NewsFinale
  • Home
  • News
  • Local News
  • Business
  • Health
  • Finance
  • Celeb Lifestyle
  • Crime
  • Entertainment
  • Advertise Here
Gleammour AquaFresh
NewsFinale
  • Home
  • News
  • Local News
  • Business
  • Health
  • Finance
  • Celeb Lifestyle
  • Crime
  • Entertainment
  • Advertise Here
Home Local News Authors Challenge Ban on ‘Tango Makes Three’ Book in Federal Court

Authors Challenge Ban on ‘Tango Makes Three’ Book in Federal Court

Authors appeal ‘Tango Makes Three’ book ban ruling in federal court
Up next
The Future of Criminal Defense
The Evolution of Criminal Defense Strategies
Published on 04 October 2025
Author
NewsFinale Journal
Share and Follow
FacebookXRedditPinterestWhatsApp


TALLAHASSEE, Fla. – Attorneys for the book’s authors and a student Friday quickly appealed a federal judge’s ruling that rejected a First Amendment challenge to a 2023 decision by the Escambia County School Board to remove the book “And Tango Makes Three” from school libraries.

The attorneys filed a notice of appeal three days after Chief U.S. District Judge Allen Winsor ruled against authors Peter Parnell and Justin Richardson and the student, identified in the case by the initials B.G.

As is common, the notice does not detail arguments the plaintiffs will make at the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. But it started another chapter in legal disputes about decisions in Escambia County — and other parts of Florida — to remove certain books from library shelves.

[WATCH: Is banning books a solution or a problem? (from 2023)]

“And Tango Makes Three,” which tells the story of two male penguins who raised a penguin chick at New York’s Central Park Zoo, has become a prominent part of a debate. The plaintiffs in the Escambia County case allege it was targeted because of its depictions of same-sex parents raising a child.

In a February brief, attorneys for the plaintiffs argued the Escambia board violated First Amendment rights because it removed the book from school libraries “based on unlawful viewpoint discrimination.” The brief said the book should be returned to five school libraries where it was previously held.

“Beyond its scientifically accurate depiction of penguin behavior, Tango celebrates family values, adoption, and parental responsibility,” the brief said. “The evidence at trial will show that Tango’s authors, plaintiffs Peter Parnell and Justin Richardson, wrote Tango to express a viewpoint that same-sex relationships and families with same-sex parents exist; that they can be happy, healthy, and loving; and that same-sex parents can adopt and raise healthy children.”

[WATCH: A battle over books: Central Florida parents clash over books in schools]

But in his 18-page ruling Tuesday, Winsor wrote that “there is no view of the facts that could support plaintiffs’ claim that the board engaged in unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination or otherwise violated the First Amendment with respect to Tango.”

Winsor, who is based in Tallahassee, wrote that the “government does not create a forum for others’ speech by purchasing books for a public library.”

“The author plaintiffs have no First Amendment right to speak through the library, and B.G. has no First Amendment right to receive the author plaintiffs’ message through the library,” the ruling said. “Nor do the author plaintiffs have a First Amendment right to demand the library ignore the book’s viewpoint when determining whether to include it in its collection.”

Winsor added that the ruling “does not, of course, keep the book (or any viewpoint in it) from B.G. or any other student. … The Escambia County School Board has simply decided students wanting this particular book will have to get it elsewhere.”

Escambia County has been a battleground as school districts in various parts of Florida have removed or restricted access to books. Parents, authors, the publishing company Penguin Random House and the free-speech group PEN American Center, Inc. also have filed a broader lawsuit contending that Escambia County book decisions violated the First Amendment. That case remains pending.

Breaking News Alerts

More Stories Like This In Our Email Newsletter

Share and Follow
FacebookXRedditPinterestWhatsApp
You May Also Like
Florida House moves forward with property tax proposals as the Senate breaks its silence
  • Local News

Florida Legislature Shakes Up Property Taxes: House Advances Proposals as Senate Weighs In

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. (WFLA) — A significant development unfolded at the statehouse this…
  • NewsFinale Journal
  • November 21, 2025
OpenAI and Taiwan's Foxconn to partner in AI hardware design and manufacturing in the US
  • Local News

OpenAI and Taiwan’s Foxconn Forge U.S. Partnership for AI Hardware Innovation and Production

TAIPEI – OpenAI has teamed up with Taiwan’s electronics powerhouse, Foxconn, to…
  • NewsFinale Journal
  • November 21, 2025
Decatur school’s time capsule dug up after 20 years
  • Local News

Decatur School Unearths 20-Year-Old Time Capsule, Revealing Treasured Memories

DECATUR, Ill. (WCIA) — A wave of excitement swept through a gathering…
  • NewsFinale Journal
  • November 21, 2025
Mind your manners: Why air travelers being asked to behave with more 'civility'
  • Local News

Airlines Urge Passengers to Embrace Civility Amid Rising In-Flight Disruptions

The Department of Transportation is taking steps to address unruly conduct and…
  • NewsFinale Journal
  • November 21, 2025
Attorney discusses whether disruption of Muslim prayer at USF was a hate crime
  • Local News

Legal Expert Weighs In: Was the Interruption of Muslim Prayer at USF a Hate Crime?

In Tampa, Florida, the boundaries between hate speech and free expression are…
  • NewsFinale Journal
  • November 21, 2025
Clemson road rage leads to arrest for attempted murder
  • Local News

Clemson Road Rage Incident Escalates to Attempted Murder Charge: Suspect Arrested

In a startling incident in Clemson, South Carolina, a driver came under…
  • NewsFinale Journal
  • November 21, 2025
Trump offers praise for 'rational' Mamdani in remarkable White House meeting
  • Local News

Trump Applauds ‘Rational’ Mamdani in Unprecedented White House Gathering

(The Hill) – In a surprising turn of events, President Trump extended…
  • NewsFinale Journal
  • November 22, 2025
Second person found guilty of murder in fatal Walterboro Waffle House shooting
  • Local News

Second Individual Convicted in Deadly Walterboro Waffle House Shooting

WALTERBORO, S.C. — In a tragic incident at a Walterboro Waffle House…
  • NewsFinale Journal
  • November 21, 2025
Trump says he's terminating legal protections for Somali migrants in Minnesota
  • Local News

Trump Announces End to Legal Protections for Somali Immigrants in Minnesota

WASHINGTON – On Friday night, President Donald Trump announced the immediate cessation…
  • NewsFinale Journal
  • November 22, 2025
Man killed infant daughter and her mother on his birthday
  • Crime

Tragic Incident: Man Fatally Attacks Infant Daughter and Her Mother on His Birthday

Background: Brandon Isabelle appears in Shelby County court for his sentencing hearing…
  • NewsFinale Journal
  • November 22, 2025
Somerville House is a 126-year-old school in South Brisbane.
  • AU

Education Minister Criticizes Elite School for Leaked Student Document Scandal

Education Minister Jason Clare has expressed disappointment over a prominent…
  • NewsFinale Journal
  • November 22, 2025
Marjorie Taylor Greene resigns from Congress
  • US

Marjorie Taylor Greene Steps Down from Congressional Role: What’s Next?

Marjorie Taylor Greene has announced her intention to step down from her…
  • NewsFinale Journal
  • November 22, 2025
NewsFinale Journal
  • Home
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Sitemap
  • DMCA
  • Advertise Here
  • Donate
Go to mobile version