Judge quotes Humpty Dumpty, takes state AG to legal woodshed
Share and Follow

Background: Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier at a press conference on June 14, 2025 (AG James Uthmeier/Facebook). Left inset: President Donald Trump watches as Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent participates in a ceremonial swearing in of Paul Atkins as chairman of the Securities and Exchange Commission, in the Oval Office of the White House, Tuesday, April 22, 2025, in Washington (AP Photo/Alex Brandon). Right inset: U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement conducting a raid (Fox News/YouTube).

Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier spent his Fourth of July pushing back against immigration advocates in a filing to the U.S. Supreme Court, urging the justices to reject pleas to uphold a federal judge”s injunction blocking the state’s new immigrant enforcement law — a move Uthmeier blasts as a “remarkable power grab.”

“The district court extended its injunction to cover every Florida law enforcement officer even though they had not been sued,” Uthmeier said Friday in reply to a response brief filed by the Florida Immigrant Coalition, the Farmworker Association of Florida and two individual plaintiffs who are suing the state over the immigration law.

“Plaintiffs’ response carries forward the same mistakes as the district court,” Uthmeier blasted.

Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.

Last month, the Florida AG asked the U.S. Supreme Court to step in and allow him to continue enforcing the new state law — known as SB 4-C, which criminalized the entry and presence in Florida of immigrants who have entered the United States illegally — after a federal judge blocked it with a preliminary injunction.

U.S. District Judge Kathleen Williams issued a 14-day stay blocking the law on April 4 after it was signed into effect by Gov. Ron DeSantis in February. The legislation and its enforcement has been a powder keg for controversy, recently resulting in Uthmeier being held in contempt of court.

The AG’s emergency Supreme Court application asserts that his state’s inability to implement the new law has left Florida exposed and vulnerable to the “evil effects of illegal immigration,” which he describes as “more than sadistic.”

When Williams — a Barack Obama appointee — ordered the legislation not to be enforced, she reasoned it was the federal government’s responsibility to apprehend and litigate migrants, not individual states. She extended her order on April 18, and then issued a preliminary injunction on April 29, noting how the new law was “likely” unconstitutional.

Attorneys for the immigration groups and two plaintiffs filed a 41-page response brief to Uthmeier’s Supreme Court application last Wednesday, urging the nation’s highest court to shoot down the request and keep Williams’ injunction in place temporarily. They argued that SB 4-C “conflicts with the intricate federal scheme at every turn,” citing a 2024 ruling in a Texas case that established a “comprehensive framework” on what penalties apply for those who enter the United States unlawfully, according to the groups.

More from Law&Crime: ‘Too speculative and conclusory’: Trump DOJ tells environmental groups suing over ‘Alligator Alcatraz’ construction to take in the ‘flora and fauna’ elsewhere

“Congress has provided a range of tools and broad discretion to federal officials in order to balance a range of national interests, yet SB 4-C seeks to wrest control of one of those tools — criminal regulation of entry — from federal control and discretion, to be applied however Florida (and, presumably, any other state) sees fit,” the groups said.

Uthmeier hit back Friday with rebukes of those suing Florida and Williams specifically, saying their arguments are based on “a brooding intuition that immigration, writ large, is inherently and exclusively federal in nature.” The views stated on the matter, Uthmeier said, leave no role for states to regulate immigrants in any capacity.

“By disagreeing that illegal immigration is a national crisis, plaintiffs underplay the reality on the ground, putting them squarely at odds with the past two presidents,” Uthmeier asserted.

“SB 4-C represents Florida’s commonsense effort to combat the flood of illegal immigration into its borders,” he added. “Plaintiffs and the district court insist that Florida was powerless to adopt that law.”

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Ex-Boyfriend’s Fatal Shooting Leads to Prison Sentence for Woman

Inset: Jasmoray Baugh (Volusia County Jail). Background: The 300 block of Chipola…

Outraged Mother Demands Justice: Calls for Accountability After 5-Year-Old Daughter Choked by Peers

Left inset: Antavia Kennibrew (WOIO/YouTube). Right inset: Antavia Kennibrew’s 5-year-old daughter (GoFundMe).…

Lawsuit Claims Fatality Linked to Methadone Administered Instead of Lexapro

Inset: Kyle Slade (Obituary). Background: Copper Spring East in Gilbert, Ariz. (Google…

Federal Investigation Uncovers Deadly Links Between High-Stakes Poker Games and Arson Crimes

Assaf “Ace” Waknine (U.S. Department of Justice). An individual believed to be…

Lawsuit Alleges Tesla’s Role in Fatal Car Fire Involving Couple

Inset: Jeffrey Bauer and Michelle Bauer (GoFundMe). Background: The crash scene in…

Pregnant Mother’s Suspected Killer Avoids Murder Charge

Left inset: Mattavius Anderson (Macon County Sheriff’s Office). Right inset: Ja’Niah Thomas…

9-Year-Old Absentee from Court Following Alleged Assault on 5-Year-Old Autistic Ohio Girl

In a recent court session, an Ohio juvenile judge delivered a stark…

California Authorities Unveil Crucial Security Footage in Search for Missing Melodee Buzzard and Daughter

The Santa Barbara County Sheriff’s Office in California unveiled surveillance footage on…