Court orders Trump to return National Guard control to Newsom
Share and Follow


() A lawsuit brought by California Gov. Gavin Newsom against President Donald Trump over the deployment of National Guard troops to subdue protests in the state will go to trial Monday. 

The showdown will take place in a bench trial where a judge will examine evidence in the suit challenging the legality of the federal government’s actions in California over the summer.  

Newsom and the State of California filed suit against Trump, Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth and the Department of Defense over the National Guard being sent to the state to quell protests over immigration raids.

The outcome will be highly consequential as it will carve the extent to which the president can override state leaders with military action in times of unrest.

What’s at issue in the lawsuit?

On June 6, 2025, Immigration and Customs Enforcement began carrying out immigration raids in Los Angeles, which led to city-wide protests.

While Trump called the demonstrations a breakdown of order, Newsom argues that the protests were under control by state forces.

In sending troops to LA, Trump cited Title 10 of the U.S. Code, which allows the president to “call into federal service members and units of the National Guard of any State in such numbers as he considers necessary” when there is a rebellion, an invasion or the danger of either happening.

This order must be issued through a governor, and Newsom did not request troops in LA, the lawsuit argues. It said that there was neither a “rebellion” nor an “invasion,” nor the possibility of either.

Trump’s federal troop deployment is the first without a governor’s request since the Civil Rights Movement and a violation of federal code, according to California’s lawsuit.

Judge Charles R. Breyer, who will hear the case, sided with California in a June 12 ruling that ordered the return of the troops to state control.

 “His [Trump’s] actions were illegal—both exceeding the scope of his statutory authority and violating the Tenth Amendment to the United States Constitution. He must therefore return control of the California National Guard to the Governor of the State of California forthwith.”

What are the arguments on both sides? 

Newsom cites the Posse Comitatus Act, an 1878 law that forbids the U.S. military from participating in civilian law enforcement on U.S. soil.

Exceptions to the Act include enforcement approved by Congress or under circumstances that are “expressly authorized by the Constitution.”

Newsom argues that Trump violated the law and overstepped California’s sovereign authority over the National Guard. 

Trump’s legal team argues the deployment was justified under the Insurrection Act, which can be invoked to suppress rebellion, violence or enforce the law in certain situations. 

At the time of the protests, Trump called protesters “paid insurrectionists” on social media and said demonstrators “should be in jail.”

Newsom argues that the requirements to invoke that law were not met as he did not request federal help. 

‘s Anna Kutz contributed to this story.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Negotiators meet in Egypt seeking Gaza ceasefire, hostage release

Diplomats Convene in Egypt to Secure Gaza Truce and Free Hostages

TEL AVIV, Israel () — Officials from Israel, Hamas and the U.S. are…
Jared Leto, Jodie Turner-Smith, Greta Lee and more

Stars Like Jared Leto, Jodie Turner-Smith, and Greta Lee Shine Bright

The “Tron: Ares” premiere in LA was a dazzling event, attracting notable…
America saw 'essentially no job growth' last month, Moody's warns

Moody’s Reports ‘Virtually No Job Growth’ in America Last Month

() — With official data on hold due to the government shutdown, economists…
Pope’s top diplomat blasts Israel’s Gaza offensive as ‘ongoing massacre,’ condemns Hamas attacks

Pope’s top diplomat blasts Israel’s Gaza offensive as ‘ongoing massacre,’ condemns Hamas attacks

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! The Vatican’s top diplomat…
Chicago's police chief puts criminals on notice after federal agents targeted in weekend confrontations

Chicago’s police chief puts criminals on notice after federal agents targeted in weekend confrontations

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! Chicago’s top cop came…
Dallas train shooting leaves 1 dead, second homicide on DART transit system in a week

Dallas train shooting leaves 1 dead, second homicide on DART transit system in a week

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! One person is dead…
Woman spikes her husband's wine with antifreeze amid custody battle

Woman poisons her husband’s wine with antifreeze during custody dispute

A 33-year-old woman who tried to poison her estranged husband with antifreeze…
Harry could take a dim view of Meghan's Diana crash tunnel video

Harry Might Disapprove of Meghan’s Video at the Site of Diana’s Crash Tunnel

A solo visit to the French capital by the Duchess of Sussex…