US immigration news: ICE arrests at courts in Chicago, nationwide labeled 'unlawful' in new lawsuit against Trump administration
Share and Follow

CHICAGO (WLS) — A new lawsuit is accusing the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and the Department of Justice (DOJ) of colluding to “intentionally strip people of basic due process rights,” by arresting individuals appearing for their hearings in immigration court.

The news comes after the ABC7 I-Team recently reported on two former immigration judges who fear that during President Donald Trump’s second administration, the immigration court system is being tossed aside in favor of expedited deportations.

ABC7 Chicago is now streaming 24/7. Click here to watch

This week, the I-Team interviewed the former head of Chicago’s immigration court who confirmed she and other assistant chief judges across the country were given new guidance from the Justice Department that relaxed the standards for dismissing cases in immigration court for noncitizens. Once those cases were dismissed, the judge said ICE agents were waiting in the court to re-arrest those people.

The potential class-action lawsuit was filed Wednesday by a coalition of immigrant legal rights organizations, including Chicago’s National Immigrant Justice Center.

Representing 12 people who have been arrested at immigration court hearings across the country and in Chicago, the lawsuit alleges these people “have been abruptly ripped from their families… for appearing in immigration court, a step required to enable them to proceed with their applications for permission to remain in this country.”

Keren Zwick is the litigation director for the National Immigrant Justice Center.

“The administration has taken many new steps in the immigration space,” Zwick said. “This one really goes after what is an unprecedented policy of going into immigration courts and arresting people while they’re in the courthouses, taking them out of their removal proceedings and placing them into a different kind of removal proceedings where they have less rights.”

SEE ALSO | ICE agents in Midwest jurisdiction recently arresting more who have no prior criminal convictions

Through the use of “expedited removal” — a process that ICE agents can use to deport someone in as little as three days – the lawsuit lays out the latest attempt by the DHS to ramp up immigration arrests after a White House mandate issued in late May demanded “3,000 arrests per day.”

“One of the things that we’re challenging is basically an instruction from the immigration judges that… trial attorneys don’t have to follow the rules anymore,” Zwick said.

Days following the White House’s arrest quota mandate, an email sent out to Assistant Chief Immigration Judges nationwide from the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) on May 30 said attorneys for the DHS would be moving to dismiss cases “to meet the demands of an increasing workload” and instructed judges to make same-day decisions on these motions.

The emailed guidance, independently obtained by the I-Team, also relaxed the standards for dismissing cases. At the same time, the email informed judges that DHS would be conducting enforcement at the courts.

Zwick said the guidance emailed to the judges violates historic standards required for dismissing asylum and other citizenship cases already proceeding forward in court.

“The trial attorneys don’t have to give people notice or an opportunity to respond when they’re trying to do these things,” Zwick said.

SEE ALSO | Millions of undocumented immigrants will no longer be eligible for bond hearings: ICE memo

Former Assistant Chief Immigration Judge Jennifer Peyton told the I-Team she was overseeing Chicago’s immigration court when the guidance was sent out.

“We were given guidance that when the department files these motions [to dismiss], we should not give them ten days for a response, we should adjudicate them right on the spot,” Peyton explained when asked about the guidance. “And so, in fact, in the last several months, there was ICE activity within our courtrooms.”

“The dismissals were being granted and the respondents were being let out in handcuffs,” Peyton told the I-Team.

The American Immigration Lawyers Association, an organization that offers independent legal guidance and analysis to immigration court judges and attorneys, told its members last month the “clandestine EOIR directive” appears to violate federal regulations and past immigration practices, as well as EOIR’s own public guidance issued a week after President Trump’s second inauguration.

In an emailed statement responding to the lawsuit, DHS Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin said making arrests at immigration court is “common sense.”

“The ability of law enforcement to make arrests of criminal illegal aliens in courthouses is common sense,” McLaughlin said. “It conserves valuable law enforcement resources because they already know where a target will be. It is also safer for our officers and the community. These illegal aliens have gone through security and been screened to not have any weapons.”

“We aren’t some medieval kingdom, there are no legal sanctuaries where you can hide and avoid the consequences for breaking the law,” McLaughlin added, “Nothing in the constitution prohibits arresting a lawbreaker where you find them.”

Kristi Nelson is a former Chicago immigration court judge who resigned just before this guidance was issued. She believes the EOIR should not be telling judges how to adjudicate cases.

“I think it’s inappropriate to be telling a judge how to rule in any particular case,” Nelson said. “That’s not supposed to happen. I mean, we’re supposed to be, as an immigration judge, we’re supposed to be independent.”

Meanwhile, news of Judge Peyton’s firing has reached Congress.

As the I-Team previously reported, Judge Peyton was abruptly terminated from her position leading Chicago’s immigration court this past month after serving in the role for nearly nine years.

In her termination letter, shared with the I-Team, the Attorney General did not state a reason or cause for the dismissal.

A spokesperson for the EOIR would not comment on Peyton’s termination.

SEE ALSO | Judge orders Trump administration to halt indiscriminate immigration stops, arrests in California

U.S. Senator Dick Durbin on Friday said he believes Peyton’s termination was in retaliation after she gave the member of Congress a tour of Chicago’s immigration courthouse.

“I think this kind of pressure on people who are making those decisions, to not even open the door for a member of Congress to observe a public event is shameful,” Durbin told ABC7. “And it tells you that something is going on there that they’re embarrassed about.”

Copyright © 2025 WLS-TV. All Rights Reserved.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Feds use 'violent force' on protesters, press, clergy at Broadview ICE facility: ACLU suit

ACLU Lawsuit Claims Excessive Force Against Protesters, Media, and Clergy by Federal Agents at Broadview ICE Facility

CHICAGO () The American Civil Liberties Union of Illinois filed a lawsuit…
Bill Belichick's North Carolina assistant coach suspended

Bill Belichick’s Assistant Coach in North Carolina Faces Suspension

Things keep getting worse around Bill Belichick and his North Carolina football…
Beloved rock singer Ann Everton killed in car crash as she began tour

Rock Star Ann Everton Tragically Dies in Car Accident at Start of Tour

Rock star Ann Everton has been killed in a car crash on…
October 7 attacks: Gaza peace talks enter their second day as a divided Israel marks 2 years since Hamas' attack

October 7 Conflict: Gaza Peace Negotiations Continue Amidst Division in Israel on the Attack’s Second Anniversary

REIM, Israel — Peace talks between Israel and Hamas resumed at an…
Flight chaos as air traffic control systems go dark

Air Travel Disruption as Air Traffic Control Systems Experience Outage

The ongoing government shutdown has resulted in yet another major air traffic…
Rosie O'Donnell says dramatic fight on The View was a 'setup'

Rosie O’Donnell Claims Intense Clash on The View Was Orchestrated

Rosie O’Donnell has a surprising theory about a dramatic fight on The…
The stock market has thrived even with all this economic uncertainty

Despite Economic Uncertainty, the Stock Market Continues to Prosper

A government shutdown. A weakening labor market. Stubborn inflation. None of it…
Celeste Rivas Hernandez laid to rest a month after remains discovered

Celeste Rivas Hernandez Finally Laid to Rest One Month After Her Remains Were Found

() A funeral service was held for Celeste Rivas Hernandez, the missing…