocking state…
Las Vegas men who pleaded guilty to mowing down retired police chief learn sentence

Las Vegas Men Sentenced After Pleading Guilty to Fatal Incident Involving Retired Police Chief

Two men from Las Vegas have been sentenced for their roles in…
Rob Reiner’s son Nick charged with 2 counts of murder in killing of his parents

Shocking Family Tragedy: Nick Reiner Accused of Double Homicide in Parents’ Deaths

Nick Reiner found himself in custody shortly after the tragic incident involving…