SCOTUS rules on birthright citizenship case: Local legal experts weigh in
Share and Follow


SAVANNAH, Ga. () – The United States Supreme Court handed down a ruling Friday that limits judges’ power to block an executive order that would suspend birthright citizenship.

Several months ago, President Trump signed an executive order that would mean any child born to parents who are considered “unlawfully present” or under status that is “lawful but temporary” would not be granted citizenship at birth.

However, in Trump v. CASA, the high court did not rule on whether the president can or cannot suspend automatic citizenship for those born in the U.S.

“Whether this executive order is unconstitutional, this issue has not yet been resolved,” Main attorney & owner of Siletskaya Immigration Firm Khristina Siletskaya said.

Instead, they ruled 6-3 that birthright citizenship was not the issue at hand.

“When the president issued that executive order, three courts said, ‘Mr. President, you overstepped your bounds, and we will issue what’s call an injunction, and that injunction will apply to the entire United States,'” Mills Fleming, a partner at Hunter Maclean, said.

The nationwide injunctions from federal judges prompted questions about judicial overreach.

“The U.S. Supreme court looked solely at that issue and determined that that federal judge did not have the authority to issue a nationwide injunction,” Fleming said.

Therefore, the injunction on Trump’s birthright citizenship order only stands in the states where one was issued.

  • Property tax increases approved in unincorporated Chatham County
  • St. Joseph’s Hospital celebrates 150 years serving Savannah
  • ‘Salute to Summer’ draws in large crowd
  • SCOTUS rules on birthright citizenship case: Local legal experts weigh in
  • Storm Team 3: Hot weekend with scattered afternoon storms

“As of this very moment, technically the executive order can take effect in all other states, including South Carolina and Georgia,” Siletskaya said. “It might be and most likely will happen that within the next few days, we will see new legal actions, new court orders.”

Though, there won’t be much time to litigate the issue before the order could go into effect.
“The order is not going to go into effect for 30 days. So, there’s 30 days for this to be fought out, and then we’ll see what happens,” Owner of Dobson Law LLC Craig Dobson said.

If Trump’s order does go into effect, there are still many unanswered questions about how it would play out.

“What are you going to do with somebody undocumented in the hospital, they have a child. Are the ICE agents going to show up and take that child and kick them out of the United States?” Fleming questioned.

Citizenship that has already granted cannot be revoked.

However, if Trump’s order goes into effect in the states that have not ruled on it, it would apply to any newborn that does not have at least one parent with legal status.

“There’s a very vulnerable and very particular group of people that are all in legal status. Yet, they are not green card holders. They are on the path to become green card holders, but not yet. So, if they have a child, what does this mean for this child?” Siletskaya asked.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Kennedy Center Condemns Musician’s Protest Over Trump-Named Venue

WASHINGTON – The head of the Kennedy Center condemned a musician’s abrupt…

Hundreds Gather in Mourning Following Tragic Mosque Bombing in Homs, Syria

In the heart of Homs, Syria, a poignant scene unfolded as hundreds…

Brazilian Judge Orders House Arrest for Coup Plot Convicts Following Former Police Commander’s Escape

SAO PAULO – In a decisive move, a Brazilian judge has placed…

Springfield Crime Stoppers Seek Public’s Help to Solve Carter’s Fish Market Arson Case

SPRINGFIELD, Ill. (WCIA) — Springfield’s Crime Stoppers are requesting the public’s assistance…

Family Feud: Harvey Weinstein Accuser Kaja Sokola Faces Defamation Suit from Her Own Sister

NEW YORK – During Harvey Weinstein’s latest criminal proceedings, two sisters took…

Florida’s Own Mickey Lee, Former ‘Big Brother’ Contestant, Passes Away on Christmas Day

The reality television community is mourning the loss of Mickey Lee, a…

Exciting Kickoff: Highlights from Day One of Holiday High School Basketball Tournaments

Bristol, Tenn. (WJHL) — The excitement of holiday high school basketball tournaments…

Lake County Tragedy: DUI Arrest Following Fatal Crash Leaves 2 Dead, 1 Injured, Reports FHP

LAKE COUNTY, Fla. – A tragic incident unfolded Friday night in Lake…