'It's broken us': Victims' family gives emotional testimony in Shelby Nealy sentencing trial
Share and Follow


PINELLAS COUNTY, Fla. (WFLA) — It was an emotional day in court as the sentencing trial for Shelby Nealy continued Friday. Nealy was convicted of killing his ex-wife’s parents and her brother, following the murder of his ex-wife.

Crying on the stand, Renee Splitt shared a sacred memory of her father. The court played a voicemail from Splitt’s father, Richard Ivancic, for the jury to hear.

“Hi sweetie, this is dad. Wanted to say happy birthday. I’d sing happy birthday to you, but I won’t get (inaudible)…. hope you had a good day sweetie, bye,” said Richard on the voicemail.

Splitt told the jury that recording is all she has left. Richard, her brother Nick, and stepmother Laura were brutally murdered by Shelby Nealy.

Nealy faces a life or death sentence, and he sat still in court Friday while Splitt gave her victim impact statement.

“This storm that has stretched over six and a half years to get to this day, today. And the grief that we bear, it isn’t just emotional, at times it feels really physical; it seeps into our bones, it’s aged us. It’s broken us in many ways. And it’s stolen so much from us,” Splitt said.

The state attorney called medical examiners and law enforcement to the stand. They recapped the gruesome crime scene at the family home.

“The first thing I noticed was several holes through the skull,” said Pasco County Sheriff’s Office Sergeant Joseph Schlotter. “Had what appeared to be blood splatter on the walls of the bathroom.”

Splitt shared family photos. She told the jury her father was everything a father should be. She said Laura was a sweet soul. Splitt said her brother Nick was young and full of life.

She said she and her remaining family members will have no peace in the end.

“We’ve been irreparably shattered by the murders of our family members,” Splitt said.

Court will reconvene at 8:30 a.m. Monday, July 21.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Sarasota County Schools Consider Strengthening Partnership with ICE in New Resolution

In Sarasota County, Florida, a new resolution proposed by the local school…

Concerns Arise for Mentored Youth as Coles County Program Announces Closure

CHARLESTON, Ill. (WCIA) — After five decades of fostering meaningful relationships between…

Ukrainian Officials Visit US for Key Peace Discussions Amid Russian Strikes on Energy Facilities

KYIV – As the harsh winter continues to grip Ukraine, a delegation…

Ugandan Police Refute Claims of Opposition Leader’s Arrest Amid Anticipation of Final Election Results

KAMPALA – On Saturday, Ugandan police refuted claims circulating about the arrest…

Spanberger Breaks Tradition with Unique Attire at Virginia Inauguration

RICHMOND, Va. – Breaking with a longstanding tradition, Virginia Governor Abigail Spanberger…

Full Court Friday: Unmissable Highlights and Key Takeaways from January 16, 2026

CENTRAL ILLINOIS (WCIA) – Dive into the excitement of Friday night’s high…

Heartbreaking Search: Iranian Family Finds Protester’s Body Amidst Corpses, Forced to Bury Her on Roadside

BEIRUT – The tragic death of college student Robina Aminian, allegedly shot…

Community Unites: Rallying Against 15% Staff Layoff at Telfair Museum

SAVANNAH, Ga. — A crowd gathered outside the historic Owens-Thomas House in…