Ohio cold case solved after 30 years later as man convicted in 1995 double murder
Share and Follow


MARIETTA, OH (WTRF) An Ohio jury has convicted a man of murdering a woman and her young son nearly 30 years after the killings took place.

Scott Hickman, 53, was found guilty of four counts of aggravated murder and two counts of murder in the 1995 deaths of 28-year-old Kimberly Fulton and her 17-month-old son, Daniel.

The victims’ bodies were discovered on March 5, 1995, inside a burned mobile home in Palmer Township, a small town about 100 miles southeast of Columbus.

However, investigators later determined it wasn’t the fire that had killed them. Kimberly and Daniel didn’t have carbon monoxide in their lungs, the Parkersburg News and Sentinel reported, leading investigators to believe they had died before the fire was set.

The Ohio Attorney General’s office believed the fire was an attempt to cover up the murders.

Hickman was arrested in 1998 but ended up being released because there wasn’t enough evidence against him, according to the News and Sentinel.

The case went unsolved for decades until cold-case detectives with the Washington County Sheriff’s Office and the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation reopened the investigation in 2019. Hickman was indicted two years later in October 2021.

Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost credited investigators and prosecutors for their persistence in the case.

Hickman is scheduled to be sentenced on Oct. 14.

Another man, Johnny Ball of Marietta, was indicted last year on perjury and obstruction charges connected to the case. His trial is pending.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Missing Kansas Deer Hunter Discovered on River Log Jam

OSAGE COUNTY (KSNT) — In a cooperative effort, Kansas wildlife officials and…
Grateful Dead singer who also worked with Elvis Presley dies at 78

Legendary Grateful Dead Vocalist and Elvis Presley Collaborator Passes Away at 78

Donna Jean Godchaux, a beloved singer who graced the stage with the…
Missing hunter Ron Dailey of Selma found alive near Swamp Lake Trail after 20 days lost in Sierra wilderness

Miraculous Survival: Missing Hunter Ron Dailey Rescued After 20 Days Lost Near Swamp Lake Trail in Sierra Wilderness

A hunter who had been missing for nearly three weeks in California…
Meghan Markle 'wants to become a billionaire', says royal expert

Meghan Markle’s Ambitious Path to Billionaire Status: Royal Expert Weighs In

Meghan Markle and Prince Harry boast a combined wealth estimated at £60…
Local families face first week without Head Start education services due to government shutdown

Government Shutdown Leaves Local Families Struggling as Head Start Services Come to a Halt

Action Pact has ceased operations of its Head Start programs across more…
Jonas Brothers drop "A Very Jonas Christmas Movie" soundtrack and new single "Coming Home This Christmas"

Jonas Brothers Release “A Very Jonas Christmas Movie” Soundtrack Featuring New Single “Coming Home This Christmas

LOS ANGELES — The Jonas Brothers are ringing in the holiday season…
USDA tells stores not to offer discounts for SNAP users

USDA Issues New Guidelines on Discounts for SNAP Shoppers

NEW YORK (PIX11) – The United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) has…
ICE Chicago news: Donald Trump on 60 minutes says immigration raids 'haven't gone far enough;' communities brace for what's next

Trump Criticizes Immigration Efforts on 60 Minutes: Communities Prepare for Potential Intensified Raids in Chicago

During a recent interview on CBS’s “60 Minutes,” President Donald Trump acknowledged…