Family matriarch dies day after rescue from remote island that saw family swim ashore to escape boat fire
Share and Follow

A tragic turn of events unfolded as a woman passed away a day following a daring rescue by the U.S. Coast Guard. She, along with two family members, had been stranded on an isolated island in Massachusetts, which they reached by swimming after a fire engulfed their boat, anchored in a cove overnight on Monday.

Cynthia Sullivan, aged 73, succumbed to her injuries on Thursday. Her passing was announced in a Facebook post by a family member on Friday, as reported by Boston 25 News. The incident left her family devastated.

Tragically, the family dog, who had bravely alerted Cynthia, her 72-year-old husband Patrick, and their 37-year-old son Tyler to the blaze while they were asleep on their 30-foot powerboat, The Third Wave, also perished in the fire.

Faced with a rapidly spreading fire, the Sullivan family made the perilous swim to Naushon Island, a small landmass situated about four miles from Martha’s Vineyard.

Despite suffering burns and other injuries, the family found refuge in a barn on the island. They remained there for over 24 hours until a stroke of luck occurred on Wednesday morning when their marine radio washed ashore, allowing Tyler to reach out for emergency assistance.

Coast Guard helicopter landing on island

The U.S. Coast Guard this week rescued a family of three who were stranded on a desolate Massachusetts island by helicopter after they were forced to swim there when their boat caught on fire, the agency said. (USCG)

“Mayday, mayday, mayday, our ship went down in Tarpaulin Cove,” Tyler is heard saying in a radio transmission to the Coast Guard. “Our ship burned while we were sleeping, and we barely escaped.”

A Coast Guard helicopter rescue crew soon arrived and airlifted the family to Cape Cod Hospital in Hyannis.

A family member had reported the Sullivans missing when they didn’t arrive home Tuesday and calls to their cellphones, which went down with the boat, went straight to voicemail.

Multiple agencies searched the area Tuesday night and early Wednesday, and were unable to get accurate pings from the family’s submerged phones until Tyler reached them on the recovered handheld radio, according to the Coast Guard.

Helicopter flying away from island

The Coast Guard airlifted the family to Cape Cod Hospital in Hyannis. (USCG)

In a Facebook post, Chris Sullivan memorialized his mother and provided updates on his father and “hero” brother. 

“She went in peace. We played her some John Mellencamp as she passed, he was her absolute favorite, she adored him,” Sullivan wrote. “This hurts more than anything I could have ever imagined, I am leaning on my close friends and family and my two young children. We will get through this together.

“My dad is awake and breathing on his own. My brother saved both of them, he was able to get them off the boat under extremely chaotic circumstances, he doesn’t want to be called a hero, but he is. Again, thank you for all the support, it means the world.” 

Martha's Vineyard aerial

The island is about four miles from Martha’s Vineyard.  (John Greim/LightRocket via Getty Images)

“Quick thinking and having quality equipment allowed the family to survive and call for help,” Scott Backholm, a search and rescue mission coordinator from Coast Guard Sector Southeastern New England, said in a statement. “Mariners are encouraged to pursue first aid training and ensure their vessels are outfitted with proper safety equipment.”

The Sullivans had left nearby Falmouth, Massachusetts, last Friday and had planned to return Tuesday afternoon.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Gisele Bundchen weds Joaquim Valente 3 years after Tom Brady divorce

Supermodel Gisele Bundchen Ties the Knot with Joaquim Valente, 3 Years Post Tom Brady Split

Gisele Bündchen has embarked on a new chapter in her life, celebrating…
Conan O'Brien 'stopped party guests from calling 911' on Nick Reiner

Conan O’Brien Prevents Guests from Dialing 911 in Incident Involving Nick Reiner

Conan O’Brien found himself in the middle of a tense situation during…
Ryan Lochte's divorce from Kayla Rae Reid takes another messy turn

Ryan Lochte and Kayla Rae Reid’s Divorce Proceedings Encounter Further Complications

Ryan Lochte recently penned an emotional letter to address and clarify the…
President Donald Trump speaks during an executive order signing regarding marijuana in the Oval Office of the White House, Thursday, Dec. 18, 2025, in Washington. (AP Photo/Evan Vucci)

States Weigh Adoption of Trump’s Tax Cuts on Tips and Overtime: A Crucial Decision Ahead

As legislative sessions kick off next year, a pressing question looms over…
Pictured: Homeless hero 'John' who blew Brown University case open

Photograph: Meet ‘John,’ the Homeless Whistleblower Who Uncovered the Brown University Case

A homeless user on Reddit played a crucial role in helping police…
Justice Department faces Friday deadline to release Epstein files investigation

Countdown to Justice: DOJ’s Crucial Deadline to Unveil Epstein Investigation Files

The documents could potentially offer the most comprehensive insight yet into nearly…
Detransitioner Chloe Cole shares complications after gender procedures

Former Transgender Teen Chloe Cole Discusses Challenges Post-Gender Surgery

Chloe Cole, a young woman who has experienced the contentious world of…
DOJ accused of censoring Epstein files as full documents are redacted

Controversy Erupts Over DOJ’s Heavily Redacted Epstein Documents

The Department of Justice is facing backlash after heavily redacting documents from…