Kathryn Restelli in a virtual court appearance.
Share and Follow

A WOMAN has admitted how she lured the father of her children to his death in a trap set up to look like self-defense.

Kathryn Restelli, 37, gave her estranged husband a chilling instruction to enter her family’s home unannounced before he was shot to death last summer.

Kathryn Restelli in a virtual court appearance.

Kathryn Restelli, 37, crying as she pleaded guilty to a reduced count of murder and conspiracy to commit murderCredit: Utah State Courts
Man holding up a fish and giving a thumbs up.

Matthew Restelli, 34, was killed on July 12, 2024Credit: Legacy.com
Photo of Kathryn Restelli.

Kathryn Restelli lured her estranged husband to her family’s home in UtahCredit: Facebook

The mom of two pleaded guilty to a reduced count of murder and conspiracy to murder 34-year-old Matthew Restelli on July 12, 2024.

She told the court that she planned to kill her husband on July 12, 2024, with the help of her mom and brother, according to NBC affiliate KSL.

Kathryn said she lured him from their home in California to her mom’s house in American Fork, Utah, a suburb of Salt Lake City, by promising they could get back together.

She told him that the door was unlocked and that he could just enter the house when he arrived.

Matthew walked into the house and was shot to death minutes after he arrived by his brother-in-law, Kevin Ellis.

Kathryn, Ellis, and her mother, Tracey Grist, had set the scene so they could accuse Matthew of breaking into their home, allowing Ellis to shoot him on claims of self-defense, court documents said.

Utah has a Stand Your Ground law, which allows people to use deadly force to defend themselves or others if they think it’s necessary to prevent death or serious harm.

Grist called 911, but police were already on their way to the scene after a neighbor’s call — just one of many red flags that made cops suspicious of the murder scene.

RED FLAGS

Officers who raced to the house found Matthew holding a knife in an unusual way.

Cops first noticed that Matthew was gripping the knife in his right hand, despite being left-handed.

Photo of a man in a gray shirt.

Matthew drove to Utah from his California home to reconcile with his wifeCredit: Legacy.com
Photo of Kathryn Restelli.

Restelli could face life in prisonCredit: Facebook

He was also holding the weapon in the wrong direction.

Plus, Matthew was shot in the wrist of the arm holding the blade, which makes it unlikely that he would have kept a hold on the knife.

Kathryn was upstairs during the shooting, but admitted in her plea statement that she led Matthew to the house by leading him to believe she was open to reconciling when she wasn’t.

Matthew’s mother, Diane Restelli, told the court her son said that Kathryn took their two kids and the family truck to go to her family’s house in Utah.

Kathryn told him she couldn’t rent a car to come back, so he agreed to drive to pick up his wife and kids, Diane said.

However, Kathryn didn’t plan on going home with her husband.

She admitted that she put a tracking device on Matthew’s truck to monitor his drive to American Fork.

SICK PLOT

With her mom, Kathryn planned “to reassure him that all was well and to keep him calm” as he drove to his death, her plea statement said.

She said Grist removed the screen door of the house and moved toys out of the way so that Matthew could get into the home more easily.

Grist also covered the living room couch so no blood would get on it, Kathryn said.

On top of the murder charges, Kathryn was hit with a felony gun charge.

She faces a maximum of life in prison at her sentencing on September 9.

Ellis and Grist are both charged with murder, conspiracy to commit murder, obstruction of justice, and two counts of domestic violence in the presence of a child.

Kathryn’s plea deal might impact the murder cases against her mom and brother. Both of their trials are set to start in January.

Woman crying during court appearance.

Kathryn crying as she pled guiltyCredit: Utah State Courts
Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Iconic ’90s Femme Fatale from Men in Black Resurfaces After 16 Years: Daily Mail Unveils the Troubling Story Behind Her Absence

In the vibrant tapestry of 1990s cinema, Linda Fiorentino emerged as one…

Morning Brief: Protesters’ Actions Under Scrutiny in Ongoing Narrative

Monday, January 19, 2026 Good morning, and welcome to RedState’s “Morning…

Media Reacts to Karoline Leavitt’s Controversial Comments on Trump Interview

The traditional media often face criticism for perceived biases, and such…

DOJ Launches Probe into Allegations Against Renee Good’s Partner for Obstructing ICE Agent Operations

Federal authorities have initiated an investigation to determine whether Renee Nicole Good’s…

Victims of Spanish Train Disaster Ejected from Windows, Found Hundreds of Yards Away; Death Toll Exceeds 39 as Investigation into “Truly Strange” Incident Deepens

Officials reported a tragic derailment in Spain last night involving two high-speed…

Shapiro Claims Kamala Harris’ Team Questioned His Allegiance to Israel

In a recent revelation, Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro, a Democrat, has made…

Rand Paul Declares U.S. in a Continuous Conflict with Venezuela

Senator Rand Paul from Kentucky expressed on Sunday that the United States…

Bodycam Footage Reveals Tragic Incident: Former Deputy Fatally Shot by Officers After Stabbing Son

In a tragic series of events, a former Sacramento deputy was shot…