Jack Smith feels muzzled by Judge Cannon on Mar-a-Lago
Share and Follow

Left: Special Counsel Jack Smith (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite, File). Center: Aileen M. Cannon speaks remotely during a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing (U.S. Senate). Right: Donald Trump speaks with supporters at the Westside Conservative Breakfast, June 1, 2023, in Des Moines, Iowa (AP Photo/Charlie Neibergall, File).

Once more, former special counsel Jack Smith has reached out to Congress, expressing his willingness to openly defend his legal actions against President Donald Trump. However, there are uncertainties surrounding what he can reveal about the Mar-a-Lago classified documents case, as U.S. District Judge Aileen Cannon has yet to make the investigation’s report public.

On Thursday, Smith addressed a letter to House Judiciary Committee Chairman Jim Jordan, R-Ohio, and Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa. The letter indicates Smith’s readiness to address and rectify “many mischaracterizations” concerning his investigations into the January 6 incident and the Mar-a-Lago affair involving Trump, suggesting this be done in “open hearings.”

In a recent discussion, Smith refuted claims from the president and his supporters, labeling accusations that he targeted Trump for political motives as “absolutely ludicrous.”

Regarding the Mar-a-Lago investigation, which was notably dismissed by Judge Cannon due to her ruling that Smith’s appointment was unlawful, Smith stated they had substantial evidence indicating that Trump deliberately kept classified documents and hindered their retrieval by the government.

Smith elaborated, “There was obstructive evidence, like publicly claiming ownership of the documents or similar statements, asserting a right to retain them. Evidence of refusing to return the documents, even when the government sought their return before launching a criminal probe, supports proving willfulness.”

Whether Smith can say more than that, according to his Covington & Burling lawyers, remains to be seen, because that the last thing they want is for him to be “punished.”

“He is prepared to answer questions about the Special Counsel’s investigation and prosecution, but requires assurance from the Department of Justice that he will not be punished for doing so,” the letter said. “To that end, Mr. Smith needs guidance from the Department of Justice regarding federal grand jury secrecy requirements and authorization on the matters he may speak to regarding, among other things, Volume II of the Final Report of the Special Counsel, which is not publicly available.”

As Law&Crime has reported, Cannon, a Trump appointee, issued an injunction in January that blocked the release of Volume II, given that Trump’s former co-defendants, valet Waltine Nauta and Mar-a-Lago property manager Carlos de Oliveira, still had pending appeals.

Although those appeals in those scuttled cases were dismissed at the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in February, the injunction remains in place to the present day, despite repeat efforts by intervening groups — the Knight First Amendment Institute and American Oversight — to undo the block.

Multiple reminders about the groups’ attempted interventions have not moved Cannon to act. That inaction led another federal judge to reject the New York Times’ Freedom of Information Act lawsuit to obtain Volume II.

Most recently, both the Knight Institute and American Oversight sought writs of mandamus at the 11th Circuit in late September, asking the appellate court to force Cannon to rule on whether or not to lift the injunction, to at least open the door to an expedited appeal.

The Knight Institute supported its arguments by calling Cannon’s “six-month delay” — and counting — “manifestly unreasonable” and an affront to its “constitutional right of access to judicial records” that the public has a right to know about, given that Smith’s Mar-a-Lago report “addresses allegations of grave criminal conduct by the nation’s highest-ranking official.”

To date, the 11th Circuit has not acted either.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Mother Faces Charges After Allegedly Attempting to Drown Her Three Children: Police Report

Background: The home of the family whose three children were allegedly found…

Young Child on Life Support Following Severe Assault; Mother and Partner Detained

In a heart-wrenching case out of Texas, a mother and her boyfriend…

Indiana Dad Sentenced After Neglecting Diabetic Daughter’s Care, Leading to Tragic Outcome

An Evansville father has been sentenced to prison in a case that…

Shocking Twist: Teen Allegedly Assists Father in Disturbing Crime Scene Cover-Up

Inset: Jennifer Ruth Stuart (Clackamas County Sheriff”s Office’s). Background: Mount Hood National…

Trump-Appointed Judge Dismisses California Redistricting Lawsuit

Right: President Donald Trump points to a reporter to ask a question…

Police Report: Boy Alleges Stepfamily Allowed Stepbrother to Point Gun at Him

Background: The Allen County Jail in Fort Wayne, Ind. (Google Maps). Insets…

Corvette Driver Arrested for Allegedly Crashing into Vehicle at 135 MPH While Intoxicated, Police Report

Left inset: Natalie Pierre (GoFundMe). Right inset: Dale Drotar (Palm Beach County…

Father Accused of Brutal Attack Involving Screw Driven Into Stepdaughter’s Skull

A horrific incident unfolded in New York on Wednesday when a man…