LI teen killed ex in botched murder-suicide due to heartbreak: friend
Share and Follow

A tragic end to a young romance on Long Island has left a community in shock. A local teenager, whose identity remains undisclosed, took the life of his ex-girlfriend, Emily Finn, in a failed murder-suicide attempt, a situation described by a family friend as the result of a broken heart.

Emily, 18, had just begun her college journey, while her former boyfriend was preparing to enlist in the military. Faced with diverging paths, the couple decided to end their youthful relationship, according to the family friend, who spoke to The Post.

“It was a case of young, naive love that simply couldn’t last,” said the friend, who has known the alleged perpetrator since he was a child. “These teenage relationships often don’t endure, and this one was no different.”

Expressing bewilderment over the tragic turn of events, the friend added, “I can’t fathom what pushed him to such an extreme decision.”

Addressing public speculation, the friend firmly stated, “People online are suggesting she provoked him somehow, but that’s simply not true.”

Now, the teen is spending his 18th birthday and Thanksgiving in a hospital bed, recovering from a gunshot wound to the face and awaiting murder charges.

He allegedly gunned down Finn inside his Nesconset home around 11:10 a.m. on Wednesday, Suffolk County Police said.

Finn was reportedly returning some of the boy’s belongings to him following their recent breakup — a heartbreak he was not equipped to handle.

“The frontal lobe is still undeveloped and not equipped to handle and process these emotions. I went through breakups when I was younger and they’re awful but I never contemplated doing anything like this,” the friend said, adding that he was “disgusted” by the boy’s actions.

“That’s ultimately what this was. The inability of a young kid to process this. It feels like the world is coming to an end.”

The teen purportedly had shown no signs of violence leading up to the murder.

“His parents are very, very, very angry. It’s not a situation of, ‘My kid, my kid., No they’re holding him accountable,” the friend said, adding that they haven’t been inside the house since the tragedy: “They can’t come home. How would you be able to walk back into that house?” 

“Emily is dead. Her family is destroyed. These people lost their lives in an instant.” 

Finn’s grieving family declined to speak when approached by The Post Thursday, but an online fundraiser launched in the wake of her death described her as “a true treasure of a girl.”

“To know Emily is to love her, as she became part of the fabric of the lives she touched in her generous and kind way. Through her many years as a dancer, the children she taught as she prepared for a future as a teacher, and simply as a friend to so many, she will be sorely missed by all who knew her,” the fundraiser read.

Police have not yet publicly identified the alleged killer, but said he will be charged with second-degree murder and arraigned at a later date.

The full extent of his injuries was not clear, but authorities listed him in critical but stable condition.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Nathan Chasing Horse, right, talks to his attorney Craig Mueller during his trial on charges of sexually abusing Indigenous women and girls Tuesday, Jan. 13, 2026, in Las Vegas. (AP Photo/Ty ONeil)

Trial Date Approaches for ‘Dances with Wolves’ Actor Nathan Chasing Horse in Child Sexual Abuse Case

The trial of Nathan Chasing Horse, known for his role in “Dances…
LA protesters swarm U-Haul truck that drove through anti-Iranian regime gathering

Chaotic Scene in LA: U-Haul Truck Plows Through Protesters at Anti-Iranian Regime Rally, Driver Detained

The driver of a U-Haul truck that plowed through a crowd of…
'We do not support this': Fruit Cove neighbors protest Daily's gas station proposal

Fruit Cove Residents Rally Against Proposed Daily’s Gas Station: Community Voices Concerns

Residents of Fruit Cove are raising concerns over a proposed Daily’s gas…
Mississippi synagogue arson suspect's dad turns him in after laughing confession, FBI says

Father Reports Son to Authorities Following Alleged Confession to Mississippi Synagogue Arson, FBI Reveals

An individual accused of igniting a blaze at a Mississippi synagogue, previously…
Jacksonville man charged with attempted murder after shootout with covert officers in Brentwood

Jacksonville Resident Faces Attempted Murder Charges Following Brentwood Shootout with Undercover Officers

A man has been charged with several offenses following a gunfight with…
Trump admin exit from UN, international organizations raises question of who’s next

Trump Administration’s Withdrawal from UN and Global Bodies Sparks Speculation on Future Departures

In the wake of the Trump administration’s move to pull out from…
'Dilbert' cartoon creator Scott Adams dies at 68

Beloved ‘Dilbert’ Creator Scott Adams Passes Away at 68: A Legacy of Laughter and Insight

Shelly Adams, the former spouse of Scott Adams, disclosed his passing during…
Bessent's desperate late-night call to Trump over economic 'mess'

Urgent Midnight Plea: Bessent Reaches Out to Trump Over Looming Economic Crisis

The ongoing Justice Department investigation into Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell prompted…