Jamel McGriff in custody after couple severely burned in 'horrific double homicide' in NYC: Police
Share and Follow

NEW YORK CITY — A man wanted for torturing and killing an elderly couple in Queens before setting their home on fire was taken into custody in Midtown Manhattan on Wednesday, the NYPD said.

The search for 42-year-old Jamel McGriff came to an end Wednesday after NYPD officers spotted him near Times Square and took him into custody at West 44th Street and Seventh Avenue around 5:40 p.m., according to NYPD officials.

Police nabbed McGriff using technology that tracked him across the city as he used his victims’ credit cards.

Officers throughout the city were being constantly updated through the NYPD’s domain awareness system, and its high-tech critical messaging app.

Police were closely tracking the credit card usage, and every time McGriff used the credit card, officers in the immediate vicinity were notified.

When he used the victims’ credit card at the Regal Union Square movie theater, then made his way to Times Square, police officers who had just received the notification spotted and arrested him.

Police say McGriff set Frank and Maureen Olton, 76 and 77 years old, on fire after spending five hours inside their home. The “horrific double homicide” has left the Bellerose neighborhood — and the city — in shock.

Officers say he was seen on video Tuesday pawning two cellphones in the Bronx.

McGriff, described by police as a career criminal, is a level 3 sex offender with a lengthy criminal record stretching 30 years. He was released from prison in 2023.

Officers say he was walking around earlier in the day knocking on neighbors’ doors and asking to charge his phone.

New surveillance video shows McGriff walk past Frank Olton standing at the rear gate of his home. McGriff doubled back and spoke to Frank before being let into the home.

At least one neighbor said they turned the suspect away before he approached the victims’ house.

New York City Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch shared chilling details about how the couple was killed and found.

“Mr. Olton was found in the basement, tied to a pole with multiple stab wounds. Mrs. Olton was found on the first floor, severely burned,” Tisch said. “At this time, there is no known connection between Mr. McGriff, our suspect, and our victims beyond this chance encounter.”

Police say he exited the victims’ home carrying two bags.

Detectives with the Department of Homeless Services showed up to McGriff’s last known address on Creston Avenue in the Bronx on Wednesday.

A man named Victor said he has lived in the same shelter with the suspect for the last six months.

“And the guy walked around here like he was some kind of tough guy. And then you go and murder an elderly man?” Victor said. “He was off. I’m not a doctor, I’m not a psychic, I’m a Christian. I’m a man of God. I’m just saying he just felt off.”

A spokesperson with Department of Social Services said they were working closely with authorities to support the investigation.

McGriff served 16 years in prison for an armed robbery and is wanted in two more armed robberies this summer.

Copyright © 2025 KABC Television, LLC. All rights reserved.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Mom is charged after her two sons, 5 and 7, are found dead in NJ home

Mother Faces Charges Following Discovery of Her Two Sons Deceased in New Jersey Residence

A tragic incident unfolded in Hillsborough, New Jersey, as a mother faces…
Ellen Greenberg's parents reveal last call with daughter's fiancé

Ellen Greenberg’s Parents Share Details from Final Phone Call with Her Fiancé

Sandee Greenberg doesn’t recall the precise day she last conversed with her…
Chilling final message of doctor's wife shot dead next to her twins

Tragic Last Words: Doctor’s Wife Shares Heartbreaking Message Before Fatal Shooting Beside Her Twins

Last month, the tragic discovery of Charity Beallis and her six-year-old twins,…
Two officers injured in Gainesville shooting; suspect dead

Gainesville Shooting Leaves Two Officers Wounded, Suspect Killed

In a tragic turn of events on Wednesday morning, a shooting incident…
Tim Walz anti-ICE stream turns into trainwreck as office deletes video

Tim Walz’s Anti-ICE Livestream Faces Setback as Office Removes Video

Tim Walz found himself in a difficult situation during a livestream intended…
Best hobby ideas and kits for adults: Shop our favorite picks

Top Hobby Ideas and Kits for Adults: Explore Our Curated Favorites

As a member of various affiliate marketing programs, Localish may earn commissions…
Suspended Ford worker who heckled Trump receives $600k

Ford Worker Who Challenged Trump Lands $600K Settlement: A Bold Stand Pays Off

Ford employee TJ Sabula, currently under suspension, enjoys robust support from his…
Influencer found dead inside truck hours after haunting final post

Tragic Discovery: Influencer Found Dead in Truck Just Hours After Eerie Final Post

The digital world mourns the loss of Isaac Efraín Valadez, better known…