Small town dentist facing trial for allegedly poisoning wife's protein shake amid secret affair
Share and Follow

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles!

Jury selection kicked off Monday for the high-stakes trial of James Craig, the hometown dentist accused of poisoning his wife’s protein shakes while secretly carrying on a sordid affair and plotting a new life without her.

James Toliver Craig, 47, is charged with first-degree murder after deliberation in the March 2023 death of his wife, Angela Craig, a 43-year-old mother of six. Her cause of death was determined to be lethal doses of cyanide and tetrahydrozoline.

Defense attorney Kelly Hyman outlined the strategic battlegrounds she expects to see in the courtroom as Craig’s murder trial unfolds.

“Chain-of-custody documentation and lab accreditation standards here in Colorado,” she said, “will be scrutinized at every turn.”

James Toliver Craig

James Toliver Craig is pictured in a mugshot provided by the Aurora Police Department. (Aurora Police Department)

Hyman also discussed how pretrial publicity might impact plea negotiations. Prosecutors, she suggested, often harden their stance to avoid appearing weak in the court of public opinion — even as defendants leverage the threat of venue changes or jury sequestration to force more favorable terms. 

“In situations like this,” she explained, “the real pressure point comes when both sides realize the jury pool may already be tainted by media coverage.”

Hyman said that as jury selection kicks off, voir dire must dig deeper and probe prospective jurors on how they consume news and their personal attitudes toward law enforcement. 

“You can’t assume someone who says they’re unbiased hasn’t seen a viral headline or formed an opinion,” she said.

Fox News Digital has reached out to Lisa Fine Moses for comment.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Brown janitor warned security about suspicious man for WEEKS

Brown University Custodian Alerted Security to Suspicious Individual for Several Weeks

A custodian at Brown University has revealed that he alerted campus security…
Florida teens to be tried as adults in brutal killing of 14-year-old girl

Florida Teens Face Adult Charges in Tragic Case of 14-Year-Old Girl’s Death

In a grim development from Florida, two teenagers are set to face…
Former Nickelodeon star now 'homeless on the streets of Los Angeles'

Former Nickelodeon Star Faces Homelessness on the Streets of Los Angeles

Tylor Chase, once a familiar face on Nickelodeon, has recently been discovered…
With FDA approval of Wegovy pill, new era of oral GLP-1 weight loss drugs begins

FDA Greenlights Wegovy Pill: A New Chapter for Oral GLP-1 Weight Loss Solutions Begins

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration has given the green light to…
Barry Manilow, 82, reveals he is battling lung cancer

Barry Manilow, 82, Courageously Faces Lung Cancer Battle: Iconic Singer’s Health Update

On Monday morning, Barry Manilow disclosed via an Instagram post that he…
Emergency personnel rush a victim of a small plane crash to an awaiting ambulance, Monday, Dec. 22, 2025, near the causeway, in Galveston, Texas. (Jennifer Reynolds/The Galveston County Daily News via AP)

Tragic Accident: Mexican Navy Medical Mission Plane Crashes in Texas, Resulting in 5 Fatalities

Tragedy struck near Galveston on Monday when a small aircraft belonging to…
Multiple fatalities reported as Mexican Navy plane crashes off Texas coast, recovery effort underway

Tragic Mexican Navy Plane Crash Off Texas Coast: Recovery Efforts Intensify Amid Multiple Fatalities

A Mexican Navy aircraft on a medical support mission crashed near the…
Outrage over dog found shot, tied to Jacksonville tree: 'They deserve to sit in a jail cell and rot'

Justice Demanded: Jacksonville Community Outraged Over Heartbreaking Dog Shooting Incident

Valor, a pit bull terrier with blue and white markings, was discovered…