Lingering questions after arson ruled out in devastating fire at judge's waterfront mansion
Share and Follow


NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles!

South Carolina authorities are stepping back from arson as a potential cause for the fire at the waterfront home of a longtime judge and her Vietnam War hero husband after a preliminary investigation — but questions remain about the cause of the blaze that leveled their million-dollar home in Edisto Beach.

Judge Diane Schafer Goodstein, 69, was out walking her dogs when the house went up in flames Saturday, according to the Post and Courier. Her husband, 81-year-old former state lawmaker Arnold Goodstein, reportedly suffered broken legs after jumping out a window to escape the heat. Their son and grandson were also injured.

“At this time, there is no evidence to indicate the fire was intentionally set,” Mark Keel, chief of South Carolina’s State Law Enforcement Division (SLED), said Monday night. “SLED agents have preliminarily found there is no evidence to support a pre-fire explosion.”

Investigators were still looking into the cause of the fire, however.

Three people were hospitalized, and Arnold Goodstein reportedly broke both legs after jumping out of a backyard window. Details about the injuries of two more victims, believed to be other family members, remain unclear.

According to Rep. Nancy Mace, R-S.C., the blaze also killed the family’s pets.

What evidence has been collected?

Fire marshals have likely already evaluated what remains of the burned-out structure as they searched for signs of its origin and potential accelerants, according to Fire Administration guidelines. The full investigation, which may include forensic testing of materials recovered from the scene, could take up to several months.

Bystanders also took video from the air and water nearby, which may or may not have evidentiary value.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Portnoy unleashes on Ross for coaxing NFL star into antisemitic dance

Portnoy Criticizes Ross for Encouraging NFL Star’s Controversial Antisemitic Dance

Dave Portnoy recently criticized online influencer Adin Ross following an intense exchange…
Poland scrambles jets on Christmas after detecting Russian reconnaissance aircraft near its airspace

Poland Mobilizes Fighter Jets on Christmas Day in Response to Russian Aircraft Near Airspace

On Thursday, Poland launched fighter jets in response to the detection of…
Florida man Jason Kenney kills wife Crystal Kenney, self, shoots stepdaughter over 49ers game argument

Florida Resident Jason Kenney Fatally Shoots Wife Crystal Kenney and Injures Stepdaughter in Dispute Over 49ers Game, Before Turning Gun on Himself

An unsettling incident unfolded in Florida when a man fatally shot his…
New laws going into effect Jan. 1, 2026

Groundbreaking Laws Set to Transform Lives: What You Need to Know Before January 1, 2026

In 2026, a wave of new legislation will sweep across the United…
Trump says US struck Islamic State targets in Nigeria after group targeted Christians

US Launches Strikes on ISIS in Nigeria Following Attacks on Christian Communities, Announces Trump

President Donald Trump has announced the execution of a “powerful and deadly…
Pelosis, Kennedys and other powerful families run for office in 2026

Political Dynasties Reignite: Pelosis and Kennedys Lead the Charge in 2026 Elections

The next generation of America’s influential political families is stepping into the…
The 2-hour 'Stranger Things' finale will be in theaters on New Year's. Here's how to get tickets.

Countdown to the ‘Stranger Things’ Finale: Release Date & Streaming Details Revealed!

The eagerly anticipated second batch of episodes from the final season of…
Florida man kills wife, shoots stepdaughter and himself after argument

Tragic Florida Incident: Man Fatally Shoots Wife, Injures Stepdaughter, and Takes Own Life After Domestic Dispute

A family in Florida experienced unspeakable tragedy when an argument over a…