Judge Boasberg kills couple's Jan. 6 restitution refund ask
Share and Follow

Background: Photo of Cynthia Ballenger and her husband Christopher Price at the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021 (Justice Department). Left inset: Donald Trump speaks at the annual Road to Majority conference in Washington, DC, June 22, 2024 (Allison Bailey/NurPhoto via AP). Right inset: Chief U.S. District Judge James Boasberg (U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia).

Chief U.S. District Judge James Boasberg has rebuffed a request from a Maryland couple who asked for roughly $1,000 in restitution to be returned to them now that they have been pardoned by President Donald Trump for taking part in the 2021 Capitol attack.

The rejection came Monday, just days after another judge in Washington, D.C. — U.S. District Judge Randolph Moss — swatted down a pardoned Jan. 6 defendant and former U.S. Marine who had asked for a refund, and roughly a month after Senior U.S. District Judge Royce Lamberth said no to a similar request from Utah defendant John Sullivan.

“The court need not embark on a lengthy exegesis of this issue because it agrees with and adopts in full the analysis of Judge Randolph Moss of this district, who has just reached the same outcome in an identically postured case,” Boasberg explained Monday in a brief two-page order to defendants Cynthia Ballenger and her husband Christopher Price.

“Although the government agrees that return is appropriate, the court does not and will deny the Motion,” Boasberg said.

Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.

Ballenger and Price filed a motion asking for a refund on their restitution on March 14, claiming they had previously “had no choice but to comply with the court”s restitution and assessment orders” under a threat of additional penalties and enforcement actions. The couple had asked for refund payments in the amount of $570 each.

“Defendants were not voluntary payors; they acted under legal compulsion,” the motion said. “To allow the government to retain these funds following vacatur, when there is no longer a lawful obligation, is inconsistent with fundamental fairness and due process.”

In his ruling Monday, Boasberg cited arguments made in the case that had been before Moss, United States v. Santos, rejecting a request from Jan. 6 defendant Hector Vargas Santos, 29, of Jersey City, New Jersey, for a similar refund following the mass pardons.

In his order, Moss brought up the U.S. Supreme Court decision in Knote v. United States, which described a pardon as “an act of grace” that does not restore “rights or property once vested in others in consequence of the conviction and judgment,” per the 1877 ruling. “Because Santos’ payments were collected while his convictions were ‘in force,’ the funds were not ‘erroneously collected’ and are therefore not refundable,” Moss said.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Tragic Incident: Mother of Four Fatally Hit in Driveway Amid High-Speed Pursuit

Background: News footage of the scene where Xochitl Santos was fatally struck…

Murder Trial for Nikki Cheng Faces Postponement

A new court date has been established for Tyler McCain, accused of…

Chilling Christmas Eve Incident: Hotel Guest Discovered with Blood After Attempted Attack on Sleeping Companion

Inset: Uberclein Vazquez Villareal (DuPage County State’s Attorney’s Office). Background: The Illinois…

Teen Arrested After Alleged Attack Leaves Mother Dead, Father Injured: Police Report

A tragic incident unfolded in a rural Pennsylvania town on Friday, where…

Probationer Arrested for Allegedly Slashing Roommate’s Throat with Blade

Report by Staff GAINESVILLE, Fla. – A 35-year-old man, Charles Ivan Griffith…

Shocking Incident: Gainesville Man Arrested for Assault and Robbery After Dog Trespass

By Staff Reporter GAINESVILLE, Fla. – A 59-year-old man, Troy Elwon Butler,…

Shocking Incident: Woman Repeatedly Runs Over Ex-Boyfriend with SUV, Leaving Him Severely Injured, Police Report

Share A woman from Tennessee is now facing serious charges of attempted…

Holiday Tragedy: CVS Employee Fatally Stabbed During Attempted Robbery

Background: News footage of the CVS in Lindenhurst, N.Y., where Edeedson Cine…