Deadly shooting at Dutton Island shocks community
Share and Follow


Community members react to a deadly officer-involved shooting Monday night after police say a man with a rifle threatened a couple trying to help him.

ATLANTIC BEACH, Fla — Community members react after a deadly shooting at Dutton Island Preserve. Police say a 37-year-old man was killed after an encounter with nine Jacksonville officers Monday evening.

According to the Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office, the incident began Monday night when a 37-year-old man was seen firing his rifle into the water at the Dutton Island Preserve boat ramp. Authorities say a couple approached to ask if he needed help, but the man pointed the gun at them and fought with one of them when they tried to de-escalate the situation.

Investigators said the suspect then got into his vehicle and drove off, only to return and ram the couple’s car before crashing near the RaceTrac on Mayport Road. Officers say he later barricaded himself inside his own car. After more than an hour, police say the suspect reached into a rifle case, and that’s when nine officers opened fire. The man died from his injuries at the scene.

For people who know the preserve as a quiet spot for fishing and hiking, the violence feels out of place.

“I just think it’s crazy how things escalate so quickly nowadays,” said Justin Null, who often fishes at the preserve.

Community member, Kara Anderson, said she came to the preserve to go on a walk. She said the idea of a shooting there left her uneasy.

“It’s a safe, quiet area. It’s scary to be in an area that it’s even violence or protection is even needed,” Anderson said.

Others were stunned when they first realized what was happening. Longtime visitor Martha Finch said she noticed smoke from the suspect’s truck and thought it was a traffic accident, not a deadly confrontation.

JSO confirmed the man’s past included only minor traffic offenses and a misdemeanor. 

Some community members said they will keep coming, but with a new sense of caution.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Cruise ship death: Cheerleader’s stepmom could be forced to testify against her own son

Father of Deceased Teen on Carnival Cruise Avoids Subpoena in Custody Dispute

The father of a Florida teenager who tragically passed away on a…
Costco sues Trump administration for 'full refund' of tariffs 

Costco Takes Legal Action Against Trump Administration Seeking Complete Reimbursement for Imposed Tariffs

Costco has initiated legal action to secure a complete reimbursement in the…
Judge blocks ICE from making warrantless arrests in DC without flight-risk proof

DC Court Halts ICE Warrantless Arrests: New Ruling Requires Flight-Risk Justification

A federal judge issued a ruling on Tuesday that curtails the Trump…
Actress Sarah Paulson gets a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame

Actress Sarah Paulson Honored with Star on Hollywood Walk of Fame

HOLLYWOOD, LOS ANGELES (KABC) — Sarah Paulson, celebrated for her Emmy and…
Former California deputy Marvin Morales suspected of killing his 11-year-old son is fatally shot during police pursuit

Tragic Pursuit Ends: Ex-California Deputy and Suspected Child Killer Shot Dead by Police

A former sheriff’s deputy from California, accused of the tragic stabbing of…
Hegseth cites 'fog of war' in defending follow-on strike in scrutinized attack on alleged drug boat

Hegseth Attributes ‘Fog of War’ to Justify Consequential Strike on Suspected Drug Vessel Amidst Controversy

In a recent defense of military actions, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth addressed…
Missing child found at Humboldt Park, Chicago home after disappearing more than 7 years ago; sibling, mother arrested

Tragic Naperville Train Incident: Worker Fatally Struck by Freight Train While Clearing Snow at 105 E. 4th Ave

A tragic incident unfolded in Naperville, Illinois, as a local contractor lost…
'Enough is enough': Fernandina Beach commissioners approve first reading on paid parking ordinance

Fernandina Beach Takes Action: Commissioners Approve Initial Reading of Paid Parking Ordinance in Response to Resident Concerns

“I’m extremely proud of this commission,” expressed City Commissioner Tim Poynter. “They’re…