ICE has been 'unlawful' in its immigration arrests: Judge
Share and Follow

FILE – Law officials spread out through an apartment complex during a raid, Feb. 5, 2025, in east Denver (AP Photo/David Zalubowski, File).

A federal judge has determined that Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officers have been conducting arrests of suspected undocumented immigrants in Colorado in a manner that is “unlawful.”

In a comprehensive 66-page ruling delivered on Tuesday, U.S. District Judge R. Brooke Jackson criticized ICE for executing warrantless arrests without probable cause to believe the individuals posed a flight risk. The decision was in favor of four individuals, who, although found to be in the U.S. illegally, maintain “deep and longstanding ties to their communities.”

Judge Jackson stated, “No reasonable officer could have reasonably concluded that these plaintiffs were likely to flee before a warrant could be obtained.” He further noted, “Yet ICE nonetheless arrested each one immediately and detained them for significant periods, causing severe hardship and loss.”

Appointed by former President Barack Obama, Judge Jackson emphasized, “Mere presence within the United States in violation of United States immigration law is not, by itself, sufficient to conclude that a person is likely to escape before a warrant for arrest can be obtained.”

The four individuals, represented by the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), initiated a lawsuit last month. They alleged that ICE agents in Colorado were “indiscriminately stopping and arresting people” based on racial profiling in an effort to meet increased enforcement demands set by the administration. The plaintiffs argued that the agency had no legal grounds to perform warrantless arrests or detain individuals without probable cause and evidence of a flight risk.

The Trump administration responded by noting that agents had indeed obtained warrants, just after the initial arrests. Jackson found this argument unavailing.

“Under the defendants’ reasoning, ICE could simply stop any suspected undocumented person, conduct a warrantless arrest with no probable cause of flight risk, and then bring the arrest within the color of law by issuing a warrant at the field office,” he wrote, finding that such a view violates the law.

Jackson ultimately sided with the plaintiffs that they have likely been harmed by ICE’s actions. “Although none of them presented a flight risk by any reasonable measure, they were each arrested and detained without warning, ultimately spending between approximately two weeks and three months in custody,” the judge wrote, finding that a preliminary injunction to stop the arrests without probable cause was warranted.

He pointed to the administration’s actions at large as evidence why such a decision is necessary.

“ICE has almost doubled its headcount in Colorado this year alone, is actively recruiting and hiring many more officers, and plans to open three additional detention centers in Colorado, nearly tripling its current capacity,” he wrote. “On this record, plaintiffs have shown that, without the requested injunction, there is likely to be a substantial increase in the number of warrantless arrests made without probable cause of flight risk.”

The judge also found that the plaintiffs can represent a class of all individuals who have been arrested since Jan. 20, the day the current Trump administration began, “or will be arrested in this District by ICE without a warrant and without a pre-arrest, individualized assessment of probable cause that the person poses a flight risk.”

The plaintiffs were also likely harmed because of the financial “burdens” placed on them due to the arrests and subsequent bonds they had to pay, Jackson found. Because of this, the administration has been ordered to repay them for their posted bonds.

Immigrant rights groups celebrated the judge’s decision, with the ACLU of Colorado writing that the court “confirmed what has been enshrined in federal law for decades: ICE cannot terrify our communities with their haphazard warrantless arrests.”

“A federal court has now declared that ICE must immediately stop these aggressive and unlawful tactics,” Tim Macdonald, ACLU of Colorado legal director, added.

The Department of Homeland Security (DHS), which oversees ICE, indicated that it would appeal the ruling.

“This activist ruling is a brazen effort to hamstring the Trump administration from fulfilling the President’s mandate to deport the worst of the worst criminal illegal aliens,” said the statement attributed to Tricia McLaughlin, DHS assistant secretary for public affairs, per Colorado Public Radio.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Father Relives Son’s Final Moments as Convicted Killer Receives Prison Sentence

Left: Jalen Garces (Norfolk police). Right: Ali Muhammad (Bilal Muhammad). A Virginia…

Tragic Gun Accident: Unsecured Firearm Claims Life of Toddler, Mother Faces Charges

Inset: Evelyn Etress (Blount County Sheriff”s Office). Background: Cops investigate after Etress’…

Outrage Erupts: Father Receives Lenient Sentence After Violent Attack on Fiancee and Infant

Inset: Avery Mapes (Lucas County Sheriff’s Office). The Ohio neighborhood where Avery…

Gainesville Resident Charged with Threatening Violence Against Woman and Dog

Staff Report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – In the early hours of today, authorities…

Ohio Dentist and Wife Found Murdered: Former Surgeon Arrested in Connection with Tragic Case

An Illinois resident is under arrest, facing serious accusations related to the…

Heartbreaking 911 Call: Child Hears Mother’s Tragic Murder in Real-Time

Left inset: Felipe Ayala (Springfield Police Department). Right inset: Suzette Flores (GoFundMe).…

Tragic Fallout: Innocent 12-Year-Old’s Life Lost in Senseless Social Media Feud Involving AR-15 and AK-47

Insets from left: Antawan Benson and Javen Conner (Montgomery County Prosecutor”s Office)…

Mother Receives Prison Sentence for Locking 11-Year-Old Son to Fuel Tank with Handcuffs for 17 Hours Over Dietary Dispute

Left: Chazzity Candelario with her children (Facebook). Center: Chazzity Candelario (Lebanon County…